X Factor

X Factor 1 Premiere – Recap Roundup

‘The X Factor’ premiere review: Simon Cowell and his shocking, brief sincerity

This U.S. edition of the British hit features auditions, to be followed by mentoring, to be followed by a $5 million prize. On the Wednesday-night, two-hour premiere, X showcased some fine performances, including those of Rachel Crow, Stacy Francis, and Melanie Amaro. Add one or two more depending on your taste (sorry, but to me Marcus Canty sounded like a nice fellow doing an impression of Al Green singing Stevie Wonder), and that’s not much talent to hold one’s interest over two hours.

EW.com

Ratings

Early Ratings: X Factor Short of Idolesque

Preliminary numbers are in for x Factor, and the results are good or bad, depending on how you look at it. The ratings were solid, but compared to Idol, the ratings fell short. X Factor came in third for the night, behind Criminal Minds and Modern Family.

UPDATE: X Factor won the demo in the 8 pm hour, came behind Modern Family in the 9 pm hour. Demo LOWER than The Voice premiere.

UPDATE: TVByTheNumbers tweeted that X Factor will actually come in 2nd behind Modern Family. We’ll have more info at noon.

X Factor

X Factor 1 Auditions – The Premiere! Recap and Videos

My verdict after the first episode of the X Factor? I’m underwhelmed. Simon Cowell’s new show is a lot like his summer show, America’s Got Talent, if you stripped out all the variety acts. X Factor is light on good singing and heavy on the drama. It’s a reality show first and foremost. Simon is on the search for pop stars he can mold and develop. Auto-tune makes good singing unnecessary. As an example, two acts from the last series of X Factor UK, Cher Lloyd and the boyband One Direction are doing well on the UK charts, but were dreadful singers on the show. Cher could barely sing in tune, and One Direction rarely attempted to sing harmonies, and exhibited weak vocals.

Live blog and Videos inside.