Comments on: X Factor Week 8 Performance http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm American Idol - I Love This Cheesy Show Fri, 10 Feb 2012 06:45:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: butte009 http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510301 butte009 Sun, 29 Nov 2009 17:54:34 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510301 <blockquote>With the twins gone, I'm now rooting for Lloyd to win. He is the worst singer for sure (has been since almost the beginning), but I like him, no one else can be said to be really good (I'd say Olly is the best left), and I don't care about X-Factor to want a legitimate singer to win. I really dislike Danyl, hope he'll go soon.</blockquote> I don't know that I'd go so far as to let him win, but I wouldn't mind him getting 3rd after Joe and Olly. Way back in the audition stage I said he would go far because all the young girls would like him and I thought he had potential if he were given good mentoring. Not sure that Cheryl has done much to help him with her song choices but I still think he has potential based on the a capella part of his audition. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kA2t07q9G8. Put him in a boy band and he'll be fine. Joe is always solid (even though I don't care for his vocals myself). Olly just seems like a really nice guy. I don't mind cheesy when it comes from him. Danyl and Stacey were at their best during auditions and really have gone downhill since IMO.

With the twins gone, I’m now rooting for Lloyd to win. He is the worst singer for sure (has been since almost the beginning), but I like him, no one else can be said to be really good (I’d say Olly is the best left), and I don’t care about X-Factor to want a legitimate singer to win. I really dislike Danyl, hope he’ll go soon.

I don’t know that I’d go so far as to let him win, but I wouldn’t mind him getting 3rd after Joe and Olly. Way back in the audition stage I said he would go far because all the young girls would like him and I thought he had potential if he were given good mentoring. Not sure that Cheryl has done much to help him with her song choices but I still think he has potential based on the a capella part of his audition. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kA2t07q9G8. Put him in a boy band and he’ll be fine.

Joe is always solid (even though I don’t care for his vocals myself). Olly just seems like a really nice guy. I don’t mind cheesy when it comes from him.

Danyl and Stacey were at their best during auditions and really have gone downhill since IMO.

]]> By: druzilla http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510213 druzilla Sun, 29 Nov 2009 16:02:46 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510213 At this point Joe is my favorite. Lloyd is adorable but should never be allowed to sing. The others are various levels of mess and annoyance. Generally I agree with MJ's review this week. At this point Joe is my favorite. Lloyd is adorable but should never be allowed to sing.
The others are various levels of mess and annoyance. Generally I agree with MJ’s review this week.

]]> By: Hazehel http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510207 Hazehel Sun, 29 Nov 2009 15:58:18 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510207 With the twins gone, I'm now rooting for Lloyd to win. He is the worst singer for sure (has been since almost the beginning), but I like him, no one else can be said to be really good (I'd say Olly is the best left), and I don't care about X-Factor to want a legitimate singer to win. I really dislike Danyl, hope he'll go soon. With the twins gone, I’m now rooting for Lloyd to win. He is the worst singer for sure (has been since almost the beginning), but I like him, no one else can be said to be really good (I’d say Olly is the best left), and I don’t care about X-Factor to want a legitimate singer to win. I really dislike Danyl, hope he’ll go soon.

]]> By: justjude http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510181 justjude Sun, 29 Nov 2009 12:00:50 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510181 IMHO> Daniel first song was just ok. 2nd was acutually better once he go his throat to calm down....Should be in top 3 Joe McElderry has the best voice but does lack some charisma and the first was very good, 2nd song actually blew me away and I had to (heaven) agree wuth Simon.....He sang and emoted absolutely beautifully If he can find this muse again... Should IMHO> Daniel first song was just ok. 2nd was acutually better once he go his throat to calm down….Should be in top 3
Joe McElderry has the best voice but does lack some charisma and the first was very good, 2nd song actually blew me away and I had to (heaven) agree wuth Simon…..He sang and emoted absolutely beautifully If he can find this muse again… Should

]]> By: JosieX http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510175 JosieX Sun, 29 Nov 2009 10:53:12 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510175 hr100, thanks for posting that, I had not watched the auditions. That was actually very touching, I thought. And he showed better composure up there than people years older than him. A very impressive young man, I like Joe very much. hr100, thanks for posting that, I had not watched the auditions. That was actually very touching, I thought. And he showed better composure up there than people years older than him. A very impressive young man, I like Joe very much.

]]> By: lica http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510174 lica Sun, 29 Nov 2009 10:51:56 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510174 Am I the only one who stop watching when Simon is gushing over Danyl? Danyl's second song (even though I imagined it would be a good choice for him) can send him home before Lloyd. Sad, but true. (one more thing - it felt like his voice was gone... How will he be a performer if his voice disappears after one song???) If Lloyd doesn't go home this week... He should ask to leave. He is the worst of the group. Olly did ok with the first song. I just think he lost bits of his charisma. I also think he is not giving it all these last weeks. Does he really want it? The second song says so... I think the competition is really between him and Joe. Stacey sang one really briliiant tune in the whole season - Who Wants To Live Forever. All she sang before was bad, and all she sang afterwards too. She should get her bottom 2 this week. Unless Britain is crazy. Comparing her with Lucie... It's just mean. Dannii had the winner and because of the stupid deadlock, the best girl singer is gone. Where is her upbeat song? They said this week was supossed to have one ballad and one upbeat song... Both her songs were ballads. Joe, so the boy can't dance, but he is IMO one of the sparkles of talent in this competition (the other is Olly). Love it. I think he should win. But I can't predict anything yet. I thought initially that Cheryl had made the wrong choices for her group, but Joe is a perfect choice (Lloyd not so much - he is cute but he lacks everything else). As anybody can go home now (as the judges have no saying on the final result anymore), it's difficult to predict. Let's hope it's Lloyd, his expiration date in the program has expired a long time ago. But it can be Stacey and Danyl too. Am I the only one who stop watching when Simon is gushing over Danyl? Danyl’s second song (even though I imagined it would be a good choice for him) can send him home before Lloyd. Sad, but true. (one more thing – it felt like his voice was gone… How will he be a performer if his voice disappears after one song???)

If Lloyd doesn’t go home this week… He should ask to leave. He is the worst of the group.

Olly did ok with the first song. I just think he lost bits of his charisma. I also think he is not giving it all these last weeks. Does he really want it? The second song says so… I think the competition is really between him and Joe.

Stacey sang one really briliiant tune in the whole season – Who Wants To Live Forever. All she sang before was bad, and all she sang afterwards too. She should get her bottom 2 this week. Unless Britain is crazy. Comparing her with Lucie… It’s just mean. Dannii had the winner and because of the stupid deadlock, the best girl singer is gone. Where is her upbeat song? They said this week was supossed to have one ballad and one upbeat song… Both her songs were ballads.

Joe, so the boy can’t dance, but he is IMO one of the sparkles of talent in this competition (the other is Olly). Love it. I think he should win. But I can’t predict anything yet.

I thought initially that Cheryl had made the wrong choices for her group, but Joe is a perfect choice (Lloyd not so much – he is cute but he lacks everything else).

As anybody can go home now (as the judges have no saying on the final result anymore), it’s difficult to predict. Let’s hope it’s Lloyd, his expiration date in the program has expired a long time ago. But it can be Stacey and Danyl too.

]]> By: hr100 http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510161 hr100 Sun, 29 Nov 2009 09:28:09 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510161 I have liked Joe since his first audition http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rv6xnt_i-A8 It seems that Simon also realises now that he will most likely win which is why extra praise is being heaped on him. He does seem like a really nice lad and is a good singer, he will probably have 2 albums and then on to musicals which lets be honest most singers would jump at. I have liked Joe since his first audition

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rv6xnt_i-A8

It seems that Simon also realises now that he will most likely win which is why extra praise is being heaped on him. He does seem like a really nice lad and is a good singer, he will probably have 2 albums and then on to musicals which lets be honest most singers would jump at.

]]> By: Thea http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510154 Thea Sun, 29 Nov 2009 08:39:11 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510154 I know I repeat myself, but if Archuleta can have a career in music, then so does Joe. IMO the voice is as good (and he does not have the kind of training and experience DA had when he was on AI), 5 times the personality, and could grow up to become quite a good looking young man. Having said that, he probably is suited to doing music I would not buy (like I do not buy DA's)... I know I repeat myself, but if Archuleta can have a career in music, then so does Joe. IMO the voice is as good (and he does not have the kind of training and experience DA had when he was on AI), 5 times the personality, and could grow up to become quite a good looking young man.
Having said that, he probably is suited to doing music I would not buy (like I do not buy DA’s)…

]]> By: JosieX http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510151 JosieX Sun, 29 Nov 2009 08:33:50 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510151 Once again, Joe leaves the rest in the dust from a vocal standpoint, in my opinion. Last week seemed like a very bad week for everyone except him, and at least it seemed to me that they all improved over last week. Even Lloyd, who still wasn't too good, but was at least better. Danyl and Stacey are similar to me in that they each have moments where they sound good, but they're not consistent. Olly is very likeable, and although I don't find his voice that appealing, I thought he did a great job on "Saturday Night". But I still think that Joe is the best. I agree with Simon that he took a real step up in maturity on the stage this week. Once again, Joe leaves the rest in the dust from a vocal standpoint, in my opinion. Last week seemed like a very bad week for everyone except him, and at least it seemed to me that they all improved over last week. Even Lloyd, who still wasn’t too good, but was at least better. Danyl and Stacey are similar to me in that they each have moments where they sound good, but they’re not consistent. Olly is very likeable, and although I don’t find his voice that appealing, I thought he did a great job on “Saturday Night”. But I still think that Joe is the best. I agree with Simon that he took a real step up in maturity on the stage this week.

]]> By: jack5791 http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-510122 jack5791 Sun, 29 Nov 2009 06:42:23 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-510122 Honestly, none of them are going to be superstars. They just simply aren't good enough. Lloyd is just downright terrible. I don't know how he got this far, and beat out some of the other people who were better. Perhaps his looks, but he doesn't have any star quality. Stacey, while a very pretty girl, is also in my opinion just awful. She hits some good notes but 95% of them are EXTREMELY pitchy. She has no stage presence or charisma. She's basically relying on her looks and that she seems like a nice girl. I'm sure being the last girl isn't hurting her either, but she really isn't great at all. I find Danyl totally overrated. He hits nice big notes, but I find his tone very irritating and most times, pitchy as well. Simon GUSHES over him, but I doubt he will be very successful either. Is he really current? I don't think so. Joe is by far the best technical singer left, but he is lacking star quality. He performs well, and sings pretty good also. He is just missing the "IT" factor, or since it is the X Factor, he is missing the X Factor. He is a really good singer though. I find Olly the best overall around. I'm still not sure how successful Olly would be, but he is a really great entertainer and has a good voice to back it up. He isn't as good as Joe technicality wise but Olly still has a nice voice. He is the only one I think that will actually make it SOMEWHERE if he ever won. Honestly, none of them are going to be superstars. They just simply aren’t good enough.

Lloyd is just downright terrible. I don’t know how he got this far, and beat out some of the other people who were better. Perhaps his looks, but he doesn’t have any star quality.

Stacey, while a very pretty girl, is also in my opinion just awful. She hits some good notes but 95% of them are EXTREMELY pitchy. She has no stage presence or charisma. She’s basically relying on her looks and that she seems like a nice girl. I’m sure being the last girl isn’t hurting her either, but she really isn’t great at all.

I find Danyl totally overrated. He hits nice big notes, but I find his tone very irritating and most times, pitchy as well. Simon GUSHES over him, but I doubt he will be very successful either. Is he really current? I don’t think so.

Joe is by far the best technical singer left, but he is lacking star quality. He performs well, and sings pretty good also. He is just missing the “IT” factor, or since it is the X Factor, he is missing the X Factor. He is a really good singer though.

I find Olly the best overall around. I’m still not sure how successful Olly would be, but he is a really great entertainer and has a good voice to back it up. He isn’t as good as Joe technicality wise but Olly still has a nice voice. He is the only one I think that will actually make it SOMEWHERE if he ever won.

]]> By: Sassycatz http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-509873 Sassycatz Sun, 29 Nov 2009 02:03:17 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-509873 <blockquote>Ppl here are comparing Joe to Archie, but I'm actually finding him to be similar to George Michael's tone & presence. I can just imagine Joe singing some GM ballads like Careless Whisper, One More Try, Turn a Different Corner, or Father Figure.</blockquote> Are you suggesting that there's more there, there? I mean, with Archie, it's what you see is what you get. I can't imagine George Michael was George Micheal in the beginning.

Ppl here are comparing Joe to Archie, but I’m actually finding him to be similar to George Michael’s tone & presence. I can just imagine Joe singing some GM ballads like Careless Whisper, One More Try, Turn a Different Corner, or Father Figure.

Are you suggesting that there’s more there, there? I mean, with Archie, it’s what you see is what you get. I can’t imagine George Michael was George Micheal in the beginning.

]]> By: Reflections On Life http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-509865 Reflections On Life Sun, 29 Nov 2009 01:58:15 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-509865 Ppl here are comparing Joe to Archie, but I'm actually finding him to be similar to George Michael's tone & presence. I can just imagine Joe singing some GM ballads like Careless Whisper, One More Try, Turn a Different Corner, or Father Figure. Ppl here are comparing Joe to Archie, but I’m actually finding him to be similar to George Michael’s tone & presence. I can just imagine Joe singing some GM ballads like Careless Whisper, One More Try, Turn a Different Corner, or Father Figure.

]]> By: eboytc http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-2/#comment-509861 eboytc Sun, 29 Nov 2009 01:53:17 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-509861 Oh, is it just me or the show is so much boring without the Jedward! At least they're fun to watch. Lloyd, you're such an eye-candy but it's awkward watching you sing. They're all boring tonight. I like Joe's 'Could it be Magic' but his 'Sorry seems to be the hardest word' didn't touch me. Oh, is it just me or the show is so much boring without the Jedward! At least they’re fun to watch.

Lloyd, you’re such an eye-candy but it’s awkward watching you sing.

They’re all boring tonight. I like Joe’s ‘Could it be Magic’ but his ‘Sorry seems to be the hardest word’ didn’t touch me.

]]> By: NatalijaS http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-1/#comment-509829 NatalijaS Sun, 29 Nov 2009 01:09:27 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-509829 mj, you've pretty much written my exact thoughts! Lloyd is way past his sell-by date, Danyl is pitchy and oversings, Joe is dull and Olly's vocal is weak - he's only saved by his energy onstage. At this point I'd like Stacey to win because I like her personality the most - none of them are going to have successful careers in pop music anyway. I do agree she lacks charisma and has pitch problems, but it would be way more fun to see her win it than Joe, who I think secretly thinks he's going to win anyway. AI is infinitely better with much more promising talent...Only a month and a half to go - so excited! Am counting down the days... mj, you’ve pretty much written my exact thoughts! Lloyd is way past his sell-by date, Danyl is pitchy and oversings, Joe is dull and Olly’s vocal is weak – he’s only saved by his energy onstage.
At this point I’d like Stacey to win because I like her personality the most – none of them are going to have successful careers in pop music anyway. I do agree she lacks charisma and has pitch problems, but it would be way more fun to see her win it than Joe, who I think secretly thinks he’s going to win anyway.
AI is infinitely better with much more promising talent…Only a month and a half to go – so excited! Am counting down the days…

]]> By: Pam http://www.mjsbigblog.com/x-factor-week-8-performance.htm/comment-page-1/#comment-509828 Pam Sun, 29 Nov 2009 01:08:40 +0000 http://mjsbigblog.com/?p=12711#comment-509828 <blockquote>Lloyd really needs to go home. No really.</blockquote> THIS without a doubt! Heh I think he was the worst tonight by a mile. I think Joe's second song was the best of the night and I think he will advance and if he doesn't, I'll be shocked. I think Danyl is losing his edge in the competition. He definitely butchered "Your Song". Thanks for the vids mj. :)

Lloyd really needs to go home. No really.

THIS without a doubt! Heh

I think he was the worst tonight by a mile. I think Joe’s second song was the best of the night and I think he will advance and if he doesn’t, I’ll be shocked.

I think Danyl is losing his edge in the competition. He definitely butchered “Your Song”.

Thanks for the vids mj. :)

]]>