American Idol 10 Top 12 – Who Will Go Home Tonight?

Who do you think is going home tonight on American Idol?

I think it will be a an all female Top 3 once again, with Karen Rodriguez, Haley Reihnhart and either Thia Megia or Naima Adedapo taking the 3rd spot.

If a guy manages to squeeze in there at all, it will be Paul McDonald who seems to have lost his way on the Idol stage, bad cold notwithstanding.

Who am I picking for the pool? Karen Rodriguez. She was utterly forgettable last night, and I don’t think she’s got the fan base to sustain her. Haley and Thia both have people, and I think Naima may be developing a little fan base of her own.

However, although, Naima triumphed last week, a lot can change in 7 days. If she were eliminated it would not be a shocker.

In any case the contestant going home tonight WILL be a girl. I’m taking part in a pundit pool over at Zap2it. Take a look at it here. The votes are split between Karen, Haley and Naima.

Also, play our Idol pool HERE. Remember, you can make your picks up until 8 pm ET today.

Who do you think is going home?

About mj santilli 34544 Articles
Founder and editor of, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!