American Idol 9 Top 9 – Who is Going Home?

So, what do you think peeps? Who is going home?  Here’s what I think:

Katie Stevens turned in her best performance to date last night. Did her heartfelt performance of “Let it Be” save her? Or did her fans get complacent and stop voting?

Tim Urban turned in his best performance to date last night. Did he disappoint the fans who enjoyed the WTF? abandon him? Did VFTW vote as hard as ever? Did Tim pick up new fans last night? Or, has his time finally run out?

Aaron Kelly turned in arguably the worst performance last night. Will his poor performance and early performance slot put him in danger? Or will his fanbase vote hard to save him?

Andrew Garcia reverted back to ho-hum last night, after last week’s mini-triumph with the judges. Is his fanbase still large enough to save him? Or are his fans abandoning him for contestants like Lee DeWyze and Casey James who are pulling out of the pack?

These four are in the most danger this week. But, if I have to pick who is going home…I’m going for Andrew Garcia.  He was buried in the death spot last night–#3, the judges once again hated his performance, and the performance itself was unremarkable. I think it may finally be Andrew’s time to leave

Katie Stevens benefited from the judges praise, picking up casual votes. Tim Urban is riding high, still on media buzz both positive and negatve.  Aaron Kelly has had some decent performances and a fanbase who will see him through a poor performance.

  • Read my recap of last night’s show at AOL Television HERE.

BONUS VIDEO: The Top 9 reveal their obsessions…

Video after the JUMP…

About mj santilli 35052 Articles
Founder and editor of, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!