Guide to the Top 12 Guys

Tonight, the Top 12 guys sing for the first time. This is the point at which I think this damn dog and pony show really begins, and I could not be more excited.

What can I say. I’m an Idol junkie.

I’ve put together a schedule for the season here. And, my guide to the Top 12 guys begins after the jump. There will be one for the girls tomorrow. Enjoy!

*****

Chickezie Eze 22, Inglewood, CA – Auditioned in San Diego – Chickezie made it to Hollywood last year, but no farther. According to his bio, he began singing when he was 13 years old. Before auditioning for AI, he was a T.S.A. (Transportation Security Administration) screener and a cashier. He studied singing at Santa Monica College. His parents are Nigerian. His initial audition was impressive, but the producers didn’t feature him much during the Hollywood Rounds. However, if he continues to perform at the level of his audition in San Diego, (“All The Woman I Need” by Luther Vandross), he could sneak into the Top 12. Not that I can imagine TPTB wanting an urban adult contemporary artist making it very far in this competition.

Colton Berry 17, Staunton, VA – Auditioned in Charleston – Poor Colton. He’s had virtually no screen time–except when he was pitted against the affable Kyle Ensley as the final guy to get the nod for the Top 24. Appearing to be be the reason (even if it isn’t so) for someone’s demise is never a good thing. To add insult to injury, Nigel Lythgoe compared him to Boris Becker during a recent press conference and said, “I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t know if heà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ll have underdog appeal because he was the last one chosen; he might have the underdog appeal because he IS an underdog. For me he and Garrett are two quite shy quiet guys, both extremely talented…but this show requires more than that at the end of the day. It needs that charisma coming across and giving the audience a reason to get off their backsides and pick up the phone to vote for them.” Ouch! Unless Colton comes out of the box with a terrific performance, he’ll be swiftly dispatched. More on Colton: is a senior at Wilson Memorial High School. He began singing in church when he was 5 years old. Active in community theatre, he also mentors children in a music class at a local elementary school.

Danny Noriega 18, Azusa, CA – Auditioned in San Diego – Danny, like Chikezie, made it to Hollywood Season 6. He claims that “nerves and song choice” did him in last year. Danny has tremendous potential, but he hasn’t quite honed his performance style yet. Well, unless he thinks he’s got a future singing in drag clubs. He needs to dial it back a notch. And for that reason, he could be a contestant that you either love or hate. I wasn’t terribly impressed with his initial audition (“Proud Mary”) but warmed up to him a little more during the Hollywood rounds. I think Danny’s outgoing personality and vocal skills will more than likely propel him into the Top 12. More on Danny: He recently graduated from high school. In his spare time he likes to dance and make people laugh. He loves animals. Bonus: Danny singing “Chain of Fools” pre-Idol.

David Archuleta 17, Salt Lake City, UT – Auditioned in San Diego – According to David’s bio, he began singing at age 7, is currently a junior at Murray High School, performed with an a cappella choir group and plays the piano. What his official bio conveniently leaves out, is that he won “Junior Singer” on Star Search back in 2003. There is a ton of video of David performing posted on You Tube. So much, that Entertainment Weekly put them all together in a post called “The (Many) songs of David Archuleta”. Not only can you find his Star Search moment, but there’s video of young David performing at the piano, on a local TV show and weirdly, he belts out a version of “And I Am Telling You” in front of the American Idol Season One cast in what looks like an airport. It appears that David is the male version of the “pageant singer” trained by his parents from birth to compete and perform. The problem with pageant kids, is that they often sing like wind-up dolls, and have problems learning to sing as an adult rather than like an adult. David’s initial audition and Hollywood performances were pretty good, but nothing spectacular. In fact, listening to his youthful performances, he seems to have lost something–between his voice changing and the vocal chord paralysis he described as part of his back story. TPTB seem to be pushing hard for David. He’s a cute kid, has been playing the game for years and has talent. I’d be shocked if he didn’t make the Top 12.

David Cook 25, Tulsa, OK – Auditioned in Omaha – For some reason, the producers are pushing David as the next Chris Daughtry. If they keep that up, they’ll alienate the very fans they are trying to court with the comparisons. If there is one thing fan bases is hate, is comparisons to their favorite. I don’t really see it–except that David admitted to studying Chris’s audition to “get the competitive edge.” His initial auditioned featured a slowed up version of “Living on a Prayer”. He’s got an effortless raspy pop-rock sound, with good range. He acquitted himself well in Hollywood, singing “Everything I Do” and “Heaven” by Bryan Adams. David has gotten plenty of screen time. He’s definitely one of the pimped ones. Unless he falters during the semis, he’ll have no problem making it to the Top 12. More on David: He graduated from Central Missouri State University in 2006. He has been singing since he was in the 2nd grade and also plays the guitar. Cook was a member of two bands, Axium and MWK.

David Hernandez 24, Phoenix, AZ – Auditioned in San Diego – David wasn’t featured until the Hollywood rounds, where we finally saw him perform. He impressed with an acoustic-style performance of Stephen Stills’ “Love the One You’re With”. David has confidence and charisma. If he comes out of the gate with good performances he could give the other’s a run for their money for a spot on the Top 12. More on David: He has performed at Urban Network Events, à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Arizona Idolà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  and the Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Parade. He has been a member of the bands Tribà ©t and Straight Up. Bonus: You Tube video of David singing Boyz II Men’s “If I Ever Fall in Love Again”.

Garrett Haley 17, Elida, OH – Auditioned in San Diego – Garrett would be the perfect teen idol–if it were 1976. Interesting retro look aside, I’m curious to hear him sing, because out of this year’s cannon fodder, he’s the most obscure. Aside from never getting a chance to hear him sing, he was barely given any screen time during the audition and Hollywood Round. We didn’t even get a chance to see him meeting with the judges during the Top 24 reveal episode–just a shot of Garrett returning to the holding room with a smile on his face. For that reason, most folks are expecting an early dismissal for Garrett. Wouldn’t it be cool if he gave the performance of his life and then managed to survive to the Top 12? *crickets* More on Garrett: He’s a junior at Elida High School has performed in local talent shows and high school musicals. Not much more.

Jason Castro 20, Rowlett, TX – Auditioned in Dallas – Jason is another contestant whose singing talent is a mystery–unless you do a search for him online. Here’s some live acoustic footage of Jason performing Gnarles Barkley’s “Crazy” and Sublime’s “Santeria”. Nigel Lythgoe claims to be “destroyed and distraught” because Danger Mouse from Gnarles Barkley wouldn’t let them use “Crazy” in the broadcast of the show. What, that’s the only song he sang? Whatever. Jason’s long dreads make him pop visually, which may help him once he performs live. If he performs well, he could be a dark horse. More about Jason: He grew up playing drums and played in a band called Keeping Lions. Before auditioning for Idol, Jason was majoring in Construction Science at Texas A&M University. His family is from Columbia, South America.

Jason Yeager 28, Grand Prairie, TX – Auditioned in Dallas – According to his bio, Brandon currently resides in Branson, MO, began singing when he was 2 years old and was a member of a boy band called True This. He also plays guitar, piano and drums. In his americanidol.com intro video he admits that he doesn’t care how far he gets. So much for ambition. He also says that the Idol he identifies with most is Taylor Hicks, his favorite band ever is Journey, and he loves Sam Cooke and Michael McDonald. So maybe he’s got a big soulful voice? Who knows. He’s another contestant who will absolutely have to come out of the box swinging.

Luke Menard 29, Crawfordsville, IN – Auditioned in Omaha – We haven’t heard Luke sing yet either, but who cares? His soap-opera star good looks could be enough to keep him in the game for at least a little while. As it turns out you can hear Luke sing, thanks to the magic of You Tube. Luke was a member of a’capella group Chapter 6, you can watch them perform here, here and here. More about Luke: He earned a B.A. in Communications from Millikin University in Decatur, IL, and worked for a finance company in Chicago.   He began touring with Chapter 6 when he quit that job to pursue singing. His favorite performer is James Taylor. He also loves riding motorcycles.

Michael Johns 29, Los Angeles/Atlanta – Auditioned in San Diego – Originally from Australia, Michael moved to the US in 1998 to attend Abraham Baldwin Agriculture College in Tifton, GA, then moved to Buckhead, GA outside of Atlanta to pursue a music career. One of the semi-pros of this bunch, he had a major label contract with Maverick Records back in 2003. Back then, his name was Michael Lee, and his initial negotiations with Maverick included the band, Filmland, as the band’s frontman. When Maverick indicated interest in him as a solo artist, Michael ditched the band. Filmland claims that he tried to take their songs with him. Oh, the drama. A record was never released, and Michael faded back into obscurity, until he auditioned for Idol. Michael has had generous screen time. The producers have showcased his excellent initial audition (a growly and soulful “I’ve Been Loving You Too Long”) and two outstanding Hollywood performances: “Light My Fire” and “Bohemian Rhapsody.” Michael is talented, good looking, and the producers love him. He’s a contender.

Robbie Carrico 26, Melbourne, FL – Auditioned in Miami – Robbie spent his teen years pursuing boybandom. He was a member of a group called Boyz IV Girlz and even dated Britney Spears when the group opened for her on her European tour. Later, he was a member of the rock/Christian band, Missing Picket. Although he’s got all the accouterments of a rock singer (skull cap, long hair, rawk t-shirt), he performed “Simple Man” in his initial audition with the requisite boyband hands and a big-voiced pop sensibility. Robbie hasn’t made a big impact yet. I think the other rock singers, David Cook and Michael Johns have more buzz. If he ditches the rock shtick and sticks to pop, he could be a dark horse in the race.

Sources: TV Squad, Idol Chatter and americanidol.com.

 
  • claireb7tx

    Thanks MJ great info and insight….I have had very little time to look into any of these guys and I didn’t read spoilers, so this actually makes excited to see how they do.

    Too bad for the pimped ones because now they will have to really really impress me for my vote. I hate to be manipulated, especially by NL.

  • http://steve-o-meter.com steve-o-meter

    Jason Yaeger was a member of a boy band named “True This” ?????

    You are kidding, right? Please God! Tell me you are kidding!

  • http://kmantoniva.blogspot.com/ KristiVA

    Luke is a hottie!! As long as he doesn’t sound like William Hung, he’s getting my vote tonight! I want my eye candy for as long as possible!!! :wub_tb:

  • IGetCranked

    This group of guys is so much more interesting than last year. I’m very excited tonight! Not one time last year did I feel this way. I even quit watching til the finale. I don’t want any of them to go home though I wouldn’t mind cutting Jason’s hair off.

  • http://www.myspace.com/mignonette33 purplesmile

    Although heà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s got all the accouterments of a rock singer (skull cap, long hair, rawk t-shirt)…

    You forgot the wallet chain, mj. ;)

    Is it just me or does Michael Johns look a little bit like Pierce Brosnan?

    I’m really excited to finally hear Jason Castro (I like what I heard on his youtube clips)…maybe even a little bit more than I look forward to Luke’s performance. I also want to finally see what Garrett sounds like. I hope these guys blow us away.

  • bean99

    I always love guy nights on AI. Luke is really a cutie, hope he sounds as good as he looks. I really liked David H’s voice in Hollywood.

  • primeminister

    Ditto, bean99. Not too excited about the girls this year. I can’t even tell some of them apart yet.

  • Daughtry_AJ

    Here’s my early guesses at the 6 guys that will make it into the top 12, put in order of how likely I think they are to make it:

    1. Michael Johns
    2. David A.
    3. David C.
    4. Chickezie Eze (I actually think he has a pretty good shot at making top 12, depending on how good he does I think he’ll be fairly popular)
    5. David H.
    6. Luke Menard (I do think one of the five we haven’t really seen will sneak into top 12, and just basically by looking at their pictures I’m taking a stab it’ll be this guy)

    I don’t think Danny Noriega will make it, because I think he’s going to really falter in the semis, and I don’t think people actually will vote for another potential Sanjaya. Then again my feeling could be wrong and if he does do really well in the semis, he most likely will make top 12. Also of all the guys Garrett Haley and Colton Berry are the two I’d be willing to bet money on as the ones who for sure won’t make top 12, unless one of them just does spectacularly well which I doubt.

  • Ladybug

    Thanks for the prep work MJ! I appreciated reading it all in one place and well-stated.

    OK, I am with IGC above in thinking this is a FAR more interesting group of guys than last year’s mostly boring lot. KristiVA. I agree. I want Luke around for the eye appeal alone! If he can sing (and not turn into a puddle of nerves like Ace did) that is a bonus!

    And one can only hope that should Danny progress, he will appear in the future in full on drag singing a Cher song. Now THAT would be entertainment. (OK, and, well, suicide for him).

    Something about David Cook bothers me, but not sure what it is. Maybe the unfortunate hair and scaggy soul patch. Or those turn-off comparisons to Daughtry. Not sure. He does have a decent voice though.

    Waiting for the inner boy bander outed from our rough tough rocker boy Robbie tonight. One can only hope we see the outstretched open hand and an “oh girl” thrown into his performance.

    Let’s all hope Jason Castro can break the jinx of being a Texas Aggie. (‘Nuff said from this Texas Longhorn)

    Anyway. I am ready for da guyz tonight. The ladies tomorrow night…ehh, not so much other than hoping Carly will be a train wreck, but, of course, with her vast experience, that is not going to happen. Maybe Syesha will drive out in a Ford.

  • http://www.myspace.com/mignonette33 purplesmile
  • t2

    Heh — Danny Noriega thinks it’s “GQitful”….he cracks me up.

  • jokiebird

    Yay, competition! I’m finally interested. Thanks for compiling this.

    That pic of Colton Berry really creeps me out. A 17-year-old with a “come hither” pout. Eeeeeeewwwwwwwww.

  • maracaibo

    Thanks for that great recap of the Top 12 guys.

    I can’t wait to watch Michael Johns perform tonight. He’s awesome.
    Hope all of the guys chose great songs from the 60′s, although I am not very excited about theme weeks during the semifinals.
    It was much more fun to see the contestants pick their own songs. Oh well, we’ll see what happens. Go Michael!

  • tinawina

    I would be surprised if anyone but the pimped make it to the top 12, with this whole “theme” thing starting in the semi finals. I think it’s just a way for TPTB to stack the deck towards their favorites earlier. How much you want to bet that the non-chosen will get slammed on “song choice” tonight? LOL.

  • Little Boy Blue

    RE: Jason Yeager — He also says that the Idol he identifies with most is Taylor Hicks, his favorite band ever is Journey, and he loves Sam Cooke and Michael McDonald. So maybe heà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s got a big soulful voice

    ?

    This could mean 3 things for me ( all speculation of course ) : 1) He got through because of Paula and Randy’s votes; 2) He is on Simon Cowell’s hate list. ; 3) TPTB want him out as soon as possible.

  • JJ

    Damn, Luke can’t sing. Oh well, who the hell cares. He gets my vote.

    At least Michael Johns is hot and can sing.

    “Something about David Cook bothers me, but not sure what it is. ”

    I think its the forehead thats a mile high.

  • hapi

    Where did you hear Luke’s voice? Couldnt tell from his former group vids what he individually sounds like. Did I miss one? Want to hear.

  • jersey

    I really hope Luke can sing so that I can pretend that’s why I’m voting for him. :blush_tb:

  • http://www.myspace.com/mignonette33 purplesmile

    An alleged Jason Castro original song:

    A Song About Stars

    I am not sure that I like that song much but I think I am becoming quite the Jason Castro fan. Heh. I hope he does not disappoint his first time on the AI stage. But with a 60s theme, I am a little bit afraid… :s

    (Don’t worry, Luke…I still *heart* you! ;D)

  • JJ

    Where did you hear Lukeà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s voice? Couldnt tell from his former group vids what he individually sounds like. Did I miss one? Want to hear.

    MJ posted some links above. You can hear him singing Over the Rainbow. Sigh….he can’t be perfect.

  • jersey

    Ah, JJ, I don’t think you can tell much from that vid. It’s like a cell phone video. I’m holding out hope.

  • http://www.myspace.com/mignonette33 purplesmile

    JJ, I couldn’t even get that video to play properly. Or maybe I was just too distracted by that chest…was he wearing a padded bra? LOL

  • jm

    Someone needs to tell Michael Johns that Buckhead, Ga. is a tiny little town in Madison County with about 250 residents.

    I’m sure he was trying to impress by giving “Buckhead, Ga.” as his former address. The Buckhead area of the city of Atlanta is the hot spot for clubs and restaurants and luxury homes.

  • JJ

    OH my dear Jersey and Purple. I heard enough to realize he dosen’t sound good, but maybe I was just distracted, as purple says. It really dosen’t matter if he can sing or not.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Luke worked for a financial services firm in Chicago? So did I a few years ago. Damn, he didn’t show up in the “Knowledge Center” (aka library).

    I’m so tempted to click on the links to hear Jason Castro. I will wait.

    à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Something about David Cook bothers me, but not sure what it is. à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ 

    I think its the forehead thats a mile high.

    I said this before, but I think he looks like Perez Hilton’s little brother. It’s bothersome.

  • GwendolynD

    Nice smile on Mr. Eze. ;)

  • http://www.myspace.com/mignonette33 purplesmile

    Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m so tempted to click on the links to hear Jason Castro. I will wait.

    Aww, come on, pj. Do it! You know you want to. ;) Besides, weren’t you the one annoyed that Renaldo Lapuz ate into Jason’s airtime? LOL

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Purps, I like him too much already based on nada. If he’s good and fails me like Brandon Rogers, I don’t know what I’d do!

  • http://kmantoniva.blogspot.com/ KristiVA

    Luke HAS to sound good! *crossing fingers*

  • IGetCranked

    And one can only hope that should Danny progress, he will appear in the future in full on drag singing a Cher song. Now THAT would be entertainment. (OK, and, well, suicide for him).

    *DL* Why do I think that he could actually pull this off?,

    I really hope Luke can sing so that I can pretend thatà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s why Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m voting for him

    oh Jersey, you shallow girl! I would NEVER be(staresatpictureagainandfansself) like that. I have integrity! (wondersifhewaseverandunderwearmodel)

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    Well, since Jason was my chosen one for tv boyfriend many weeks ago, I HAD to listen to him. And I think he sounds pretty damn good. Hope 60′s week doesn’t eff him up. I could totally see him doing some acoustic number tonight. Just him and his guitar, singing about the times they are a changing. :-)

  • tinawina

    Luke Menard is the only one that might give Hot Aussie a run for his money in my book. If he is as seexxxayy moving around as he is in that picture… oh MY.

    I an mot above voting for him just to keep him around either. Brandon sucked for weeks last year until he finally bit the dust. (mmmmm. Brandon. mmmmm.) I’m not saying I was directly responsible for that, but I did my part. :-) Eye candy rules!!!!!!

  • Nostradamas

    With three Hoosiers in the top 24….who knows? Maybe a chance for some midwestern singers this time around.

  • hapi

    Aw gee, really can’t tell from this. These amatuer audience recorded thingys can often make even a good singer sound not too hot. Ive seen some Marc Broussard vids like this that he really sounds bad on and he’s great. Also that type of chapter 6 group is “different”…so have great hopes for the guy.

  • JJ

    And one can only hope that should Danny progress, he will appear in the future in full on drag singing a Cher song. Now THAT would be entertainment. (OK, and, well, suicide for him).

    This would be one of the greatest moments in Television history.

  • Soapbox0916

    I feel like almost the only person who does NOT like Michael Johns. As soon as the spoilers came out, I listened to every MySpace and music file that I could find on the contestants. Michael reminds me of a soul singer, but emotionally he gives me a cold vibe. I do highly prefer a more natural raw sound and Michael came across to me as too in control when singing and too polished for my taste. This was before I heard about his attempt to take his former bandmates songs as his own. I think Michael has alot of talent, but something is just missing for me, I think it is control related, I can’t quite figure it out.

    Considering that my AI picks usually have horrible luck, by not having my support, I have probably just helped Michael out a whole lot.

  • JJ

    Considering that my AI picks usually have horrible luck, by not having my support, I have probably just helped Michael out a whole lot.

    I hope you hate Luke Menard too. I would really be bummed if you broke up my threesome.

  • maracaibo

    Luke looks like a soap opera star, really.

    Hey, if things don’t work for him in this competition, I bet he will get a gig on TV as soon he is done with Idol. I am sure of that, just based on his looks.

    Michael Johns IMO is way hotter. He is like incredibly sexy when he performs. Those looks combined with his awesome voice are mesmerizing.
    Go Michael!

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    Thanks for the excellent Guide to the Top 12 Guys, MJ. Only 9 hours and 8 minutes to go. Eye candy rules indeed!

  • JJ

    Eye candy rules indeed!

    This is the year of eye candy and jail bait. Are there actually any girls in this competition this year??

  • Ladybug

    I think Michael has alot of talent, but something is just missing for me, I think it is control related, I canà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t quite figure it out.

    I think there is something a bit calculated about him. I will reserve judgment for when I finally see him perform, but, so far in spite of his good looks and good voice, there is something of the fake about him.

    One of the things I have found that the majority of the Idol winners have had is a genuine quality to them.

    There is something that rings of “not genuine” about Michael Johns.

  • geekygirl

    Luke Maynard = YUM!!!!

    Boy I can’t wait to see the clips tomorrow morning! I thought Luke sounded good on the BR clip, if he is the lead singer guy. But as you say, who cares! In some ways it can go against him as a lot thought Ace was just a pretty face too.

    Let the games begin, I am so excited!

  • geekygirl

    Lost in a Luke moment there, forgot to add that I know what you mean about David C, I think I want to throw him in the shower?

    And the first time I saw Colton Berry I said “He looks like Boris Becker!!” lol

  • Kirsten

    Michael seems to be winning the iTunes battle so far this year. “Bohemian Rhapsody” sales spiked this week (the highest I saw it was 73). It could be people just wanted to cleanse their minds, though. I kid. I kid.

    “Everything I Do, I do it for You” also saw a sales spike, but that was sung by a few people.

    Sadly, iTunes has been set up not to help us gage how each idol is doing. In order to be “fair” (like anything about this show is “fair”), they won’t be showing the relative rankings of each song. I wonder if they will refrain from reporting sales stats until after the competition.

  • http://steve-o-meter.com steve-o-meter

    Just saw Josiah Lemming on Ellen…..he was adorable

  • rher

    Wow, it has been a long time since I posted! But, similarly to all of you, I’m starved for some idol and thinking that this year has to be better (and seems to be so far).

    That Garrett fellow is taking me back to 8th and 9th grade when I was madly in love with Peter Frampton. Add that to the fact that he is from Ohio and I’ve got my pick. I scoured the internet looking for any sort of clip of him. Nothing! Even Paul Kim last year had something. I think this mystery is also part of the intrique. Sure hope he can sing!

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    Ohhhh, last year we had song spoilers on the day of the Top 24 shows, because it was taped a few hours ahead of time. I wonder if the same will happen this year? I love spoilers.

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    This is the year of eye candy and jail bait. Are there actually any girls in this competition this year??

    LOL, JJ. Not on my radar, anyway. I look at the pic of the Top 24 and much of what I see is a bunch of interchangeable blonds.

  • Soapbox0916

    Re-reading my post, I did not mean to sound as negative toward Michael Johns as I came across (I cut down a much longer post before actually posting), I am still very much open to liking him, well atleast musically like him. I am just struggling to figure out what it is that bugs me about him. That is all. Just me in the twilight zone rambling away as usual.

    I kinda do like Luke, but don’t worry, I don’t think its enough to jinx him. LOL

  • moody

    I was wondering the same thing about spoilers. Does anybody know if these shows are being taped ahead of time?

  • calimari

    Hey – you know how the fan bases up come w/ ridiculous names for themselves like “McPhans” or “Yaminions” or “Fanjayas?” I’m betting that Chikeze guy gets the “Eze Riders.” :mrgreen_wp:

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    Pretty sure the shows are “live” this week.

  • primeminister

    I heard that the guys performed on Saturday, and the girls on Sunday.

  • JNM

    So ready for tonight!

    You all are cracking me up with the Luke love. Boy IS good looking though, have to admit.

    I’m hating myself for really liking a plant, but what to do? Idol will do what it wants. It doesn’t care, it doesn’t have to.

    I think Michael Johns just might take the whole thing.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    Hmm, ok, since it’s “live” this week. Anyone wanna play “match a song from the 60′s with each guy”?

  • meme

    Every time I see Luke “Menard’s” name I want to go shopping at my local hardware store in Indiana. :lol_tb:

  • Chicago-sally

    Chikezie looks like levert; yes?
    Luke Menard looks like a soap star.
    Let the games begin!

    (MJ how can I get your feed on my site?)

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    I’ll play, Tara! I’ll bet you a number of these songs will be sung tonight, not necessarily by the guys I’ve chosen, but just for fun here goes:

    Chikeze – Stand by Me
    Colton – Proud Mary
    Danny – My Girl. Heh.
    David A. – Pretty Woman
    David C. – She’s Not There
    David H. – Midnight Hour
    Garrett – You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling
    Jason C. – Dock of the Bay
    Jason Y. – Heard it Through the Grapevine
    Luke – Tracks of my Tears
    Michael – Suspicious Minds
    Robbie – When a Man Loves a Woman

    I am so excited!

  • Little Boy Blue

    Since this is the 60′s theme, I’d like to hear someone ( say Michael Johns ) try one song that has never been done before — UNDONE by the GUESS WHO.

    And I wonder if anyone is up to the challenge of trying Roy Orbison’s CRYING.

    Here’s another song that’s only been attempted once in Canadian Idol with great success by Kalan Porter HOUSE OF THE RISING SUN by THE ANIMALS.

    All of the above songs have the potential to either bring the house down or bring you down.

  • Little Boy Blue

    RE: Luke Menard – are you sure he never appeared at Beverly Hills 90210 ?

  • angelia

    David A. may do pretty well as a pageant kid. I understand that Jordin was the ultimate “pageant kid” and look where that landed her.

  • Little Boy Blue

    RE: Garrett Haley. There was another guy by the name of Garrett who was a singing star for the tweens of the 70′s who looks like our Garrett ( same hair too ) — Leif Garrett. Wonder whatever happened to him… he was as hot as Hannah Montana is today.

  • NOLA

    “Let the games begin!”

  • geekygirl

    oh yea! I saw something about him on AOL “where are they today” about Leif Garrett. I think he got fat and busted for drugs, arrested, and found god. As they do…

    I think it was written along the lines of what a waste of someone who had it all. I don’t remember him so didn’t pay too much attention.

    and have I mentioned Luke Maynard is HOT!!!

  • PrplDva

    oh yea! I saw something about him on AOL à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“where are they todayà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  about Leif Garrett. I think he got fat and busted for drugs, arrested, and found god. As they doà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦

    and bald….

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj
  • PrplDva

    OMG- I don’t know if this was mentioned, but…

    iTunes has a FREE video of I Am Your Brother. That was the little guy all in white with the silver cape that they all got up and sang with.

  • St.Lucia

    WOW! The Leif Garret pictures are SCARY!

    Let’s hope the same doesn’t happen to poor Leif Garrett junior, when he gets potential idol rejection, scaring him for life, and making him run to drugs an alcohol. Poor Garrett Haley he has to know who he gets compared too…not sure that’s a compliment considering the road Leif Garret traveled down. I mean his first name is Garrett, he looks like Leif Garrett, oh that’s all people will be talking about tomorrow. The real Leif Garrett thankfully had more hits in the 70′s(right?) so therefore that should prevent Garrett Haley from singing any of his songs tonight.

    And I so would have died to hear him sing “I was made for dancing!”

    On other notes, oh how I love me some Luke Menard!!!!! Can we put him on Grey’s Anatomy if this whole Idol thing doesn’t work out? I wouldn’t know what to do with all that eye candy. I’d like Luke so much more though, just because he can sing. :)

    SO EXCITED for tonight.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    The 60′s happens to be my favorite decade of music. I love almost all of it. I always said I was born too late in life. But anywho, I’m sure they will be singing songs that have been done before on Idol. Which is sad.

    Carie I bet at least half of those songs on your list will be done.

    Hmmm, I’m trying to decide if I want to make a list.

    I would really like to hear someone sing The Times They Are a Changing, or Give Peace a Chance. Or maybe Last Kiss. Orrrr Tracks of my Tears, The Sounds of Silence.

    Yeah, I could go on and on. I love the 60′s.

  • rher

    I don’t think that David A will win (wishful thinking anyway); we’ve already had a heavy dose of young and professionally manicured and pageantified last year.

    Wasn’t Leif Garrett on some VH1 show a few years back? He lost his golden locks. I think our Garrett resembles Frampton more than Leif.

    Let’s get in on! (for those Mxc fans out there)

  • geekygirl

    Ok now I have the fit of the giggles! Luke is too sexy for his shirt! St Lucia you crack me up! I haven’t been influenced by a pretty face in any of the seasons but damn that man is fine!!! Is there an equivalent of salt peter for women because I think we all need a dose!

    Please let there be a god and he can sing!

  • jersey

    MJ, it appears this has become a Luke Menard fantard site – and we haven’t even heard the boy sing. Hope you don’t mind; and even more than that, I hope his wife doesn’t mind, lol.

  • St.Lucia

    TARA-

    I would LOVE to hear anyone(well maybe not ANYONE) sing “Give Peace a Chance” or “The Sounds of Silence.”

    Oh that might make my day.

    I’m so tired of over idoled songs I could scream.

    I love the 60′s too, but I’m not sure what I love from the 60′s is what Idol loves from the 60′s Who know what kind of list they had to choose from.

    My love for Simon and Garfunkel, The Beatles, Stones, Doors, Beach boys, and Bob Dylan runs deep, and it would make my day to hear those songs versus the Diana Ross and The Supremes (which I have nothing against, but you know one of those Idoled to death songs), The Temptations, Stevie Wonder, songs. Which I LOVE all those artists, but I’m so tired of hearing all the songs.

    If I hear “Ribbon in the Sky” tonight I may cry. (which I’m not sure if he did that song in the 60′s or not)

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    I wonder if Micheal Johns will do the Doors again.

    I wish we had some spoilers! :-(

  • St.Lucia

    I know! I’m DYING for my spolers and I only have a little more than two hours to go.

    I’m such a little kid…entirely impatient with this blasted show.

  • IGetCranked

    MJ, it appears this has become a Luke Menard fantard site – and we havenà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t even heard the boy sing.

    He sings?

    I wouldn’t mind Michael singing some Doors either.

  • IGetCranked

    Yahoo has a buzzmeter on the contestans.

    http://tv.yahoo.com/american-idol/show/34934/buzzmeter

  • beesims

    Chikeze – Stand by Me
    Colton – Proud Mary
    Danny – My Girl. Heh.
    David A. – Pretty Woman
    David C. – Sheà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s Not There
    David H. – Midnight Hour
    Garrett – Youà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ve Lost That Loving Feeling
    Jason C. – Dock of the Bay
    Jason Y. – Heard it Through the Grapevine
    Luke – Tracks of my Tears
    Michael – Suspicious Minds
    Robbie – When a Man Loves a Woman

    If these are a sampling of the 60 pre-approved songs from teh 60′s, I am going to barf. Sorry CarieB, but these songs have all been done, done, done to death on Idol.

    I am pumped about tonight but I am really sorry that we aren’t going to get more personal and idiosyncratic choices for the semi-finals. How about Danny Noriega doing “Incense and Peppermints” while wearing a paisley caftan?

  • Ladybug

    OMG- I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t know if this was mentioned, butà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦

    iTunes has a FREE video of I Am Your Brother. That was the little guy all in white with the silver cape that they all got up and sang with.

    OK. Someone would PAY for this? And, since it is free, someone would DOWNLOAD this?

    I am looking forward to the mystery boys tonight. And to the ones we have heard before.

    I really liked little David A. on “Star Search”. (Oh wait! That show did not exist. He was NEVER on it. Go to the light! Go to the light!). Anyway. He is still little David A. and I think he is a cutie. I will enjoy “hearing him for the first time on a reality talent competition” tonight.

  • jersey

    I hope that we get 24 different songs from the top 24. They only had 50 songs to pick from. I’m guessing there were at least a couple of overlaps when everyone went through the list the first time. May cause some tension – either that or 4 people will be singing “My Girl”. (*gag*)

  • Kirsten

    I found some spoilers at TWoP (Spoiler thread is locked so they are in Speculation). Are we allowed to post spoilers here? They are pretty vague. They taped the shows this weekend. I’ll post the vaguest of them until we get a confirmation from MJ that they can be posted here.

    SPOILERS HO…….

    Tonight, we will here songs by Neil Sedaka, Harry Nilsson, The Beach Boys and The Doors (“Light My Fire”…where have I heard that one this season before?)

    SPECULATIONS HO…

    Jason C: Nilsson: “Simon Smith and his Dancing Bear”
    David C: Sedaka: “Love Will Keep Us Together”
    Luke: Beach Boys: “Wouldn’t It Be Nice” (If You’d Heard me Before Tonight)
    David A: Nilsson: “Sixteen Tons”

    Okay, it’s a good thing they don’t let me pick songs (although, I would have fun torturing people)

  • NOLA

    I loved opening my TV section of today’s newspaper to see a “large” photo of Michael Johns promoting tonight’s show. *sweet*

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    RE:Jason C: Nilsson: à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Simon Smith and his Dancing Bearà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ 

    Really Jason? This is how you’re going to be introduced to the AI audience?

  • jersey

    I don’t know if I buy those spoilers. David Cook singing Neil Sedaka, really? Although if Luke sings “after having spent the day together, hold each other close the whole night through”, he may get a few votes.
    Wait, Kirsten, were you just kidding? Sometimes I can’t tell!

  • Kirsten

    Really Jason? This is how youà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢re going to be introduced to the AI audience?

    It’s a joke! LOL. I just picked the most the most unlikely song from Harry’s collection and assigned it to the singer least likely to sing it. All the speculation ones are jokes on my part.

    BTW REAL* SPOILER: Everybody has the flu (don’t adjust the tint on your TV)

    *There is no evidence that any of my spoilers are true. I’m just reporting what I find at other sites.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    Thank God….lol. I was about ready to boycott the show for the night. I mean AI, they pick some questionable songs…..nothing is unlikely.

  • jersey

    :doh_tb:

  • hapi

    Kill me now…I accept the kill but here goes:
    I think Constantine M. did a much better job on Boh. Rhap. (and dont care for Constantine personally) But when it comes to a guy w/looks sometimes we fans aren’t really listening too closely. OK im dead now.

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    Hmmmm… If I was voting on looks alone, Luke would definitely get my vote. That said, I may vote for him tonight anyway, just to give a big FU to TPTB.

    Michael Johns is good and I like him too, but he’s basically sailing into the top 12 no matter what he does, so I’m going to help out the cannon fodder.

    Luke and David Hernandez are both QUITE swoon-worthy. I’m liking the eyecandy this year. :wub_tb:

  • http://www.idolicious.com Kat

    Well, here’s my super sekrit confession: I haven’t watched Idol all season until tonight. I wasn’t interested in the auditions at all, and from what I’d heard about the pre-ordained COs (such as Carly and Kristy Lee — whose supposed “beauty,” by the way, continues to evade me), I wasn’t exactly enthralled. However, I’m excited to watch it tonight with fresh eyes and without any favorites — I know next to nothing about any of the men, except that Luke Menard is gorgeous and that Robbie Carrico dated Britney.

    Let the games begin. :)

  • Kirsten

    I mean AI, they pick some questionable songsà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦..nothing is unlikely.

    That is true. There are probably 5 decent songs out of the 24 (all assigned to TCO) and everybody else had to fight amongst a dogs breakfast of choices. The “Four Mutes” probably got to pick last (Nigel: Okay, people, you get chose songs based on the amount of airtime you got. The more airtime you got, the earlier you get to pick. Here Carly, you go first).

    The last four songs available were “Hello Muddah, Hello Faddah”, “Does Your Chewing Gum Lose It’s Flavour on the Bed Post Overnight”, “Put Another Log on the Fire” and “Tiptoe Through the Tulips” (but perhaps they were generous and left in “Snoopy Vs. The Red Baron”, “Monster Mash”, “Woolly Bully” and “Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow”).

    Sorry for scaring you Tara.

  • jersey

    If that’s the case, Kirsten, Luke should be in good shape considering his Acappella group sings a song about Krispy Kreme donuts. How far is that from a song about chewing gum?

  • http://www.idolicious.com Kat

    Kirsten, don’t be silly. Obviously, the leftover song choices were “Green Onions,” “Soul Finger,” and for the lucky draw, “Tequila.”

  • hapi

    Im hoping all the unheard cannon fodders get all the votes!

  • Kirsten

    for the lucky draw, à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Tequila.à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ 

    Randy: I don’t know DAWG. I’m not crazy about the song choice. It just wasn’t working for me. Not enough singing. Sorry dude.

    Paula: You know I like you and I LOVE Tequila. And when you mix you with Tequila you get that special…magic. Tequila is LOVE. I sense the Tequila in you. Don’t ever let the Tequila out.

    Simon: You know what I’m going to say. You had to come out here and make an impression. Frankly, it was all a bit repetitive, You had your chance and you blew it. Not good enough.

  • beesims

    Go Team Cannon Fodder!! Garrett Haley for the win! :thumbup_tb:

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    Sorry CarieB, but these songs have all been done, done, done to death on Idol.

    Oh, I know Beesims. I wasn’t putting forth a list of songs I wanted, I just bet there’s a bunch of those they will use again this year.

    So, who do we think gets the pimp spot tonight? David A.? Michael?

    Pretty certain Carly will get it tomorrow night, and I accept that but it pisses me off at the same time.

  • lg

    David has confidence and charisma

    David H does indeed exude confidence. The way he re-worked “Love the One You’re With” was brilliant. Not bad on the eyes either. :) Go Hernandez!

    It will be interesting to see just how much the rock dudes rock. Hopefully Carrico will deliver, despite having been a boy bander. He lists Brett from Shinedown and Jonathan from Korn as his influences – now he just needs to back that up. I wasn’t that impressed with his take on Simple Man, but he did get a little better as the song went on.

    Castro is definitely a hottie and it is very interesting that he likes Ray LaMontagne. I didn’t listen to the audio above, so looking forward to hearing him for the first time tonight.

  • St.Lucia

    So, who do we think gets the pimp spot tonight? David A.? Michael?

    Oh I’m totally thinking David A or Michael, but am leaning a bit more towards David A than Michael. The judges are pretty much drooling all over him. To which I’m still wondering why. Again, one of those kids who can sing ANYTHING but could he convey the meaning.

    Carly will have it for the girls.

    Gosh, wouldn’t it be nice if they gave the pimp spot to some cannon fodder? Oh wait, that’s never happened…

    Here’s to finding some Bo Bice’s and Elliott Yamin’s! (coughLUKEMENARDcough)

  • folk

    hey everyone. i am ready. only caught bits and pieces of the auditions…like i think i saw three of these guys…so i am going to watch fresh tonight with no favs or hateds in mind …yet:)

  • Lu

    I think Carly is toast…. starting to agree more ane more with those that posted here that thought she was put on to generate buzz… and boy is it working! We shall see.

    I thought somebody might do the Name Game tonight… isn’t that the 60s? Simon simon bo bimon banana fanna fo imon me my mo imon Simon! Let’s do Chuck!

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    Oh Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m totally thinking David A or Michael, but am leaning a bit more towards David A

    Plus David’s in the #1 position on the Yahoo buzz meter-thingy, which I gather they developed by looking at internet searches for these people.

    *waves to folk* Nice to see you!

  • St.Lucia

    The buzz that David A has around him drives me a bit batty, although I’m NOT the least bit surprised. I just wish I got it. Lol. :wacko_tb: Oh well, maybe I’m not supposed to, and maybe I know too much about how this show works to be surprised, but it can still piss me off. :)

  • JOJOSIE

    I like the little older performers so I definitely will watch Michael, Jason Yeager, and Luke Menard. We have a Menard’s Home Improvement Center where I live also.It must be a mid-west chain. Lukes got the looks but I’m anxious to hear Jason Yeager, he’s a good looking, well built guy and hasn’t been too professional as there isn’t even a u-tube video. I’m already for some suprises.

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    I’m thinking David A or Michael will get the pimp spot too. What I’m wondering is who will get the death sentence of going first. The past two years, the guy who has opened the show the first week of the top 24 has gone home – Patrick Hall and Rudy Cardenas.

    Unless one of the majorly pimped ones gets that spot this year, I’d say it will happen again.

    Hey folk!! So great to see you! :)

  • http://www.myspace.com/gundomom CarieB

    Well, if the MJ Office Pool standings so far are any indication, either Colton or Jason Y. will get the death spot.

    David A. bugs. I don’t like pageant kids at all.

  • St.Lucia

    Jason Yeager for the first go! Just wouldn’t surprise me.