This week the American Idol Top 4  theme is California Dreamin or songs by California artists. The second song pick is “Songs I wish I Had Written” .

Both themes are broad and open to interpretation–it’s practically a “pick whatever the hell you want” week, which  may not be a bad thing.  For the 1st theme, I’m going to assume that any California base artist is game. For the second theme, I’m going to pick something that seems to represent who each finalist will be as an artist once they are on their own

Hollie  Cavanagh – #1 “Different Drum” by the Stone Ponies – I can totally imagine Hollie rocking some Linda Ronstadt #2 “Skyscraper” by Demi Lovato  – Could be a moment

Joshua Ledet – #1 – “Dance to the Music” by Sly and the Family Stone – Would the audience in the Idoldome be on their feet, or what?  #2 – “Closer” by Ne-Y0 – My favorite Ne-Yo song.

Phil Phillips – #1  “These Days” by Jackson Brown. I’m gonna grant Phil permission to sing one of my favorite songs of all time, because I think he might actually pull it off.  If not…maybe a tune from The Grateful Dead.  #2 – What about something by Ryan Adams or maybe James Morrison?

Jessica Sanchez – #1 “Firework” by Katy Perry #2 - Beyonce or Rihanna.  Jessica can show both her pop and R&B sides in the same week.

 

 
  • Anonymous

    I agree with only 4 left the pimp spot and death spot dont matter anymore.

  • Anonymous

    yup. when they leaked the song list I kinda wished she would be singing the india arie song and that would’ve been a stellar moment but i guess she made the most out of dance with my father.

  • Anonymous

    she’s too bubble gum to have an alternative side. might turn off her tween voters lol

  • Anonymous

    you forgot to add:

    want your idol to be perfectly bland like tap water? vote for hollie!

  • Anonymous

    Wow MJ…love your choices for P2….I’m totally a Hollie fan but if this did come to fruition, I might just have to yell out “Let Phil sing!”  ;o)

  • Anonymous

     IMO…Week after week it seemed the judges tried to (negatively) take away from anything Hollie did ( sometimes too busy OTT promoting of some other contestants really mediocre performances). So with a California themed thought , I hope Hollie “Dreams a Big Dream” for herself tonight cause the one thing the judges CAN’T take away from Hollie are her DREAMS. Dream big Hollie…dream big!      

  • Tess

    Oh…I have no problem with tap water….and the tap water where I live is excellent.  You don’t have to buy that phony-over priced crap that they bottle up and sell as something wonderful when it is the same tap water I am drinking run through a processing plant to “purify” it to the point it has no taste.

  • Anonymous

    Ummm yeah, right.