Simon Cowell on Ellen Degeneres. Oh Wait…

Anybody else find it strange that while Randy Jackson and Kara DioGuardi have offered their enthusiastic thumbs up, Simon Cowell has yet to publicly welcome his new panel-mate Ellen Degeneres to the judges table? He hasn’t been too busy to set his recent remarks on the Beatles straight, but complete and utter silence on Ellen?

It’s been reported that less than half a dozen people knew about the Ellen negotiations that took place over the course of two weeks. Maybe Simon wasn’t one of those elite few and is feeling slighted, hence the silence on his end.? What do you peeps think? Why is Simon suddenly silent?

While Simon keeps mum, others have offered their opinions. Carrie Underwood told People, “Everybody loves Ellen…I think she’ll make a great addition [to American Idol].” and Constantine Maroulis said, “I think she’s amazing. She’s really funny, so likable and I think she’ll really be a mentor to the contestants.’  And David Cook, ‘I don’t know that anyone can replace Paula, nor should they try…but I am excited to see how Ellen affects the dynamic of the show.’ 

Taylor Hicks dropped by the CBS Early Show Friday to offer his opinion, “I think it’s going to be great…I think she bring as lot of entertainment value to the show. I think that she’s a great personality, and she might have a little bit of more of a musical chop than we think she does.” Taylor’s season 5 buddy, Bucky Covington, appeared as well, “I think it would be great to have someone call Simon out on his corny jokes.”

Taylor added, “We need to get Simon (Cowell) and Ellen in a singing competition and determine which has the best musical quality.”

Two-time guest judge, Victoria Beckham tells E Online she didn’t want the job anyway.

More: USA Today wonders, “Risky Move or Brilliant plan?” and the LA Times rounds up varied 0pinions on the new 4th judge from celebrities to dumb bloggers. Heh.   Plus, the Times ran a poll–the yeses edge out the nos at 56%…

About mj santilli 34691 Articles
Founder and editor of, home of the awesomest fan community on the net. I love cheesy singing shows of all kinds, whether reality or scripted. I adore American Idol, but also love The Voice, Glee, X Factor and more!