Top 10 Girls Order – If They Had Performed Tonight

Text voters are noticing they’re getting messages back, thanking them for voting for the girls. The switch was so last minute–Michael Lynche said the boys found out at about 10:30 PT–the producers either forgot, or didn’t have time to change the confirmation messages for the text votes.

The girls order for tonight would have been:

Game of Thrones Episode 2: The Lost...
Game of Thrones Episode 2: The Lost Lords Review

1. Crystal Bowersox
2. Haeley Vaughn
3. Lacey Brown
4. Katie Stevens
5. Didi Benami
6. Michelle Delamore
7. Lilly Scott
8. Katelyn Epperly
9. Paige Miles
10 Siobhan Magnus

The order could change, but I doubt if it will change drastically. Thanks @tawneej

About mj santilli 33696 Articles
Founder and editor of mjsbigblog.com, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!

20 Comments

  1. Interesting to see the little dark horses getting the pimp spots this week!

  2. Interesting. Siobhan in the pimp spot? Paige getting the almost guaranteed pass spot? Crystal getting the opener? They must really be sure of the strength of her fanbase. And look at them sticking Didi in the muddled middle? And Haeyley/Lacey inheriting no man’s land? Hmmm….

  3. They are trying to sabotage Haeley and put her at the front! Typical… someone gives an awesome creative performance and they try to get her off the show!

  4. Crystal has the best overall fanbase of the social networking sites. Strong numbers in all three of the social networking sites the show set-up. She’s always top 3 in informal polls at the official Idol forums. IMO, it looks like they want to bury Haeley, and putting her second after Crystal is the most efficient way of doing it.

    Siobhan going last is definite dark horse confirmation, she’s probably the most versatile of the girls. She just has the off stage personality thing to overcome.

  5. If I could pick a song for Crystal… it would be “Zombie” by the Cranberries

  6. the producers either forgot, or didn’t have time to change the confirmation messages for the text votes.

    Personally, I think Idol is just trying to see if they can get Chris Sligh to crack and comment on the show on his first “Idol Free” day. This has to be killing him.

  7. Personally, I think Idol is just trying to see if they can get Chris Sligh to crack and comment on the show on his first “Idol Free” day. This has to be killing him.

    LOL! I think ya’ll have taken funny pills today, or maybe I have, because I’ve been LMAO at all of you today!

  8. Siobhan getting the pimp spot after performing tenth last week? This is definetly unusual, here’s hoping this means she has a showstopper kind of performance.

  9. Siobhan getting the pimp spot after performing tenth last week? This is definetly unusual, here’s hoping this means she has a showstopper kind of performance.

    Did Lee have a showstopper performance? Not really. So my hopes are not set too high. She will be good though.

  10. Did Lee have a showstopper performance? Not really. So my hopes are not set too high. She will be good though.

    The small difference is that Lee was fifth last week (not counting the 2 that went home) while Siobhan was eight among the remaining contestants.
    Idol is usually very strict about making contestant who went late in top 24 go early the next week. That’s why if they are really going out of their way for Siobhan it may mean that she has a killer performance.

    Of course the fact that I like her and above all that I’m desperatly waiting for a showstopping performance makes me a little biased.

  11. Looking at that line-up I’d say we’re pretty much assured the two going will come from 2-6, which is typical anyway. VFTW will have its hands full with Haeley in the 2 spot Really hoping they can’t pull her through this week. Though I fear they will succeed again.

    Appears Simon really wants Paige to stay. She’ll have to be super bad again to get voted off at #9. She did have to go 1st last week, though I think 1st is a lot better position than 2-5 to be in.

    Don’t forget to vote for Didi this week people!

    We already lost Janelle who was easily better than half these girls, though she admittedly picked totally the wrong song last week :(

  12. I can only hope they are trying to sabatoge Haeley because she does NOT deserve to be there! They let her in and she sucks big time! So now I hope they bury her and she leaves like she deserves to. No amount of charisma can nor should overcome a HORRIBLE singing voice.

  13. I don’t think Siobhan needs the pimp spot. I’d rather her sing late in the first hour. The talent is pretty thin this year so I doubt TPTB want to see her leave any time soon.

  14. Of course the fact that I like her and above all that I’m desperatly waiting for a showstopping performance makes me a little biased.

    She is my fav and I really want her to do good. But who knows…

  15. The lineup won;t change – it would mean that they would have to change the text message.. and its obvious that they seem to have lost the edit button.. so….

  16. I just got a text message that said: “Sorry! The American Idol confirmation U received last night contained the wrong contestant name. Each vote for Michael was received & confirmed.” I guess better late than never to correct the lineup! lol Wait, here comes another one!….

  17. I really hope Lacey does well this week. I hope Haeley goes home. She’s cute but she can’t sing.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.