Brooke White and Justin Gaston Sing “If I Can Dream” on Wednesday’s Results Show

UPDATE: Brooke and Justin have both confirmed the appearance. Brooke, on her website HERE, and Justin on the If I Can Dream live feed early Sunday morning…

So who IS the Idol alum who will be performing an Elvis tune on Wednesday’s results show? Idol producers haven’t spilled YET, but astute Idol fans are picking up on the clues, which are everywhere.

Those clues point to Season 7 Idol Brooke White and If I Can Dream castmate Justin Gaston joining forces to sing Elvis Presley’s “If I Can Dream” on Wednesday’s results show.

The evidence:

  1. Justin tweets to Brooke, “Playing music with @realbrookewhite . Not the fake one. Party in the UK”  Brooke tweets back, “Playing music with @justinmgaston
  2. In episode 5 of  If I Can Dream, a producer tells Justin that he’ll be performing in front of a “massive audience” within the next few weeks, per Simon Fuller, but he doesn’t have the details yet.  (See video after the jump)
  3. In the preview for the upcoming episode of If I Can Dream, Justin is sitting at a piano, with a suspiciously Brooke White-like blond, plunking out the notes to “If I Can Dream” (See video after the the jump).

Fred Bronson, of @IdolsNow tweeted tonight, “COMING TOMORROW MORNING: Exclusive interview with Idol finalist who is returning Wed night to sing an Elvis song — and their duet partner.” (If you have an iPhone? make sure to download the app! It’s awesome.)

By the way, two summers ago, Justin was a contestant on Nashville Star. I happened to watch, and can tell you–he was terrible and was eliminated pretty quickly.  Nashville Star judge, Billy Ray Cyrus introduced Justin to his then-fifteen year-old daughter Miley, who began dating Justin, who was 20 at the time. Seriously…

Videos after the JUMP…

If I Can Dream: Justin Gaston Learns he has the chance to perform in front of a huge audience in the next 3 weeks, per Simon Fuller

Preview of the next If I Can Dream: Justin sings a duet with a suspiciously Brooke-like girl at the end of the promo

About mj santilli 34534 Articles
Founder and editor of, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!