AI S9 Recaps

Rolling Stone night produced no major trainwrecks.  Well there was that WTF moment when Tim Urban turned the sinister “Under My Thumb” into a Jimmy Buffett jam–but no major disasters.  Instead, it was mostly good

Katelyn Epperly, Todrick Hall, Alex Lambert and Lilly Scott ELIMINATED! I don’t now what’s going on, peeps, but tonight’s eliminations were totally WACK.  I knew the iconoclastic Lilly Scott was going to have trouble further

For the first time, the boys were better than the girls. They weren’t spectacular, but there were fewer WTF moments, and a genuine moment, from Michael Lynche.  Generally, the guys did a better job of

UPDATE: Paige Miles is the new female Vote For the Worst pick. Whoa. Isn’t this the night everyone is supposed to be bringing their A game? What the hell happened? Crystal Bowersox, in typical fashion,

The right people went home tonight, except for John Parks, whose sing-out was way looser and more emotional than Tuesday night. A week or two more, and he might have come into his own. He’s

CRYSTAL BOWERSOX WILL BE PERFORMING TONIGHT. Per a tweet from Ryan Seacrest. Per the leaked performance order, she was set to go first. Crystal Bowersox will perform first tonight. She tells Ryan, “I’m a tough

The judges were harder on Andrew Garcia and Casey Jones than I thought they deserved, and Lee Dewyze and Alex Lambert could do great things if they could only get over their nerves.  Not a

Eliminated: Janell Wheeler, Ashley Rodriguez, Joe Munoz, Tyler Grady. Tyler was a little upset after his elimination. He had a few pointed comments for the judges. “I didn’t get much constructive criticism during Hollywood week,

UPDATE: Tim Urban is the Vote For the Worst pick. Pretty dire night:  The best were Andrew Garcia, Casey James and Lee Dewyze.  Todrick Hall, Jermaine Sellers and Joe Munoz are in danger of going

‘American Idol’ Top 12 Females Take Stage For First Performance Night After endless weeks of prep, “American Idol” finally went live Tuesday (February 23), offering fans of the show the first look at the top