American Idol 2024 Top 24 POLL Results – Did Fans Get it Right?

American Idol 2024 Top 24
(Disney/Eric McCandless) KATY PERRY, STITCH, LUKE BRYAN, LIONEL RICHIE, RYAN SEACREST

American Idol 2024 Top 24 POLL Results and YOUR PREDICTIONS

American Idol 2024 will reveal the Top 20 in a three hour mega-show on Sunday April 14! In the meantime, here are the results for polls we posted after each show. The Top 24 aired in two parts across two nights. America’s vote will eliminate two singers from each night of performances.

American Idol 2024 Top 24 Polls: Vote for Night 1 Favs, Predict the Losers
American Idol 2024 Top 24 Polls: Vote for Night 2 Favs, Predict the Losers

It’s important to note that American Idol filmed the Top 20 reveal episode on Wednesday night! (April 10). SPOILERS ARE OUT THERE! At this point, the polls are about comparing YOUR predictions to the actual results. PLEASE DON’T SPOIL THE RESULTS IN THE COMMENTS UNDERNEATH THIS POST! Be considerate to fellow fans who do NOT want to be spoiled.

However, a Spoiler post will be going up soon, where y’all can discuss how prescient you were…or not! (Click the link below)

American Idol 2024 Spoilers: Season 22 Top 20 Contestants Leaked!

Lauren Spencer-Smith returns to American Idol

Sunday’s show will feature the triumphant return of Season 18 Top 24 contestant Lauren Spencer Smith! Unfortunately for her, she competed on the 2020 season, in which COVID-19 restrictions severely impacted productions. The Top 20 were forced to scatter to far flung homes, where they filmed performances on specially configured iPhones. As a native of Canada, perhaps Lauren couldn’t garner a big enough fan base. But nevertheless, after competing on the show, she signed a major label deal with Island/Republic records and became a social media star and hitmaker. Her smash songs “Fingers Crossed” and “Flowers” have garnered millions and millions of streams.

American Idol Scandal? Kennedy Reid Accused of Having Affair with Boss

Paul Russell and the soulful singer singing show competitors LOVE to cover, Teddy Swims, will also perform.

LIVE American Idol 2024 episodes begin Monday April 15

And FYI: The LIVE SHOWS begin on Monday, as American Idol reveals the Top 14! Each of the Top 20 contestants will take the stage again, whether it’s a victory song for making the Top 10. or competing for one of FOUR wildcards. America will VOTE again to determine the Top 10.

American Idol Top 24 POLL Results!

American Idol 2024 Night 1: Which TWO Contestants Top 24 Contestants Will Be Eliminated?

You all predicted that former NFL player Blake Proehl and The Voice alum Hailey Mia are heading home from Night 1. Only Aussie Jordan Anthony garnered more than 10 percent of the vote.

  1. Blake Proehl – 31.80%
  2. Hailey Mia – 21.02%
  3. Jordan Anthony – 10.64%
  4. Nya – 9.13%
  5. Jayna Elise Brown – 6.57%
  6. Quintavious Johnson – 6.37%
  7. K.B. Richins – 3.88%
  8. Kayko – 3.15%
  9. Will Moseley – 2.50%
  10. Julia Gagnon – 2.10%
  11. Abi Carter – 1.71%
  12. McKenna Breinholt – 1.12%

American Idol 2024 Night 2: Which TWO Top 24 Contestants Will Be Eliminated?

You all predicted quirky R&B singer KBlocks and singer-songwriter Elleigh Marie will be hitting the road from night 2. No other contestant garnered more the 10% of the vote.

  1. KBlocks – 36.24%
  2. Elleigh Marie – 26.03%
  3. Odell Bunton, Jr. – 9.23%
  4. Kennedy Reid – 6.67%
  5. Jennifer Jeffries – 5.44%
  6. Jack Blocker – 3.29%
  7. Roman Collins – 3.21%
  8. Ajii – 2.64%
  9. Mackenzie Sol – 2.47%
  10. Triston Harper – 1.73%
  11. Emmy Russell – 1.73%
  12. Mia Matthews – 1.32%

American Idol 2024 Night 1: Vote for Your FAVORITE Top 24 Performance

Abi Carter, Will Mosley, Kayko and McKenna Breinholt were favorites from night 1. None of the four received an overwhelming number of votes.

  1. Abi Carter – Oceans (Where Feet May Fail) by Hillsong United – 21.24%
  2. Will Moseley – (Sittin’ On) The Dock Of The Bay by Otis Redding – 18.57%
  3. Kayko – How To Live Without You (original song) – 14.44%
  4. McKenna Breinholt – The Story by Brandi Carlile – 13.83%
  5. KB Richins – Heaven by Bryan Adams – 7.16%
  6. Quintavious – Something In The Water by Carrie Underwood – 5.70%
  7. Nya – (Simply) The Best by Bonnie Tyler/Tina Turner – 4.61%
  8. Julia Gagnon – Rumour Has It by Adele – 4.61%
  9. Jayna Elise – Confident by Demi Lovato – 4.00%
  10. Blake Proehl – Anyone by Justin Bieber – 1.94%
  11. Jordan Anthony – Titanium by David Guetta & Sia – 1.94%
  12. Hailey Mia – She’s All I Wanna Be by Tate McRae – 1.94%

American Idol 2024 Night 2: Vote for Your FAVORITE Top 24 Performance

The Voice alum Mia Matthews, Jack Blocker, Loretta Lynn granddaughter Emmy Russell and Triston Harper are your favorites from night 2. Again, no contestant garnered an overwhelming number of votes.

  1. Mia Matthews – Daddy’s Hands by Holly Dunn – 20.45%
  2. Jack Blocker – Rainbow by Kacey Musgraves – 15.96%
  3. Emmy Russell – Beautiful Things by Benson Boone – 14.71%
  4. Triston Harper – “God’s Country” by Blake Shelton – 14.46%
  5. Mackenzie Sol – Jealous by Nick Jonas – 9.35%
  6. Ajii – Higher by Tems – 7.48%
  7. Roman Collins – How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved By You) by Marvin Gaye – 5.36%
  8. Jennifer Jeffries – Bruises by Lewis Capaldi – 3.74%
  9. Kennedy Reid – Fancy by Bobbie Gentry/Reba McEntire – 3.49%
  10. Odell Bunton, Jr. – Uptown Funk by Mark Ronson & Bruno Mars – 2.49%
  11. Elleigh Marie – Forget You! by Cee-Lo Green – 1.62%
  12. KBlocks – Harleys In Hawaii by Katy Perry – 0.87%

American Idol 2024: Tori Kelly Night 1 Mentor Yay or Nay?

Tori’s advice to the contestants was more technical, which arguably made her the best of the two mentors. However, Jelly also gave good advice and his personality is warmer. So, I get why his Nay grabbed a higher percentage.

  • YAY! – 72.86%
  • Nay – 27.14%

American Idol 2024: Jelly Roll Night 2 Mentor Yay or Nay?

  • YAY! – 89.60%
  • Nay – 10.40%
About mj santilli 34980 Articles
Founder and editor of mjsbigblog.com, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!