American Idol 2019 Top 14 Voting: Poll Results, and Predictions

AMERICAN IDOL - "212 (Top 14)" - After the "American Idol" Top 20 tackled solo and celebrity duet performances, the judges narrowed down the field, revealing the Top 14 finalists. Now, they are handing over the reigns to America, who will vote to crown the next "American Idol." In this episode, the Top 14 contestants will perform on the iconic Idol stage for the first time, in hopes of winning over the hearts of viewers and being voted through to the next phase of the competition. The search for America's next superstar continues on The ABC Television Network, SUNDAY, APRIL 14 (8:00-10:01 p.m. EDT), streaming and on demand. (ABC/Eric McCandless) MADISON VANDENBURG

Tonight (April 15) the American Idol Top 14 will become a Top 10. Last night, viewers voted for the first time. Fans will be responsible for seven of the singers advancing to the next round. The judges–Lionel Richie, Katy Perry and Luke Bryan–will choose the remaining three.

American Idol 2019 Top 14 Polls: Vote For Your Favorites
American Idol 2019 Recap: Top 14 Performances (VIDEO)

Here are the results from last night’s polls. At the end, I will take a stab at predicting the four singers who will head home.

Favorite Top 14 Performance

Jeremiah, Madison, Lane and Kaci represent roughly 68% of the vote. The remaining singers scored in single digits. 

  1. Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon – We All Fall in Love Sometimes 21.64%
  2. Madison Vandenburg – Fallin’ 19.76%
  3. Laine Hardy – That’s Alright Mama 14.38%
  4. Laci Kaye Booth – I Miss You 11.83%
  5. Alejandro Aranda – One Dance 6.99%
  6. Uche – Finesse 5.38%
  7. Ashley Hess – Fix You 4.97%
  8. Walker Burroughs – Climb Every Mountain 4.44%
  9. Alyssa Raghu – She Used to Be Mine 2.96%
  10. Wade Cota – Trouble 2.28%
  11. Riley Thompson – Suds in a Bucket 2.15%
  12. Dimitrius Graham – Perfect 1.88%
  13. Evelyn Cormier – The Middle 0.81%
  14. Eddie Island – Benny and the Jets 0.53%

Who Will Be Eliminated? (Choose 4)

This is a tough one. There is a difference between WILL be and SHOULD be. And I usually do two polls don’t I? I apologize for this week’s polls being such a fail! If I were choosing who SHOULD be leaving, Eddie, Evelyn, Wade and Riley would get my votes. But considering the judges will choose three of the contestants, I’m almost certain Riley will be safe this week. She may not need the Wildcard–her socials are impressive. Also, it’s possible the judges will save Wade. They seem to really love him. 

  1. Eddie Island 23.67%
  2. Evelyn Cormier 20.73%
  3. Wade Cota 12.12%
  4. Riley Thompson 12.03%
  5. Dimitrius Graham 9.06%
  6. Alyssa Raghu 7.22%
  7. Walker Burroughs 5.34%
  8. Uche 3.32%
  9. Ashley Hess 2.67%
  10. Alejandro Aranda 1.49%
  11. Laine Hardy 0.74%
  12. Laci Kaye Booth 0.61%
  13. Madison Vandenburg 0.61%
  14. Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon 0.39%

Grade the Episode

B+ for last night’s episode.

  • B 45.14%
  • A 28%
  • C 21.14%
  • D 4.76%
  • F 0.95%

Facebook Reactions as of 2 pm (Thank you Mafs95 and Amy Beth):

Apparently, the Facebook is a decent predictor. Look at Riley there in 3rd place!

Madison – 25k
Laine – 17k
Riley – 10k
Alejandro – 9.8k
Jeremiah – 9.3k
Uche – 8.4k
Laci – 6.6k
Wade – 6.6k
Ashley – 4.6k
Alyssa – 3.9k
Walker – 3.6k
Evelyn – 3.1k
Dimitrius – 3.0k
Eddie – 2.6k

Prediction: When all is said and done, Evelyn Cormier, Eddie Island, Alyssa Raghu and Dimitrius Graham will be heading home tonight. If Walker, Ashley, Wade is in trouble, they could get a Wildcard.

About mj santilli 34835 Articles
Founder and editor of, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!