X Factor USA Spoilers – The Top 16

By On 10/18/2011 · 74 Comments · In X Factor

Share on TumblrShare via email

UPDATE: No changes to this list, but I thought I’d move it up front in case you wanted to take a peak at it. We’ll see if they are accurate or not when the X Factor reveals the Top 16 tonight.

I was hesitant to post these new X Factor spoilers, because the last batch had several errors. Unfortunately there just aren’t totally accurate spoilers for X Factor as we are used to receiving for American Idol. I think we are a little spoiled! Heh.

But I decided to post them with a big fat disclaimer, for entertainment purposes only. Don’t kill me if they are wrong.

The girls category looks really effed up, but Simon has already said he’s not sure if he made the right decisions or not. If the spoilers are true, he’s going to have a lot of ‘splanin to do!

Anyhwoo, these spoilers come by way of a poster at Digital Spy.

BOYS

Chris Rene
Brian Bradley
Phillip Lomax
Marcus Canty

Brennan Hunt (cut)
Nick Voss (cut)
Skyelor Anderson (cut)
Tim Cifers (cut)

Nothing has changed there with the boys, im still 100% these are the 4 boys who make the lives

GROUPS

Intensity
Lakoda Rayne
The Brewer Boys
StereoHoggz

4Shore (cut)
The Anser (cut)
2Squar’d (cut)
Illusion Confusion (cut)

These are different from my other thread, I had the manufactured groups correct although i had Lakoda Rayne as cut but it appears i was wrong, they made it. surprisingly it now appears 4shore were cut and the brewer boys make the lives.

OVERS

Stacy Francis
Josh Kracjik
Dexter Haywood
Leroy Bell

Elaine Gibbs (cut)
Tiger Budbill (cut)
James Kenney (cut)
Christa Collins (cut)

Nothing has changed imo the 4 who i said make it to the lives are still correct

GIRLS

Simone Battle
Tora Wiloshin
Rachel Crow
Tiah Tolliver/Melanie Amaro

Drew Ryniewics (cut)
Jazzlyn Little (cut)
Caitlin Koch (cut)

in my previous thread i had the top 4 girls as Melanie, Simone, Tora & Rachel 100% this now appears to be incorrect, and it is actually looking likely that Tiah makes it! & judging by a post ive read by another spoiler guy he seems to think that if that is the case then it is at the expense of Melanie . the other 3 girls are pretty much locks to be on the show and from what i cxan gather it appears roughly 60/40 in favour of Tiah making it over Melanie, but we will have to wait & see!

 
← Older Comments
  • BassChorus

    I really hope these predictions are wrong. The girls category is definitely the most talented bunch, and I wish their could be more of them and just get rid of most of the groups. I really thought the days of most “boy bands”/”girl groups” is over.

    The girl that deserves to make it thus far based on the performances at the houses is definitely Caitlin. She is absolutely gorgeous, and has a very distinct and beautiful voice. Her performance was amazing. How can Simon choose Simone over Caitlin??? I do also love Rachel, and Drew.

    I also don’t understand why they keep Dexter…he is horrible!! I really hate that the voice doesn’t really count for much. Elaine has a much better voice than Stacy, but I guess because she doesn’t keep crying like her.

    I also don’t understand why LA doesn’t put through one of the country guys. The young country guy is great, but does need a lot of work, but the other one has an amazing voice. “Astro” is talented, but are people really going to fall in love with someone who has a nasty/arrogant attitude??

    Again…I really hope these predictions are wrong. Simone and Tiah just don’t deserve a top 16 spot. I’m just praying Caitlin does make it.

  • BonnieDee

    Drew cut? Hard to believe.

  • BonnieDee

    Rachael Crow is my favorite.

  • Jae

    I didn’t look at these until after I had seen the show tonight. I really hope these are wrong. Welll, for the girls especially! All three listed as cut are the ones I thought should have made it through.

    As for the boys, I thought they would have kept Brennan. Surprised if Lomax really made it because he is the least commercial of the group.

  • Hercules67

    If these are true and Simon has picked Tiah and Simone over Caitlin and Jazzlyn, he has really messed-up. And on top of that, if Melanie does not make it….Wow! Simon, you think you’re a judge of talent? I am going to get a Verizon phone just to VOTE against your picks. The only one I like is Rachel.

    And then Brian makes it from the boys? Wow!

    All the other performers are interchangeable and will not go far.

    Go Rachel! Go Chris Rene!

  • Helen Marie

    For the girls’ sake, I hope the predictions are wrong. Simon has let me down with this new show. Is he looking for talent and amazing voices or commercial artists (who are a dime a dozen and whose careers last less than 15 min)?
    Jazzlyn is extremely talented and she needs to be in the top 16. She should be there instead of Rachel Crow. Rachel is good for her age, but needs to grow up and mature and then come back.

  • inthezone63

    Melanie and Elaine cut? If Paula was smart, she could have made those two into a spectatular gospel/soul group. But probably not.

  • Nele621

    Can a group of ten kids really make it big? I would sure hate to be their manager(s). Can you imagine splitting their earnings ten ways.

  • BonnieDee

    What the heck does he see in Tiah? I DO NOT get it.

  • TyraRay

    Very upset with the girls. The only one I’m happy about is Tora. They picked a horendus song for her, but she’s amazing and I think would do very well in the music industry.
    As for much Rachel, she too is incredible, but drew has the far batter voice imo.
    Tiah is a joke. And Simone doesn’t deserve a place either.
    IMO, it should be Tora, Melanie, Drew and Caitlan.

  • zuper

    Maybe I’m giving Simon too much credit for having a plan here but here is my theory (if the spoilers are correct). If you pick your favorite bottom tier person and put them directly in to the live shows. Then the obvious top tier person that got left out is pretty much a shoe in to get a wild card spot. It’s like getting to pick your top 5 instead of your top 4.

  • Benji

    At least we’ll have Stacy crying and screaming for a while.

  • SybilTrelawney

    If Melanie Amaro is out, then I will not watch the show any further. That girl has more talent in her little finger than Tiah and Simone put together. To her credit, Simone gave a decent performance of “Help,” but she’s still nowhere near deserving to edge out Melanie. Of course–I’ll say it–Simone is much more attractive than Melanie. Tiah isn’t, although she does have big boobs. If a pretty face and a nice rack beat out Melanie’s pipes–well, I’ll have a lot more free time each week.

    Frankly, I also think Rachel should be cut. She’s adorable, and she’s undeniably talented but she’s novelty act, a little girl singing big songs that she doesn’t understand. Contrast that to Drew, who is only a year older, apparently, but has a sophisticated sense of phrasing and is completely believable as a singer. Rachel is just. too. young.

  • karenc

    SybilTrelawney: Frankly, I also think Rachel should be cut. She’s adorable, and she’s undeniably talented but she’s novelty act, a little girl singing big songs that she doesn’t understand. Contrast that to Drew, who is only a year older, apparently, but has a sophisticated sense of phrasing and is completely believable as a singer. Rachel is just. too. young.

    I think so, and think she’s a good singer, but her age is the novelty. I don’t think she would be considered as good if she were older.

  • karenc

    Oh, terrific, glad Drew made it. Would have taken Tora over Simone, though

  • mikechristoffer

    If this is true it just goes to show that there are too many Black judges. I mean Dexter and the kid rapper? Dexter is pathetic and I tire of his sob story. Rap is not singing and I thought this was a singing contest. Hell, I have heard sick calves in a hailstorm sound better than the half pint Urkel imitator If Drew doesn’t make it, they should just burn the show.

  • karenc

    Something that I noticed that the contestants really seem to be talking more about how much they need the money more than on Idol. I know it’s a bigger prize, but it seems that they are taking more about that than the music they would make.

  • karenc

    I would have taken Christa over Dexter

  • koshka

    I love how they are. Conveniently editing the host out. Lol his days r numbered if rumor be true.

  • jpfan

    If this is true it just goes to show that there are too many Black judges.

    I guess you don’t realize how much black artists dominate the pop charts. The fact the AI only puts one or two black artists in their top 12/16/24 is what’s actually laughable.

  • dancingqueen

    How can there be too many Black judges, when only one, L.A., is Black? Obviously, Simon isn’t. Nicole is Filipino/Hawaiian/Russian. Paula is French Canadian/Brazilian/Syrian.

    StereoHoggz is the only group I like, Brewer Boys are OK. Marcus & Chris were the two guys I was interested in seeing go on. I would have chosen Christa & Tiger over Stacy & Dexter in over 30′a. Girls are a mess, my 4 were Melanie, Tora, Jazzlyn & Drew.

    Live performances are a whole different ball game, so, we’ll see how they fare.

  • x57x

    I don’t think there has ever been a Rap singer in any singing TV competition and X-Factor has TWO.

    I think the majority of people who listen to mostly Rap don’t watch cheesy TV reality shows, but we shall see if it works? If they don’t get any votes and leave early than we will know if TV singing competitions are ready for rap singers in a singing competition.

  • Anonymous

    my favorite is MELAINE AMARO

  • Anonymous

    my favorite is melayne amaro

← Older Comments