Hey kids.  I have a present!  SPOILERS!!! YAY!  Here ya go:

Will Makar – “How Sweet It Is” by James Taylor (original by the great Marvin Gaye, of course)
Taylor Hicks – “Taking It To the Streets” by Michael McDonald
Gedeon McKinney – “When a Man Loves a Woman” by Percy Sledge
Kevin Covais – “Vincent” by Don McLean
Chris Daughtry – “Broken” by Seether
Ace Young – “Butterflies” by Michael Jackson
Elliott Yamin – “Heaven” by Bryan Adams

No spoilers for Bucky Covington right now.


ETA:  From comments here and around the boards–Will Makar has performed a Jazzy Michael Buble-inspired version of “How Sweet it Is” in the past.