American Idol 2025 Top 24 POLL Results and YOUR PREDICTIONS
American Idol 2025 will reveal the Top 20 in a three hour Easter worship themed special on Sunday April 20. In the meantime, here are the results for polls we posted after each show. The Top 24 aired in two parts across two nights. America’s vote will eliminate two singers from each night of performances.
American Idol 2025 Top 24 Polls: Vote for Night 1 Favs, Predict the Losers
American Idol 2025 Top 24 Polls: Vote for Night 2 Favs, Predict the Losers
It’s important to note that American Idol filmed the Top 20 reveal episode on Wednesday night! (April 16). But unlike the past few years, it’s Friday night (April 18) and there are NO SPOILERS. At least not yet. If we do get spoilers, the post will go up on the website. PLEASE DON’T DISCUSS SPOILERS ANYWHERE OUTSIDE OF THE SPOILER POST.
UPDATE: Reportedly, according to posters on IdolForms.com, Breanna Nix said in a live chat on TikTok that the contestants don’t know who was eliminated. A taping for Sunday’s episode took place on Wednesday and the show hasn’t announced Sunday is live. Folks are speculating that the Top 24 taped their performances for broadcast, but the Top 20 will be revealed live. Or maybe Brianna is fibbing to throw every one off!
LIVE American Idol 2025 season 23 episodes begin Monday April 21
And FYI: The LIVE SHOWS begin on Monday, April 21, as American Idol reveals the Top 14! “The Top 14 are revealed as the finalists return to the stage with powerful, emotional live performances from Hollywood.”
On Sunday, April 27 it’s Rock & Roll Hall of Fame night “With guidance from an award-winning guest mentor, the Top 14 take on iconic songs from Rock & Roll Hall of Fame legends as America votes live for the Top 12.
American Idol airs Sunday and Monday on ABC at 8 pm ET/PT streaming next day on HULU
American Idol 2025: Full Season 23 Schedule
American Idol 2025 Top 24 POLL Results!
American Idol 2025 Night 1: Which TWO Contestants Top 24 Contestants Will Be Eliminated?
You all predicted that Penny Samar and Baylee Littrell are heading home. Hm. Baylee has had a ton of screen time and he’s the son of Brian Littrell of of Backstreet Boys. He’s likely sticking around, at least for now. Penny is a good bet. But while Zaylie’s performances have been uneven, the judges love her and she’s had a ton of screen time….
- Penny Samar – 19.53%
- Baylee Littrell – 15.95%
- Zaylie Windsor – 14.74%
- MKY – 11.56%
- CHÉ Chesterman – 9.80%
- Victor Solomon – 9.25%
- Isaiah Misailegalu – 4.13%
- Kolbi Jordan – 3.88%
- Slater Nalley – 3.07%
- Jamal Roberts – 2.85%
- Gabby Samone – 2.71%
- Breanna Nix – 2.52%
American Idol 2025 Night 2: Which TWO Top 24 Contestants Will Be Eliminated?
Kyana Fanene has had so little screen time, that her leaving the competition on Sunday would not be surprising. However, it would be a shame, because her performances are all pretty great. Grayson Torrence suffers from both lack of screentime, and uneven performances. Her elimination seems reasonable.
- Kyana Fanene – 18.24%
- Grayson Torrence – 14.94%
- Desmond Roberts – 13.65%
- Olivier Bergeron – 12.24%
- Josh King – 10.59%
- Filo – 8.35%
- John Foster – 5.06%
- Mattie Pruitt – 4.82%
- Canaan James Hill – 4.35%
- Amanda Barise – 3.65%
- Drew Ryn – 2.24%
- Thunderstorm Artis – 1.88%
American Idol 2025 Night 1: Vote for Your FAVORITE Top 24 Performance
Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts lead the pack, with Slater Nally and Gabby Samone right behind them. The remaining singer rate in single digits and are not statistically significant.
- Breanna Nix – Still Rolling Stones by Lauren Daigle – 23.10%
- Jamal Roberts – Liar by Jelly Roll – 22.87%
- Slater Nalley – Over the Rainbow by Judy Garland – 16.40%
- Gabby Samone – It’s All Coming Back To Me Now by Celine Dion – 10.91%
- Baylee Littrell – Happy by Pharrell Williams – 4.44%
- MKY – Adorn by Miguel – 4.06%
- Zaylie Windsor – Heart of Glass by Blondie – 3.99%
- Kolbi Jordan – New Attitude by Patti Labelle – 3.16%
- CHÉ Chesterman – Master Blaster (Jammin’) by Stevie Wonder -3.16%
- Isaiah Misailegalu – You Can Have It All by Maoli – 2.93%
- Victor Solomon – That’s My Kind Of Night by Luke Bryan – 2.71%
- Penny Samar – Good Luck, Babe! by Chappell Roan – 2.26
American Idol 2025 Night 2: Vote for Your FAVORITE Top 24 Performance
Thunderstorm Artis takes the No 1 position with over 30% of the vote. Back in 2020 when Thunderstorm competed on The Voice, I predicted he would win! (He finished in third place). He’s a front runner AGAIN on American Idol. Can he finally pull off a win?
- Thunderstorm Artis – Is This Love? by Bob Marley & The Wailers – 30.48%
- John Foster – Callin’ Baton Rouge by The Oak Ridge Boys/Garth Brooks – 12.70%
- Drew Ryn – I’m With You by Avril Lavigne – 11.32%
- Kyana Fanene – I Am by Stan Walker – 9.24%
- Olivier Bergeron – I Am Not Okay by Jelly Roll – 8.08%
- Amanda Barise – Defying Gravity by Idina Menzel & Kristin Chenoweth – 7.16%
- Mattie Pruitt – Wide Awake by Katy Perry – 5.77%
- Josh King – I’m Still Standing by Elton John – 3.70%
- Grayson Torrence – Ceilings by Lizzy McAlpine – 3.70%
- Filo Ebid – Who’s Lovin’ You? by Smokey Robinson & The Miracles/The Jackson 5 – 3.70%
- Canaan James Hill – Glory To Glory To Glory by Fred Hammond & Radical For Christ – 2.77%
- Desmond Roberts – Do I Do? by Stevie Wonder -1.39%
