Katharine McPhee – Here is the exact quote from the Dallas Morning News regarding Katharine’s song choice, “The theme should help sultry Katharine McPhee, who can draw inspiration as he sings “The Way You Look Tonight.” They never said she’d be singing “The Way You Look Tonight”, just that she’d be inspired by Rod’s version. I’d put that spoiler in the “wait and see” column.
Elliott Yamin – I’m hearing that Elliott Yamin’s first song choice was “It Had to Be You”. However, there was some confusion in Elliott’s camp about his song choice–which is why the early clues from his people pointed to a different song. Hee. Even the people close to the contestants have a tough time with these spoilers!