Lucy really changed her game here, very admirable. She worked the stage and the audience, she brought out her rock voice, esp on the higher notes. She’s usually pitch-perfect but was pitchy here, probably cuz she usually stands still but this time was much more performance-oriented. Strong work!

Rachel was suffering from the Lil Rounds effect. Changing up the hair and the clothes each week, often to poor effect. Her original look, the awesome haircut & edgier clothes, would have made a lot more sense for her rock song. Other than that , she sang well, esp toward the end, and I’m sorry to see her go.

BTW in another thread ppl were comparing each of the AIs favorably against their equivalent XFs, and ITA, but OTOH:

Rachel Adedeji >> Lil Rounds
Stacey Solomon >> Megan Joy

Don’t forget Cheryl Crow already covered Sweet Child of Mine http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vikes0JbGVw So it really wasn’t as big of a leap for Lucie, IMO. But still a very smart choice by Danii.

Yes, but Cheryl Crow wasn’t a fresh faced young girl-next-door type, as Lucie strikes me as being. I do think it was a pretty big leap for Lucie to credibly pull off a song that I think is so strongly entrenched in people’s minds in Axl Rose’s voice. I do agree that it was a smart choice, and a good trick for talented singers of either sex to “shop in the other department”, as Paula put it. Thinking of AI, that worked really well for some of the boys, e.g. Adam with “Believe”, Matt with “So Small” and Danny with “I Hope You Dance”.

Lucie is still my favorite of the competition. She was one of the only ones that actually sang pretty good. That was a hard, and kind of stupid song choice, for her but I think she really, really made it work and if she gets eliminated before some of these awful singers, that’s just so, so wrong. I feel like she could have a good career in music.

Lloyd was just awful. Didn’t get the song choice, thought he sang bad…don’t get the hype about him.

Danyl Johnson, wow…that was AWFUL. Still don’t get the hype over this guy, or why Simon is so gaga over him. This was PITCHY as all hell. I actually think Antonella’s version was better. Sure, he hit the big notes, but Danni’s critique on him was SPOT on. He’s lost any mojo he had. I think he also forgot the words in a few places? Simon would have killed him on Idol.

Stacey has a unique and interesting tone, but she always has the complete wrong song, IMO. I think she could do well but she needs a specific song, and with the songs she’s been choosing, it’s just been very average when with the right song, she could be pretty good. I don’t understand why they called her the best girl, because I actually think she is the worst of the three left.

Jamie was good. He doesn’t really stand out to me. He sounded fine but I always kind of just forget about him, which is a bad thing.

I thought Rachel did a really good job. It was pitchy at some points but overall I thought it was one of the stronger ones.

Jon and Edward…laughable as usual. They may be bad, but they are entertaining. I don’t care if they stay as long as Lucie doesn’t leave at their expense.

Olly is probably the best guy left in the competition. I really like Joe, but Olly has a much better voice and better presence, so I hope he does well.

I do not agree that the show is more manipulated by the judges than on AI’ ¦. on XF the judges pimp their team, but it’s out in the open, everyone expects it. On AI, the same happens, but they pretend they’re being impartial’ ¦

ITA. The XF standing Os don’t bother me at all. The judges are supposed to be supporting their team. That’s all it is. Support. I think some are reading too much into it.

Sweet Child of Mine is actually a good key for a woman’ ¦.the amazing thing is how Axl could sing it like that, not Lucie!

Yes, that’s why Danii made a really smart choice of song.

Don’t forget Cheryl Crow already covered Sweet Child of Mine http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vikes0JbGVw So it really wasn’t as big of a leap for Lucie, IMO. But still a very smart choice by Danii.

Oh, and I like Dermot’ ¦ D has an infectious smile

I like him too.

uche
11/01/2009 at 1:11 am
And, yeah, even though Adam did an AMAZING job with Whole Lotta Love, all Simon did was clap.

I have to disagree. In the few seconds he had he said that it was one of his favorite performances that Adam had ever done and that no one would be able to top it.
That said, Simon is a tool.

ok’ ¦ i also think there are no real stars this year in XF. Having said that, I think some comments are a bit biased. If you take out Adam (which is a one-off exception), and possibly Kris, the rest of AI last year SUCKED, possibly on average worse than XF this year.

With all due respect, that’s absurd. AI8, you could really critique someone for being off-key. This X-Factor, it’s almost more important to praise someone for being on-key. If the gulf is that wide (and it is), then there really isn’t much reason to think that even the lower-tier Idol contestants wouldn’t be near front runners in this competition. It’s that god awful. Can’t speak to the quality of X-Factor seasons prior (I’ve only watched a few performances), but this year the shows aren’t even comparable. Even AI6, for all of the crap it gets, wasn’t nearly this bad, even if that basically only comes on the back of its top 3 contestants.

Now, I get that the X-Factor puts more emphasis on performance, and, for that, it’s hard to compare the shows at some level, because so much emphasis is placed on the stage on the X-Factor. But for one who occasionally likes to pretend this is basically a popularity competition where the emphasis is put on singing… come on, it’s not even close. And even if you take in the whole package, it’s hard to enjoy any performance when the vocals are this off.

Lucie was the best singer of the night by far.

Most of them are creepy and pedestrian.

What is with Simon giving a standing O to that danyl guy? he was HORRIBLE. He looked terrified and was just tuneless.

John and Edward were hysterically bad.. I’d love to see them win this just to make Simon go crazy

I watched John and Edward because they are so incredibly bad and I wanted to see how they topped themselves this week.

That one judge spoke the truth (as well as made me sad) with ‘This is what the music business is all about.’ That explains a LOT.

ok’ ¦ i also think there are no real stars this year in XF. Having said that, I think some comments are a bit biased. If you take out Adam (which is a one-off exception), and possibly Kris, the rest of AI last year SUCKED, possibly on average worse than XF this year.

ITA.

Last year’s XF was SO much better than this year’s XF and AI hands down.

Simon is fucking hypocrite. After Jedward’s performance (which wasn’t that bad) he said “out of tune, you CANNOT, CANNOT defend that singing tonight Louis”. Didn’t he defend Danyl who was COMPLETELY out of tune singing that Aerosmith song? Gosh I hate that manipulative old man.

Joe yesterday was completely out of his element, because he does NOT have a rock voice, but has a really good voice (not sure why no one here is giving him credit, he is much better than, say D Archuleta, and with 3 times the personality).

I’m not a fan of Archuleta but he has the much better voice and I don’t get how Joe has much more “personality” than David, they both seem to be very nice and polite young kids.

Every year we have the cute young kid with an ok voice going far on the x factor based on their popularity among the show core audience, we had Ray Quinn in S3 who finished second to Leona then Leon Jackson who won then Eoghan who was also supposed to be the answer to Archuleta.
None of these singers got much going on after the show despite going far in the competition so I’m not sure how Joe is different from them.

Sweet Child of Mine is actually a good key for a woman’ ¦.the amazing thing is how Axl could sing it like that, not Lucie!

Yes, that’s why Danii made a really smart choice of song.

Joe yesterday was completely out of his element, because he does NOT have a rock voice, but has a really good voice (not sure why no one here is giving him credit, he is much better than, say D Archuleta, and with 3 times the personality).

I don’t agree with the Archuleta comparison. While I do agree that Joe has a good voice, I think it is at best equal to Archie’s (even that is doubtful). I think David has more maturity, uniqueness, and soulful quality to his voice that Joe lacks. Technically, Joe is very good, but I never really feel the connection with his performances as I did with David’s.

Seriously, I mean, Poo Hoo Danyl was in the bottom two during Rat Pat Week. So? Adam was, too, and the next week he kicked a** with Led Zeppelin’s Whole Lotta Love. Honestly, being in the bottom two is no excuse.

I think the circumstance is a little different between the two. First off, Adam appearing in the bottom 3 was in the later stage of the competition when the differences among contestants are not as big and obvious as early weeks. No one should really be considered safe at that point of the competition. On the other hand, Danyl was in the bottom two last week when he had arguably the best performance of the night, with plenty of people clearly having worse performances than he had. Add to that all the horrible press that he was getting (which, I think, is worse and more personal that what Adam got), he must have doubts in his head wondering whether he is truly the “most hated” contestant ever. If that doesn’t affect your confidence and performance, I don’t know what will. I don’t think you can really compare where Adam was to where Danyl is right now.