Corey Clark has lost the lawsuit he filed against MTV, according to Hollywood Reporter. The MTV reporter was Jim Cantiello.
Corey Clark, who was disqualified as a contestant on American Idol and later achieved notoriety for claiming to have had an affair with then-Idol judge Paula Abdul, has lost a $40 million defamation lawsuit against MTV and its parent company Viacom.
He sued in July 2012 over various statements published by an MTV reporter, mostly to the effect that he had been disqualified from the singing competition series after concealing from producers an arrest involving an alleged assault on his sister. In the lawsuit against MTV, he later was joined by ex-Idol contestant Jaered Andrews who was also unhappy with the characterizations of his own disqualification.
Unfortunately for both, neither of them have been able to survive the standards necessary to prevail on a defamation claim.
From the judges opinion, which you can read in full here.
U.S. District judge William Haynes writes in his opinion that these statements are “comments upon or characterizations of published facts,” and thus not actionable as libel. The Tennessee judge also points out that the characterizations were reported by other reputable news organizations including The Tennessean, the Boston Herald, Cleveland’s The Plain Dealer, the Chicago Sun-Times and People magazine.
As for Andrews, who objected to a report that he was “sent home over undisclosed assault charges,” the judge nods to the fact that he admitted he was in fact “charged with one misdemeanor account of ‘simple assault.'” As such, the judge says that the statement is true, and even if it is injurious to his reputation, it’s not actionable.
Clark attempted other legal avenues to punish MTV, but those have also failed.
Corey still has a pending lawsuit against E! Entertainment and FOX over statements made about his exit from the show and an alleged affair with Paula Abdul. He and Jaered are also a part of that other lawsuit several disqualified Idol contestants have filed against FOX that argues the number of disqualifications involving African Americans is part of a pattern of discrimination.