David Hernandez is Eliminated Tonight

Bottom 3:

  • Syesha Mercado
  • Kristy Lee Cook
  • David Hernandez

Video:

thank you Lawrence for the video…

Next week’s theme? The Beatles. Yes, you read that right…

The show tonight opens with cross promotion: Horton’s little Whos sit in front of the television, anticipating the start of American Idol. Just like the rest of us.

You did it America. Over 29 million votes Tuesday night. And it’s finally happening. Season 7 is out pacing Season 6 in vote totals. Last season’s Top 12 garnered 28 million votes. I’m not surprised. I expect to see the same kind of turn-about in the ratings as the buzz for this season continues to grow.

ETA: More recap After the Jump!

Jim Carrey, in the audience dressed as Horton, begins tonight’s pimpathon for Horton Hears a Who, the new movie–from FOX, of course.

Ryan jokes that the Beatles theme was SO popular, the kids are going to do it again next week. Wait. He’s not kidding. TPTB are actually going to push their luck with the Lennon/McCartney songbook. The kids are singing Beatles tunes again next week. Eep. The contestants did such a fantastic job with the catalog this week, why not just leave it at that? Unless they’ve managed to secure Paul McCartney as a mentor, I don’t see the point of a repeat.

Oh yeah, GROUP SING! Over the years we’ve had the Beatles music turned into fodder for chipmunks, muzak, disco music (remember “Stars on 45″?) and any number of bland, banal ripoffs. That’s why I don’t mind the kids pointy posing to some of the Beatles’ early tunes. It can’t be worse than the Season 5 tribute to Sgt Pepper, can it?

Michael Johns is off key and forgets the words to “All My Loving”. He thinks it’s pretty funny too. Shot of Jim Carrey rocking out in his ridiculous costume. Jason Castro singing one of my fav early songs, “I Feel Fine” puts a huge grin on my face. OMG, the kids strike a very choreographed pose. I am so VERY happy! This choreography is WAY TOO AWESOME! David Cook solo! YAY! The camera keeps cutting to Jim Carey and it’s cracking me up.

Go Chikezie! That’s my new mantra. David Hernandez messes up the words to “Can’t Buy Me Love.” David Archuleta shaking his hips is something I don’t need to see. Thanks a bunch.

The kids cry for “Help”. It’s probably their theme song right about now.

LOVED the group sing. So did Jim Carrey. And heh, there is Sanjaya Malakar and his sister Shyamali! They liked it, too.

Back from break, it’s time to get to work. Ryan asks, “Who will get the ticket to ride?” *blink* Ryan says that he’s looking for the three people with the lowest number of votes for the bottom three. He asks Carly Smithson, Michael Johns, Jason Castro and Syesha Mercado to stand up. Gosh, who could possibly be in the bottom three out of that bunch? So far, this isn’t exactly a nail-biter. Ryan begins, “…America voted, and Carly, you are safe.” He continues, “Michael, I need you…to take a seat, you are safe.” Michael, a little faked out, is relieved. Ryan lets the ladies scream for Jason before he says, “…America voted, you’ve connected with them, you are safe.”

Syesha Mercado is left. “After the vote, Syesha, you are in the Bottom 3 tonight.” She nods and joins Ryan center stage. The judges think sending Syesha home would be the wrong choice, but Simon believes she belongs in the Bottom 3. Ryan hands her the mic. The Bottom 3 will all be reprising their performances tonight. Time killer! She sings, still with the awkward pauses, but not smiling nearly as much as the night before. She screams one last note, and it’s an ear buster. Ouch.

Ford Commercial! How clever, the American Idol contestants as political candidates. Nobody has ever made that comparison before! Ahem. They sing, “The Distance” by Cake.

And it’s back to the results. Wait, no it’s not. First, we have to watch a weirdly edited tape. It’s a smoosh-up of the Idols attending the Horton Hears a Who premier over the weekend/sitting for their Top 12 official photos. It’s oddly framed by the Beatles’ “A Day in the Life”–”I saw a film today, oh boy…” Kill. Me. Now. At least the version of the song is a cover and not the genuine article. Whoever edited this clip must have been tripping. Literally.

Now, it’s really back to the results. Ryan asks Chikezie, Amanda Overmyer, Kristy Lee Cook and David Cook to stand up. David, why do you look so nervous? As if you’re even close to being in the Bottom 3. Ryan brings Chikezie down to the stage to tell him he’s safe. C’mon, after Chikezie’s break-out performance the night before, couldn’t y’all give him a break and stop playing with him? Amanda is safe too. And David Cook. Of course.

Kristy is left. Before Ryan even opens his mouth, she asks, “Where is my microphone?” Smart girl. Ryan says, “How do you know what’s happening?” She says, “Because I sucked big, giant donkey balls last night.” No, she doesn’t really say that, but she should have. After the blah blah run through of judges comments, Ryan finally tells her to grab the microphone. Kristy apologizes to the judges, and hopefully to all of America, “Sorry you have to hear it again.” Kristy babbles incoherently, like a confused pageant queen, when Ryan asks why she thought she was going. She sings out, and it’s not half-bad–she hits that last high note. Simon still hates it.

After the break, Ryan “takes some calls”. Most of the questions are directed at the judges, but A 12 year old asks Jason Castro, if he could be any American Idol judge, who would he be? Jason, who appears to be in a perpetual state of embarrassment, points out helpfully that Pauler is a girl, and then he mumbles something about Randy’s shoes. Simon rolls his eyes. Ronnie Paulie, aka “dumbass”, has auditioned for Idol 6 times and asks the judges for advice. Simon tells him to find another job. Ronnie walked right into that one. John Aaron wants to know when Simon and Ryan are going to “throw down.” Ryan says, “Load in the mud, I’m ready.” Simon says, “See you after the show, Ryan.” Ok, Simon didn’t say that, but it would have been awesome if he had. Ryan dumps the “Simon is sexy…” call. Jellus! A British lady living in the States asks Simon who he thinks are better singers, Americans or Brits. He says, “American singers have the most talent, however, on the judging panel, the Brits.” Wow, that Simon-so clever on his feet! Right. Well, as time-wasters go, that could have been worse.

Katharine McPhee and scary asshat David Foster are next, singing George Harrison’s “Something.” A nod to George. He deserves it, he wrote more incredible Beatles songs than I have time to list. Eh, I’m not loving Katharine’s diva take on “Something.” So, it’s safe to assume Katharine is all done singing “rhythm pop” since that didn’t work out for her too well? On to the next genre! She tries them on like clothes. Speaking of clothes, what the hell is she wearing? It’s some kind of hooker-flapper look. Not flattering. David Foster plays piano while Katharine sings. As Simon would say, the performance is very “old fashioned” and “cabaret”. I’m not feeling this at all. Eh. Still, I’m glad they are sticking to Idol alumni as musical guests. Foster says that he and Katharine will be making a record together. Goodbye “Open Toes”, we hardly knew ye!

It’s time for the last of the slicing and dicing. Cut to the contestants. Jim Carrey is out of his Horton costume, sitting with the kids. “I should have never done the REO Speedwagon thing, man.” I’m sure the Idols still awaiting their fates are loving this “comedy”.

Carrey seems to be finally done with his whoring for the night, and goes back to his seat. Ryan asks David Archuleta, Brooke White, David Hernandez and Ramiele Malubay to the center stage. David H. and Ramiele groan. “Let’s start with David…Archuletta…America voted…David, you get a chance to redeem yourself, you are safe.” Screams from the audience. David hugs Brooke, you can hear her say, “I’m so glad.” David goes back to his seat. “Now, let’s turn our attention to Brooke…America voted, you are safe, take a seat.” Brooke sits down.

Ramiele and David H. are left. Ryan goes through the judges comments with both. “…America voted, Ramiele…you are safe…which means David, you are in our Bottom 3.” Ryan asks David how he’s doing right now. How do you think, Ryan? What a stupid question. David says he’s pretty exhausted, but he’s fine, “It doesn’t necessarily mean I’m going home tonight, I’m just in the Bottom 3.” Yeah. David sings. On the verge of being eliminated, he has dialed the performance way back. It’s much less corny here. “Who is going home?” asks Ryan. Syesha and Kristy Lee join David on stage. “I’m going to send one of you to safety, one of you can relax…

…after the break.”

After the damn break, Ryan asks the judges what they think. Randy thinks it’s “probably” the right Bottom 3. Paula says she’s never seen a “more stronger” Bottom 3, but eventually admits, after some prodding from Simon, that America got it right. Simon says, “I think America got this absolutely spot on.”

“I can send one of you back to safety right now,” says Ryan, “that person coming back next week…Syesha, you are safe.” Syesha looks pained, smiles, and then goes back to her seat. “We are now left with Kristy and David…after 29 million votes, America has decided, that Kristy…” She narrows her eyes. “You are safe. David Hernandez leaves us tonight on American Idol.”

David and Kristy hug for a bit and exchange words before she goes back to her seat. “Here’s David, guys.” David gives the thumbs up. “Tough night, huh?” Gah, with the stupid questions, Ryan. David talks to his fans, “Things happen for a reason…you’ll see me at the top…this isn’t it for me…”

Ryan introduces the new boot song, “Celebrate Me Home” sung by Ruben Studdard. The song is a real tear-jerker. David’s goodbye video plays out over the credits.

Tonight’s elimination–not a surprise. Between the fall out from stripper-gate, and a horribly picked song performed horribly, David lost his spot. That’s how it goes in Idol land.

 
  • primeminister

    Yay, I think I got bonus points. The Carly pimping has begun.

    WHAT?! THE SAME THEME NEXT WEEK?!

    Jason sounded terrible in the group song. Bandzillaaaa.

    Could Michael get any more face time?

    POINTY POSE!!!!

  • s0x_prisoner

    Well I got 9 points in total this week. Wow that sucks :P

    If only Kristy had been voted off… :(

  • primeminister

    Ah just as I had expected: Kristy STAYS. However I put all my points into Syesha, not David H. It sucks that either Kristy or Syesha (or both! Gosh, I hope not…) will be on the tour.

  • t2

    Blech — wrong choice America.

  • longsong

    DANG!! We had to suffer through Kristy Lee Cook’s song again – FOR NOTHING!!!

    And I thought Jason sounded JUST FINE. I heart him.

    I tried to listen to Kat with an objective ear, but she sang “Something”!! Of course I couldn’t help but compare it to Taylor’s version, and she came up way short. When Taylor sang it, MAN.

    Is it my imagination, or did Kat keep singing the lyrics, “Don’t want to leave him now, you know I believe him now”? It was like a high school recital, no true emotion.

    I just don’t get why David Foster would want to work with her. I don’t!

  • primeminister

    I heart Jason too, but the group performance was not good. Couldn’t they have given him a more decent solo part? No, instead they had him run to the side and up the stairs so that he could sound like GASP Archuleta GASP.

    And then there was Bandzilla…

  • JOJOSIE

    I was sad to see David H go as I thought he was one of the better singers and I had hoped to see all three Davids for a while. AI is probably glad he’s gone as less controversy. I guess I’ll pick David C to vote for now as David A is just too young, too cute and too immature to be the American Idol IMO. I really wanted to like Katherine tonight as I think being with David Foster is a good move for her but Dawg I just didn’t get it tonight. Maybe because Taylor sang it so well. Like Paula said he didn’t over sing it he just did it great. I thought Katherine murdered a Beatle song tonight and I never thought I say that as I like to hear others sing Beatle songs. They are great songs and need to be sung.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    OMG!! Please don’t restart the wars. That was amazing. She is stunning, her voice is stunning. I’m literally shaking. There was SO much emotion in that song, her notes were fabulous. Everything was so great. She looked so happy. Ugh, love her.

  • http://idol-mania.com/american-idol-fan/ idol fan

    No way David H should have left before KLC and another round of Beatles, way to Milk it Nygel until we can’t stand it anymore….

  • longsong

    Could Michael get any more face time?

    I thought that was hilarious! People would be singing their solos, and he’d horn in….he stopped abruptly with the first one for some reason (I forget who it was with. Someone sitting on the stage). Maybe she poked him or something.

    I got a titter out of all that horning in.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    I just got my studio version of If I Fell by Jason on Itunes. I LOVE it.

    Love love love it.

  • longsong

    I’m having trouble with this site tonight, sadly! Anyone else?

    It’s not “restarting wars”, I’m just giving my honest opinion of Kat’s performance tonight.

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    UGH. I got no points. DAMN YOU AMERICA! Don’t you know you were supposed to send SyNOsha home?!

    Katharine. Bleh. Just my opinion. I never “got” her when she was on the show, and I never will. No one is starting wars. It looks to me like people are stating opinions. It amazes me that out of ALL the Beatles songs out there, they had her sing the one Taylor sang on the show. Just :rolleyes_wp:.

    Heading to iTunes to check out the recordings. THANK GOD these are full studio ones.

    ETA: yes longsong. I’ve been having trouble with the site. Chat disconnected for me right before the elimination, and then I couldn’t get back on here for like 45 minutes.

  • abbysee

    I am sorry Kat was horrible. If this was his way of saying see America this is what you passed up, he failed miserably.

    Carly was pimped tonight? Shoot, this was a freaking Michael John’s love fest. He might as well sang the group song alone. I mean seriously.

    This show needs to be shorter. Get the bottom two or three, sing the song, boot someone, cue the boot song, which I could not judge because I couldn’t hear it well, and good night.

    David H was robbed. Kristy became the Sanjaya of the season without the humor and excitement. Who the hell is voting for her, and can I pay them to stop please?

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Oooh, Tara, it’s up? I’m going to download Jason and Chikeze.

    Except for the outfit, Kat performed like she was on the Lawrence Welk show.

    Dang, Beatles again next week.

  • jdt

    VERY disappointed David Hernandez is gone….VERY….I’d have to say the worst elimination in Idol history…..1st one gone in the top 12? no way!

  • barefootgirl

    Arggh! Very disappointed 2 weeks in a row. No Danny or Hernandez on the tour. This sucks. America did not get it right.

  • longsong

    Miss Tara: I’m clueless on Itunes – do you have to have on Ipod? Or what do you download it onto? If the response would be too involved, there’s no need to bother. I would love to hear the studio version is all.

    I think the bottom three were right on tonight, and although it’s sad to see anyone go, I have a feeling the three were interchangeable and while it was David H’s turn now, it’ll be Syesha and whatsername’s next – in whatever order.

  • Sparkles

    I was hoping Kristy Lee would get the boot so she could go home & buy her horse back from the glue factory. No such luck.

  • longsong

    That poor, poor horse…

  • Sparkles

    That poor, poor horseà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦

    The horse? What about us? We had to hear that song twice. And who knows what she’ll do next week. That glue factory is looking pretty good right now.

  • Chicago-sally

    Somebody explain to me why the top 12 cannot go on tour. Why is it only 10? They should change it.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    longsong, just go to http://www.itunes.com download it…you don’t need an ipod. then you just set up an account, and buy the songs you want. usually .99 cents a song.

    i would so send it to you, but Itunes makes their songs protected Mp4s, and I don’t have the program to unprotect it and make it a Mp3.

  • St.Lucia

    UGH UGH UGH! KRISTY for another week! NO! Even David looked surprised…and he should be.

    Which preteen, tone deaf girls fingers do I need to pry off the telephone? Who on earth is voting for this tripe? I’m not the biggest fan of country music, but surely no country music fans actually consider her good…although she is the only “country”(as of last week) artist we have in this competition this year…so who knows.

    Let’s get her gone next week, please. Okay, thanks.

    Same theme next week…well I suppose, are you going to give them an even crappier selection of 25 songs the second time around, Nigel?

    HATED the phone call part. Was it only me that noticed the conveniently(grant it, I didn’t see the question) seem to skip over the “older” fans question(who was 50) and go towards the more younger questions? Or was that just me that noticed?

    Enjoyed Kat tonight, and I’m surprised to say that. I thought she did beautiful, in fact, it…almost made me miss her in a competition. She does have a beautiful voice. I was never a Kat fan, but after last year where I had no one to rally behind and this year of not nearly as stellar voices(oh wait, I forgot, it is the BEST SEASON EVAH!!!!!) , I thought Kat sang exquisitely.

  • MN Sue

    Sorry, to everyone but Nanny, but I really liked Kat’s performance. (Do I have to turn in my Soul Patrol walker?) I thought it was in her range and it was delivered with tenderness. She was beautiful! Just one thing, though. Could her dress have been any shorter? I bet the mosh pit got an eyeful.
    As expected David Foster stole Kat’s time to talk. I’m okay with that.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Jason’s recording is love. That. Is. All. :smile_wp:

  • primeminister

    Since there were only 25 songs to choose from last week, does this mean that they will pick from the remaining 13? The fight is ON!

    MJ, maybe we’ll get to see Jason do your pick!

  • primeminister

    I’m having trouble with iTunes. “The item you requested is not available.” GRRRR.

  • jpfan

    Very sad to see David Hernandez go. I’m not voting so I can’t complain but I’ll miss him alot. An hour elimination just too much. I really hated hearing all the bottom 3 murder their songs again.

    They didn’t announce the mentors for the season and are doing the Beatles AGAIN next week. That’s just weird.

    Kat sounded fine but the “look” and the “facial expressions” just didn’t work with I guess the new David Foster Kat. I was not a Taylor fan but if they were going to bring anyone back to do that song it should have been him.

    Also: Foster got to plus some stupid gig on Access Hwood and Real Love didn’t get a mention. Also weird.

  • longsong

    Thanks, Miss Tara!

    St. Lucia, I noticed Ryan conveniently, GLARINGLY skipping over the 50 year old caller as well! She was the last one on the screen and he skipped to the next page! He did ask a 40 year old’s question, but STILL.

  • St.Lucia

    Could her dress have been any shorter? I bet the mosh pit got an eyeful.

    HA! I thought the same thing! I was like wow, one wrong move and I’ll see more than I need to. The “mosh pit” I’m sure got more than they cared to see….or maybe not… lol.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    Jasonà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s recording is love. That. Is. All. :smile_wp:

    Isn’t it??? I’ve got it on repeat. I’m totally swooning. He has such a wonderful studio voice.

  • longsong

    DAYUM! My son’s asleep right now so I can’t get it until morning! Thanks again for the info Tara I CAN HARDLY WAIT!! I’ve watched Jason’s “Hallelujah” video over and over and over…..LOVE it! Need more songs!

  • jpfan

    Oh by the way Paula said this was the best bottom 3 in the history of American idol. That’s exactly what I was thinking when I heard them murder their Beatles songs. This is awesome.

  • http://myspace.com/girlgeek mj

    If you guys are downloading from iTunes, help support the site: Remember to click the iTunes link on my page. :) . Thank you!

    PS. Sorry about the site crapping out. I think a lot of people were trying to access the site to find out who was eliminated. I’m going to call the hosting folks tomorrow…

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Isnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t it??? Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ve got it on repeat. Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m totally swooning. He has such a wonderful studio voice.

    He does. So pretty and I love his quirky inflections. Randy needs to stfu.

  • longsong

    Will do, mj (iTunes). You’re a popular chickie!

  • tinawina

    Well, I put 8 points on David and I think I got a bonus question, so I did ok in the pool. I had 10 points on Syesha and 2 on Kristy. I thought Syesha going 1st gave her the edge over David and all the stripping, but I was wrong. There’s always next week!

    Beatles AGAIN? Shouldn’t they at least wait a few weeks? I don’t get that at all. Weird.

  • yesiyam

    In January, the announcement was all over the news. Ruben, Taylor, and Kat were dropped by their labels. Every news article and every blog never failed to mention Idol’s triumvirate of *fail*.

    Now Ruben is singing the Idol exit song. Kat is signed with David Foster. It is some form of redemption at least. But Taylor? Still dropped and faded into obscurity. Loves it.

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    On my iTunes, I can’t find where the tracks are available yet. Just the videos so far. Grrrrr.

  • barefootgirl

    “If I Fell” is truly beautiful. Is this the first full version download? The Hallelujah download sounds exactly the same as the live version except for the “fixed” note at the end.

  • Little Boy Blue

    I was not a Taylor fan but if they were going to bring anyone back to do that song it should have been him

    .

    Folks, the producers of Idol just want to FORGET about Taylor Hicks bucking their system and winning the title in Season 5. Which means Taylor is for all purposes, persona-non-grata on the show. It will snow in Hawaii if I ever see them invite him back ( in fact I don’t even think they’re showing his face in the opening credits at all ).

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Thanks for the reminder, MJ. Sarah, I noticed it says presale, but then if you scroll down they are there. I clicked on the AI link at the top. Works better than searching their names. Hope that helps.

    ETA: Barefootgirl, yes, this is the first week with studio versions.

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    If you guys are downloading from iTunes, help support the site: Remember to click the iTunes link on my page. :) . Thank you!

    MJ I click on your link every time I want to download something :thumbup_tb:

  • http://www.myspace.com/xmisstarax Miss Tara

    On my iTunes, I canà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t find where the tracks are available yet. Just the videos so far. Grrrrr.

    Sarah, I pre-order my Jason songs, and they always send an e-mail to me as soon as it’s released, and i just click from there. It usually takes it a hour or so to come up on Itunes.

  • Chicago-sally

    What does top 12 get you? If you can’t go on tour, what’s the point? Why can’t the top 12 go on tour?

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    I don’t search names. I search for “american idol performance” so it brings up the full list of songs, then click on names from there. On every one I clicked on (David C, Jason, Brooke, Michael, Carly, David A) it only had the video available for purchase. The song was still in preorder mode.

    ETA: pj, when I do it your way, and get to the individual pages, it has the songs listed, but when I click on the song, it says the item is not available. Again, does that for everyone I’ve tried.

    GRRRRR!!!!

    And I concur about the tour. It’s hella long, and it would just cut out time from others.

    Also, season 1 kinda set the precedent for the tour. Since there were only a top 10 that season, those 10 toured, and it has always been that. Apparently it works well, and they don’t have to pay expenses for two more people (and guardians if the contestant is under 18).

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Sally, have you ever been to a tour show? It’s long as hell. Add a couple more riff-raff and they’d never sell tickets.

  • MN Sue

    I loved David’s “Papa Was a Rolling Stone” as much as I hated “I Saw Her Standing There”. America did get it right. Kristy and Syesha’s voices were better than David’s last night. (Some of you know how much I dislike Syesha). David singing about a 17 year old girl and not being able to dance with another seemed against type and a little pervy to me. I agree with you, primeminister, putting one or both of these annoying leftovers on the tour would be painful.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Sarah, go to the main page of the store and click on the AI banner at the top. Then you can select your contestant. That’s what I did.

  • marymagdalene

    For me, I thought that Kat was just a’ight…

    I have always said (though maybe not here) that Kat has a LOVELY voice, but she just does not do it for me… I just think she uses “too many notes” though she does not do those ridiculous Mariah/Whitney runs…

    There were some songs that Kat did on AI5 that I thought she was great with, but others…

    Just curious, but what is wrong with doing a song JUST as it was written?
    Unless if you are a skilled interpreter of songs (Eva Cassidy, Harry Connick Jr, Bette Middler, Frank Sinatra, Rosemary Clooney, & et al),
    LET IT BE!

    As a total aside, when Michael was singing the refrain to “Across the Universe” I could have SWORN that he was singing “Jackaroo (something undistinguishable though kosher)” that I actually had to look up the lyrics to this song’s refrain, which are:

    “‘Jai Guru De Va Om
    Nothing’s gonna change my world
    Nothing’s gonna change my world.
    Nothing’s gonna change my world
    Nothing’s gonna change my world.’”

    HUH! I actually LEARNED something! LOL!

    Chikeze = WOW!!!
    David Cook = WOW!!!
    Brooke = WOW!!!

  • maracaibo

    Yay! I think I put half of my points on David H.
    He really was not good last night. Honestly, never cared for him. He can sing, but there’s nothing special about him.

    I wished Kristy would have been voted off instead, but I suspected that she was going to stay because of her looks and the only country girl.
    But America as Simon got it absolutely right. Spot on.

    Anyways, why are we having another Beatles night?
    Don’t they have enough creativity to bring on a new theme?

  • http://myspace.com/girlgeek mj

    MJ I click on your link every time I want to download something

    Thank you. :)

  • Chicago-sally

    Yeh, but why would you put so much emphasis on 12, when you want ten? I don’t get it. They should eliminate it down to 10. Anybody else see the story about David A.’s father being the stage father from hell?

  • JSG

    I’ve had a terrible time accessing this site today..but hey I’m finally in.

    To me, comparing Kat and Taylor’s versions of ‘Something.’ is sort of like apples and oranges.
    It was just good to see Kat’s deep rich voice back on the Idol. Wait a sec, I’m sounding like Paula.
    So the real lesson here is to make and keep the friends in high places you meet on Idol. And David Foster’s really not a bad fit. At least there’ll be no more ‘Open Toes.’ But please, no Whitney.

    Sorry to see DavidH go because I thought he had a real strong voice that would have held up on the Idol tour. But two mediocre performances will do it every tume.
    So this means Syesha makes the top 10. See ya Kristy.

    And they are tied at five each for the tour.

  • judy

    The hour long cruelty fest is way too much – they need to go back to 30 minutes and get it over with. Simon looked like he was ready to fall asleep. And what’s with all the stage time for Michael? And WHY did they make Jason run up the stairs, sing four words and then run back down? How stupid was that?

    I’m just sick that David H. went – there was a lot of potential there. I really liked him. Seemed like a nice guy, great voice, good attitude, not too much ego. Once again, I foolishly hoped Carly would be the shocking elimination. And……….. another damn week of Kristy.

    Same old Katharine with a shorter dress. Beautiful girl. great voice, but no passion – just that robotic, technically perfect singing. David Foster – what an ego, what a stage hog!! Kind of left Kat just standing there to get his plugs for himself in. One good thing – he seems to have toned down the screech in McScreech so maybe he can dig and find some passion. What happened to the acting career?

  • Allen

    Kat did a wonderful job tonight, I thoroughly enjoyed it.

    Ugh to another week of Beatles though. This week was fine, but two weeks of the same thing is overkill.

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    OMG, this Doxology/Eleanor Rigby stuff is SHIT.

    I especially love how TMZ tries to “connect the dots” by pointing to an interview on AI Extra with Blake after last year’s finale where Blake mentions Doxology. And then implies that David C saw that, instantly decided “OMG I HAVE TO KNOW WHO THIS BAND IS!”, went to iTunes, downloaded Doxology’s version of the song, and then subsequently used “their” arrangement on iTunes.

    Yeah. Right. That’s exactly how it happened. Since, you know, I’m sure that David C watches AI Extra. Especially since he went to audition for AI because his brother asked him to go as moral support.

    Nice publicity stunt, manager. Contacting TMZ was stealth! And probably the best thing that could have happened for the band. So, the big deal now is???…

    /rant (sorry, just needed to get that out)

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    Sarah, go to the main page of the store and click on the AI banner at the top. Then you can select your contestant. Thatà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s what I did.

    That is what I’m currently doing. Still says not available when I click on the song.

  • meme

    I went to iTunes and downloaded Jason’s “If I Fell” this evening. I absolutely love his take on the song. I have had it on replay for over an hour. Next week Jason will be getting my votes. :exclaim_ee:

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile

    Could somebody please gift me with Jason’s full version of If I Fell? I was really hoping he would sing that for Beatles night and got my wish. Yay! I love me some Jason! Hee.

    Wow, I did so well in the pool today. :D I got all the bonus points. Yay! Too bad a little part of me didn’t want to see David H. go so soon (even though I am not his biggest fan and I thought he sucked last night), so I put my other 5 points on Syesha (whose performance last night I missed), as I would rather have seen her go before David (she’s good but really does nothing much for me). Kristy Lee, I knew, would not be going…yet.

    I’m back in the game! Woohoo!!!

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    LOL, Sarah. Breathe. I don’t think anyone cares about that “scandal.” Where did you see them connecting the dots? I didn’t see that on their site.

    ETA: Sorry they aren’t showing up for you on itunes. :-(

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Purps, you know I have your back. :-)

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile

    Oh, thanks, thanks, pj! *hugs*

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    PJ, I saw it on the TMZ tv show. It just came on here, and was their “lead” story. I saw it before I switched over to Leno. And yeah, I don’t think it’s a big deal and that anyone really cares too terribly much. I just needed to vent. I swear I’ll shut up about it now. :)

    And yeah. I guess AI just doesn’t want my money tonight. I’ll try to get them in the morning. I’m definitely getting David C, Jason, Michael, and Brooke. Maybe Carly and Chikezie too.

  • KrazeeK120

    The show was pure torture. There is no reason to have it be 1 hour long and to hear the bottom 3 sing again! Isn’t that why they’re in the bottom 3?? Because the are NOT good and America wants them GONE?? The only part of the show I really enjoyed was Katharine, and I by no means am a Katharine fan. I thought that the bottom 3 would be who it was, but I thought one of the girls would be going home.

    And, really, why do we have to have the same theme 2 weeks in a row? I really like the Beatles, but enough is enough. Also, this theme did not work out so well for TCO…I he going to have another disaster next week?

  • primeminister

    Still not available to me. I need Jason to soothe me while I stress about my miderm tomorrow. lol

  • Kirsten

    Anyways, why are we having another Beatles night?

    Because Nigel is a HUGE Lennon and McCartney fan. He’s hoping that if he does the Beatles theme often enough, everybody will be eventually pushed so far out of their comfort zone that we’ll have an entire night of Kristy Lee quality performances. If that doesn’t cause John Lennon to roll over in his grave, stand up, and come to beat Ryan about the head with his own shin bone, I don’t know what will (but, then, I thought Kristy Lee’s performance was bad enough that I’m surprised that didn’t already happen).

    After that, John might agree to write a few more songs with Paul before returning to his crypt.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Ah, I see Sarah. I haven’t watched the TMZ show. Sorry you can’t get the downloads yet. You too, primeminister. I was able to download Jason and Chikeze. :)

  • bluegreen

    I too was surprised to hear they’re taking another stab at the Lennon-McCartney songbook next week. But the Beatles fan in me goes, Woo. Way Woo. I guess I’m just an optimist, and so I’m hopeful that with a second week to familiarize themselves with the material, everyone will have a chance to do really well. They’re the greatest songs and there’s so much to choose from, every mood, every style, it’s just up to each of them to relax and most of all, to pick the right song. So, Woo.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    If they were gonna repeat the theme, the should have waited a few weeks.

  • cheese

    TMZ has a tv show?

    Yay! I got David C’s recording. Jason’s is next on my list. Anyone who didn’t care for Eleanor Creedby last night might like David’s recording just fine. It’s more Eleanor Vedderby – a bit more subdued and he sounds just great. And it doesn’t sound like Doxology’s recording except for the fact that they’re both rock arrangements of the same Beatles song. :P

    If they must do Beatles week again, they should wait until top 5 or 6. At the very least, they need to open up the songbook a little wider. I want to hear Brooke sing Blackbird, Jason on Norwegian Wood, David on Don’t Let Me Down or I’ve Just Seen a Face, Michael on Oh Darling, etc.

    I want Syesha and Kristy off my TV. Why did Jason and David C get like 5 words a piece in the group song?

  • jdt

    David Hernandez

  • Little Boy Blue

    If next week is another Lennon McCartney, I’d like to hear Amanda slow it down and do a bluesy version of OH DARLING ( and yes, she can evoke Janis Joplin if she likes ).

    Michael John should try THE LONG AND WINDING ROAD

    Jason Castro should try GIRL ( without the guitar )

    I’d like to hear David Cook try HEY JUDE

    Brooke White should up-tempo a bit after two weeks of slowness with You Won’t See Me ( if Ann Murray can do it, she can too ).

    Kristy Lee has a chance to redeem herself with Mother Nature’s Son ( John Denver countrified it and it worked ).

    Ramiele can try YESTERDAY since this is one that’s closest to a ballad.

    David Archuleta can highlight his ability to emote ( if he can ) by trying THIS BOY

    After 2 weeks of lively songs, Chickezie should try to wow us with a ballad — MICHELLE

    I’d really love to see Carly tackle Fool On The Hill

    Sysha could probably try TICKET TO RIDE. Karen Carpenter did it in the 70′s.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    Yay! I got David Cà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s recording. Jasonà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s is next on my list. Anyone who didnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t care for Eleanor Creedby last night might like Davidà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s recording just fine. Ità ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s more Eleanor Vedderby – a bit more subdued and he sounds just great.

    LOL. You convinced me. Oh, and Doxology looking for a bit of press? It’s hard out there for a pimp. I mean band. I don’t blame them. LOL.

  • Terrie

    MJ, I know we share some musical tastes (Rundgren, Costello, etc.) and I think we’re around the same age. Like you, the Beatles were a hugely influential part of my childhood. At age 7, my first crush was on Paul when I saw him on Ed Sullivan, although I grew to prefer John musically. I know every syllable and note of every song in the Beatle catalog, too, even if I haven’t heard them in ages. I watched the cheesy Beatles cartoon on Saturday mornings. My preteen friends and I fell for the “Paul is dead” hoax. I remember where I was when I heard the Beatles broke up.

    Thanks for bringing back warm, fuzzy feelings of an exceptional and exceptionally innovative era. I love the 80s, but the 1960s was undoubtedly the most creative decade in rock ‘n’ roll, led by Lennon and McCartney.

  • Kirsten

    So, I’m guessing that if this week was “Early Beatles” (plus whatever-they-wanted-to-sing for a few select precious ones), next week will be “Late Beatles”. Are songs like “Let It Be” back on the table? Can people repeat? Is David A getting counselling since he’s already sung the one Beatles song he knows and he sucked at even that? Has anybody seen Nigel since last night? Has he had to seek a spot in the witness protection plan after David A’s Stage Dad heard about the repeat of the “killer theme”?

  • Grammie Kari

    So sorry to see David H. leave tonight! I believe his singing career has been jump started by being on AI. David’s “Papa Was a Rolling Stone” performance ranks right up there with the best on the show. Darn, he won’t be on the tour!

    Jason will be though; love him!

    IMO, Kat still remains the most beautiful woman to appear on AI and her singing was pretty good tonight.

  • maracaibo

    Is Michael Johns single “Across the Universe” already available?
    I so want to buy his song, he made me feel it. He did a great job last night and his voice sounded incredible.
    I am going to go check I-Tunes now and see.

  • moody

    An hour long results show is way too much. Too much useless filler–movie pimping, stupid questions, sing-outs by all of the bottom 3. It seemed disjointed and awkward tonight. Maybe they’ll work the kinks out eventually.

    Kat sounded okay to me. Parts of it were good, other parts just okay. And David Foster is still creepy.

    I need to watch Syesha’s (mock)sing-out again. Was it just me or did she hold that last note long after the music ended? I was afraid Ryan was going to have to wrestle the mic away from her.

    I was laughing when Kristy asked for the mic. Ryan seemed a little irritated. Well, duh, she was the last one standing in that group and everyone else was safe. It followed the exact same pattern as the first group of 4.

  • jpfan

    I have absolutely no idea if David Cook heard the Eleanor Rigby version done by Doxology but since the band is one of Blake Lewis’ favorites, why does everybody here assume they’re just a bunch of fame whores trying to get some AI promo. Blake who seems to take music seriously lists them as musical role models. So maybe when they say Cook borrowed from them they’re not just full of crap.

    Again I have no idea if they’re full of it or not. Nor do I think in the end it matters but why the big rush to judgement.

  • primeminister

    maracaibo, yeah, Michael did do a great job last night. Great song for him.

    All the songs are up on iTunes! Does Jason sound WAY better or what? (Talk about a beautiful recording voice!)

  • Terrie

    I developed an early preference for David Hernandez, a hybrid of my all-time AI favorites Clay and Elliott, until he went melodramatic and super-mellismatic on us. Still, I wish he made the tour.

    Are we really having Beatles redux? I was looking forward to Jason’s interpretation this week of You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away or Norwegian Wood or For No One or Blackbird or Julia (probably too soporific). Brooke could have one of his castoffs.

    If Michael performs A Day in the Life with its slumberous verse and bouncy bridge, it could be the breakout moment he needs. Otherwise, I’d like to hear him try She Came in Through the Bathroom Window. I want him to hang around long enough to perform Neil Finn on Split Enz Night (in my dreams).

    If David Cook chooses Dear Prudence or I Am the Walrus, he’ll get slammed for copying Siouxsie or Oasis. Better that he should pick I’m Only Sleeping or Things We Said Today, different sounds and styles to help him avoid musical monotony a la Daughtry. If Alone Again Or by Arthur Lee & Love was ever available and suitable for a future theme, he would do it justice. Since Constantine expanded the AI repertoire in season 4, I’ve been wanting someone to sing Jeff Buckley’s Last Goodbye and, as Jason probably won’t be revisiting that album, I’d like to see Cookie try.

    You may say I’m a dreamer, but Jason made me a believer.

  • http://myspace.com/saltwatercures pj

    jpfan, I love Blake and I like Doxology. It’s not unreasonable that David Cook found their version through that connection. However, it’s pretty random. So, I’m not buying it.

  • cheese

    I really have no opinion on Doxology’s motives and do not think they’re full of crap or famewhores. I’m just not so much hearing the similarities. I don’t see what Blake has to do with it. I also don’t think it’s strange that 2 different modern rock acts would come up with a similar take on the same iconic song. David’s version sounds more like Godhead’s version, if anything. At most, he probably clicked on a couple of different samples at iTunes and concluded that yes, Eleanor Rigby can be rocked out a bit. It’s not like he just fell off the turnip truck musically. His recording doesn’t sound anything like the live performance.

  • primeminister

    Carly doesn’t sound good at all. What’s with the helium voice? She was better live, imo.

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    mj, I keep clicking the itunes link but it’s not coming up. Wait, it just came up in my toolbar – never mind!

    Of course I”m buying Jason but I’m also buying Chekezie – he deserves it. Hey, do these guys get any of the proceeds? Not that I’d stop buying because the download numbers endear them to that freak, Clive.

    Kat was okay tonight. Voice was fine but hello, is anyone home? She really has a problem in the performance. It amazes me that she wants to pursue acting. Just doesn’t have the ability to connect with alot of the market.

    If Kristy isn’t kicked off next week, I might have to go for impatient care.

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    deleted double post

  • Kirsten

    I have absolutely no idea if David Cook heard the Eleanor Rigby version done by Doxology but since the band is one of Blake Lewisà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ favorites, why does everybody here assume theyà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢re just a bunch of fame whores trying to get some AI promo.

    I listened to the Doxology version of Eleanor Rigby on YouTube interleaved with listening to David Cook’s version.

    Okay, I’ll grant that the melody is the same (but that would be kind of expected, no?), but the arrangements didn’t seem to be the same and David Cook certainly sang it differently (and without the sign language that the Doxology lead singer seemed to feel was necessary). The opening riffs are not even the same (and the ending is totally different). The only thing the seems the same about them is that they are both rocky versions.

    AI is a pretty big deal (see what it did for Jeff’s 14 year old song last week). It would be tempting to tie your wagon to a popular contestant on AI. Heck, I’d never heard of Doxology until tonight and now I’ve checked them out, so score one for publicity.

    David was given a task of singing The Beatles. There are a gazillion covers of Beatles songs. One would be hard pressed to come up with a genre twist that hasn’t been tried before. Just because they are both rocked up versions of the same song doesn’t mean that David C copied some non-mainstream band.

    I’m not surprised that Blake has heard of Doxology. Both he and the band are from Seattle. They probably shared a stage together. It would be a little harder for a bartender from Houston to have heard of them. LOL. Doxology (the band) doesn’t even have a wiki page yet.

    BTW I will almost be willing to bet my house that nobody tries to claim that Kristy Lee ripped off their version of “Eight Days a Week”

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    Help — I don’t want the video, I want the mp3 or 4, whatever. It doesn’t appear!

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    Oh, I read an article this week that itunes has imbedded a tracker in their software so they can track you ALLLLLLLL ovah the internet. Disturbing. Yet I still keep clicking.

  • primeminister

    carolina-

    Eh? Tracking what exactly? That IS disturbing.

    By the way, you’ll love Jason’s. Amazing, I tell you, amazing. I’m smitten.

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    Tracking everywhere you visit on the internet. I’ll see if I can find the link.

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    Originally I saw the link on Drudgereport. I don’t know if this is the same article that was posted there but here’s one I found quickly that addresses that.

    http://www.mcelhearn.com/article.php?story=20060111150127268

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile

    Yeh, but why would you put so much emphasis on 12, when you want ten? I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t get it. They should eliminate it down to 10.

    Mandisa has this to say on that…

    …several of you have asked why only the top 10 go on tour as opposed to the top 12. Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m afraid I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t have a good reason for ya. Simply put, it is because that is what the producers want. It could be because it adds a little more drama knowing that the first 2 contestants to go home after we hit the big stage are missing out. It just is what it is…

    Mandisa’s blog on AI Top 12

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile
  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    If they must do Beatles week again, they should wait until top 5 or 6. At the very least, they need to open up the songbook a little wider.

    Exactly… I’d really prefer they save it for a later week when the fodder has been weeded out for the most part and the real contenders can take a crack at more than one song. Top 5 would be a PERFECT week for a second Beatles theme. Nigel’s jumping the gun here, methinks.

    And re: Doxology. Cheese, PJ, and Kirsten are much more succint than I was. :) I agree with them.

  • dancin

    performances. If that doesnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t cause John Lennon to roll over in his grave, stand up, and come to beat Ryan about the head with his own shin bone, I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t know what will (but, then, I thought Kristy Leeà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s performance was bad enough that Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m surprised that didnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t already happen).

    lmaooooooooo i was saying almost the same thing to my kids last nite about this eheh ur a hoot kirsten

  • http://www.myspace.com/swood1104 Sarah

    Finally got the downloads!! Have listened to David, Jason, and Michael so far. They all have good recording voices, and I really like the studio versions they did of these songs.

    Now, on to Brooke, then on to work. :)

  • dusty

    I have always thought the two that did not make the tour were back ups for the tour should something happen to one or two of the touring contestants-like literally breaking a leg, being in an accident, etc.

    One benefit in being in the top 12 is that only one person is eliminated per week as opposed to the previous 4 per week.

    Another is the celebration of the top 12 by AI, the press, etc. More people in the US know your name than the name of the Chief Justic of the Supreme Court in the US. So the exposure is worth a lot.

    As for AI, they have their schedule down pat with FOX and have stretched the program from mid January through May sweeps.

    Here are the two main Nielsen Sweeps periods that span this year’s AI:

    February 2008: 31 January – 27 February, 2008

    May 2008: 24 April – 21 May, 2008

    Performing well during these periods sets the advertising rates for the show.

    So, doubtful they would mess with that schedule except to do as they have done, to make the eliminations one hour to sell more ad time.

    IMO they could make the top 24 reveal night show longer– make it 2 hours and give adequate airtime to ALL who make the top 24. But that doesn’t work with their pimping agenda.

    (Ten of the 24 who made the top 24 were barely shown on the top 24 reveal night, and 8 of those 10 did not make the top 12.)

    I was not bored with the full hour last night. Maybe it is reading MJ’s write-ups over the years, but I look forward to the group number and reveal of the week’s goofy Ford ad. All that cheesy goodness, to quote MJ.

    And the repeat singout? I think Kristy may have Haley Scarnato’d herself into the top 10 after looking so fetching last night–I thought she looked and sang better than on performance night. Syesha, on the other hand, was more overcome last night than on performance night. And David was the right call. He just didn’t have the fan support compared to the others in the top 12. Syesha got some diva support, Kristy some country music fan support, etc. And doesn’t the bottom two person who wasn’t eliminated usually get saved by fans the next week? So, imo, Syesha will be the next likely to go, not Kristy.

    And if the results show isn’t a full hour, then how will AI pimp some other stuff? Note to Jim Carey–you are not the first person to go sit with the AI performers as they wait to find out if they were eliminated. Brad Garrett did it to pimp his Fox show, and there may have been others who have done it as well. It would have been a lot funnier if you had left your Horton costume on–because the visual gag of sitting there with the contestants would have been funny.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    What happened to the acting career?

    Her first movie, “The House Bunny” where she plays a pregnant girl named Harmony comes out in August, unless they change the date. There is already tons of press about it, so you will be hearing more about I’m sure. I can’t wait to see her on the big screen.

    I soooo don’t get the not connecting thing, I mean to each their own, I respect all of your opinions, everyone’s is different and that’s fine, but I have connected with that girl in every single thing she has performed, I and so many other people think she’s just amazing.

  • calimari

    Is it my imagination, or did Kat keep singing the lyrics, à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t want to leave him now, you know I believe him nowà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ?

    That’s how I heard it too, which bugged me, as the lyrics are “you know I believe and how.” She looked pretty enough, the refrains sounded off to me. Didn’t come close to Taylor’s version, although you would expect it to be different w/ a woman’s touch. I thought she went too big on it like she did w/ that elvis tune. She should have sung it simply instead of going all power note on it.

    Bored to death w/ the phone in calls, which were mostly for judges & not contestants, the whole Jim Carrey time waster, and seeing ALL THREE bad performances again. Correct bottom 3, but wrong one went home.

  • hicksaholic

    I’m in the didn’t get Katharine category. She seems to smile and look heavenward at the most inappropriate times. She just doesn’t seem to communicate a song’s meaning(at least not to me). Taylor’s version although probably not better technically was head and shoulders above Katharine’s IMO

    David Hernandez should have stayed- Kristi Lee Cook is awful and I got the feeling watching her in the bottom three she knew she wasn’t going home.

    The group number was probably the worst in Idol history which is really surprising considering these are SUPPOSEDLY “the best top twelve EVAH”

  • bean99

    BTW I will almost be willing to bet my house that nobody tries to claim that Kristy Lee ripped off their version of à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Eight Days a Weekà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ 

    :lol_tb:

    I was so bummed last night about David H going home instead of Kristy. It makes me nervous that a guy might go next week. I thought David’s performance last night was better than Tues. and he might have stayed longer if he’d done it that way. I refused to listen to Kristy again.

    Ditto about the phone calls/texts. Boring. I did think the group sing was pretty good. You’ll never find me complaining that there’s too much Michael, lol. Kat sang well although my favorite version will always be George Harrison’s. I don’t know why we need another Beatles week. I’d love to hear them sing more current songs for once.

    I think there are some that need to mix things up next week. Ramiele needs to pick a faster, more fun song. I’m not sure what she’s been thinking in her song choices. Brooke and Jason should consider stretching a bit and going out of their comfort zone. I can’t see either of them on stage doing anything other than playing an instrument or sitting/standing in one place. Chikeze needs to continue to wow next week. Michael needs a money song and I hope it’s a faster one next time although loved Across the Universe. David A needs to remember his lyrics. :rolleyes_tb:

  • LoveU

    Another Beatles night next week is only a plus if the intended theme were originally Gloria Estefan. I have yet to see anyone perform well on those type of nights.

    It seems unfair as everyone has already picked his/her best choice.

    Having Kat sing “Something” was a bad decision.

  • JJ

    I thought Kat was pretty awful last night. She was flat in spots and I still find her voice annoying.

    I will vote for ANYONE (well excpet for Kristy Lee) who does Rocky Raccoon.

    I agree that I think A Day in the Life could be Michaels breakout performance. He hasn’t been singing that well lately, but damn, he is still hot.

  • Allison

    I’m disgusted that Kristy is still around to torture us again next week.
    Also not too jazzed about a repeat theme.

  • sciencefan

    Don’t forget – according to Ryan, it was because of calls from fans that they decided to do another Beatles Night. Oh really? Which fans? Maybe they should have specified, “in a few weeks from now”.

    I was a Kat fan that year, but last night I was reminded that it was only because she was the lesser of the evils. I didn’t “love” anyone that year. Kat has an indistinct voice. If I heard her on the radio, I would not recognize it was her. She sounds just the same as a hundred beauty pageant contestants. She was pretty and her notes were perfect, but she forgot to smile, and she didn’t even know the right words! What’s the matter?! Don’t they look up the words?!

    btw: David H. did that too.
    WAY beyond compare – not FAR beyond!
    He sang, “it was plain to see” – instead of “I, I could see”
    No! No! No! You can’t do that David!
    Hope he gets a singing job. It would be a shame if he had to go back to stripping to make a living.

    Jason run up the stairs and run back down – yes, that was perplexing. Jason is very charming and has the fresh sound that seems so stylish right now. I’m glad to see so many fans here. One thing interesting about his AI video is that he had only performed 5 times in public before he started on AI. He’s a real sweetheart. I hope we get to see a lot of him. I would definitely buy one of his albums.

  • Allison

    Nanny Mcphee
    Mar 12th, 2008 at 10:43 pm
    OMG!! Please donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t restart the wars. That was amazing. She is stunning, her voice is stunning. Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m literally shaking. There was SO much emotion in that song, her notes were fabulous. Everything was so great. She looked so happy. Ugh, love her.

    It’s funny how one person can be entranced, and another is left cold. I thought Kat was alright, but she didn’t seem to connect to the song IMO. Didn’t she botch the lyrics? Her face is pretty, but the short skirt shrieks “I’m SEXY”. She would have been more classy with more coverage.

  • Allison

    HATED the phone call part. Was it only me that noticed the conveniently(grant it, I didnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t see the question) seem to skip over the à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“olderà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  fans question(who was 50) and go towards the more younger questions? Or was that just me that noticed?

    No I noticed it right away, too. Way to go Idol discounting adult viewers.

  • Ladybug

    Having Kat sing à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Somethingà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  was a bad decision.

    Agreed.

    I think we are seeing our future bottom 2/3 with the 2 who remained last night plus ??? (insert bad performer here, except David Archuleta). They will have to deliver killer performances to climb up out of there. I did not see a single surprise last night.

    I don’t know how I feel about another Beatles week, but better that than disco. And if it will keep any and all Whitney at bay, that is not entirely a bad thing.

  • sciencefan

    “I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t know how I feel about another Beatles week, but better that than disco. And if it will keep any and all Whitney at bay, that is not entirely a bad thing.”

    tee-hee
    When you put it THAT way, I agree!

  • JJ

    I really like Jason Castro’s voice, it is very soothing. I just realized who he reminds me of, he reminds me of Jack Johnson. I actually put Jack Johnson CD’s on in the car because the kids don’t fight or aruge when they are on. (I’m not kidding, his voice is soothing).

    I think Jason is starting to fall into a trap, everything he does is very soft. Jack Johnson songs are soothing, but tend to be a bit peppier. If it ever fits into a theme, I would like to see him to any of the following:

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=pNlmn7vbXBQ

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=nrZwGGKGkuU

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=u57d4_b_YgI

  • primeminister

    Better Together is one of my favorites.

    And yes, Jason needs to do a more upbeat song next.

  • ericalina

    Her face is pretty, but the short skirt shrieks à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m SEXYà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ . She would have been more classy with more coverage.

    Kat was never known for her ability to cover up. She also could have done better than a ponytail with a cocktail dress, but that is neither here nor there. I was reminded last night why I never voted for her — zero connection. I thought Carrie Underwood was robotic back in the day! Kat puts her to shame.

  • geekygirl

    Watched the clips, shame David H didn’t deserve to go yet. Interesting that any of the males that have been openingly gay or setting off gaydar are gone. I thought David had a great voice but was pretty crap at picking songs.

    And laughing at the group song, more Like Michael Lee and his backup singers! lol

  • beesims

    And laughing at the group song, more Like Michael Lee and his backup singers! lol

    Did anyone else notice the huge droplet of sweat that came flying off Michael’s face during the group sing? If he sweats this much during Idol, imagine the buckets he must be shedding during tennis or footie.

  • JJ

    Did anyone else notice the huge droplet of sweat that came flying off Michaelà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s face during the group sing? If he sweats this much during Idol, imagine the buckets he must be shedding during tennis or footie.

    Such a lovely thought.

  • jersey

    Uh Oh, JJ and the sweat again!

  • Nanny Mcphee

    Having Kat sing à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Somethingà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  was a bad decision.

    In your opinion, I thought she was fabulous. Katharine is anything but robotic, she was putting an emotion into what she was doing, she was trying to express the sincerity of the song. I can’t argue with how you all feel, but Katharine has done some really amazing performances that are FULL of personality and fun and emotions. She is an amazing person as well as perfomer. I think as non-kat fans you all have missed out on some of the things that she has done. Amazing, Amazing things. Not just professionally, but personally too. I really wish some of you knew what kind of person she really is. It’s a shame that you will never know, but to each his own. I’m just so happy that I am a Mcphan. There is so much more to come and I can’t wait for it. :smile1_tb: :wub_tb:

  • JJ

    Uh Oh, JJ and the sweat again!

    Don’t blame me, beesims started it.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile

    Did anyone else notice the huge droplet of sweat that came flying off Michaelà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s face during the group sing? If he sweats this much during Idol, imagine the buckets he must be shedding during tennis or footie.

    Such a lovely thought.

    Why am I not surprised at this reaction, JJ? LOL

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    I’d like Jason to do some Tracy Chapman —

    Baby, Can I Hold You — not all puppy and rainbows

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjRo_CHSdt0&feature=related

    or my fav, The Promise

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISSTz1xxdRw

    He could spice it up and I have to say Randy is so stuck — I love how Jason floats the notes.

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    JJ – I noticed that as well!~ heh.

    NannyMcPhee, I have to give you props for always staying on task!

  • ParticleHustler

    Since the worst thing about this show is the music, any chance I have of them performing music I actually like is fine with me.

    I hope Amanda does Helter Skelter, and I really think Brooke could do a fantastic job with Norwegian Wood.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile

    Purps, you know I have your back. :-)

    I already have a copy of the full version of If I Fell! Yay! I love, love it! Thanks for offering to get it for me, pj. :)

    I also love MJ’s Across The Universe. I am officially a fan. I really like his voice.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    NannyMcPhee, I have to give you props for always staying on task!

    Thanks Carolina, I just look at it as my job as a fan. It pains me to see some of these things written here, but instead of getting all defensive I’m just going to give my opinions on why I think Katharine is so fabulous, just like most of you give your opinions on how you think she isn’t. :cry_wp:

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/iamthepurplewalrus purplesmile

    I didn’t get to see the results show, so thanks for the great, very detailed recap, mj. :)

  • http://myspace.com/girlgeek mj

    I really wish some of you knew what kind of person she really is. It’s a shame that you will never know, but to each his own.

    Nanny, I could care less what kind of person she is. It really doesn’t matter. It has nothing to do with her singing.

    I feel the same way about all the other Idols.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    Nanny, I could care less what kind of person she is. It really doesnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t matter. It has nothing to do with her singing.

    I was really just addressing the people that think Kat is some kind of shallow, selfish, vapid bitch. None of which are true. She does amazing things for other people, she’s opening Katharine Mcphee’s school for girls in Africa sometime in the next year. Sexy Hair gave her a check for 10k to go towards it, there are just a lot of things about her that people who think she’s such an awful person for making fun of Meatloaf or giggling when someone made fun of Elliott’s teeth don’t know about her. That’s all I was trying to point out. As far as all of the other idols go they don’t get bashed constantly over here. EVER. So like I said I’m just being a fan and letting people know that Katharine Mcphee is a good person. Her singing is up to the individual that is listening to it. I’m not trying to make anyone love her singing like I do, but I can state my opinions on how I feel about it.

    That’s not breaking any guidelines is it?????

  • http://myspace.com/girlgeek mj

    Thatà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s not breaking any guidelines is it?????

    Technically no. But the defending is OTT, and it’s becoming too much. You’ve made your point, several times.

    I was really just addressing the people that think Kat is some kind of shallow, selfish, vapid bitch.

    Every comment in this thread about Kat has addressed her performance on the show. The criticism has been reasonable.

    This site is not designed for the intensely-invested fan. Vociferously defending your favorite everytime someone says something negative about her becomes pointless after awhile, and not that interesting to read.

    I would suggest letting it be for now.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    Youà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ve made your point, several times.

    4 times!!! I’ve talked about Kat and her performance 4 times, once or twice before she even performed and then twice after she performed, everyone else in here has stated several times how they didn’t like it and how Taylor’s was better and it was a big mistake, the same people too, saying the same things!!!!! How am I different from those people? Just forget it. I’ll stop now.

    It has been a lot more civil than usual though I will admit that, some non-fans actually enjoyed it. Every conversation I have had has been civil, until now, because for some reason I annoyed you, but I guess that’s all that really matters, it’s your blog after all.

  • http://inkdbylilyanna.com carolina

    Kat is opening a school for girls in Africa? She’s copying Oprah?

    I hope she has tons more money than $10,000.00.

    Really, I find that OTT. Why not start a nice day care in Watts for the local needy children. That would be actually do-able.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    Kat is opening a school for girls in Africa? Sheà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s copying Oprah?

    I hope she has tons more money than $10,000.00.

    Really, I find that OTT. Why not start a nice day care in Watts for the local needy children. That would be actually do-able.

    It’s a new charity she’s involved with. Her peeps she models hair products for gave her 10 grand to go towards it. It was all announced at the American Beauty show where she was a model. I’m not sure of all the details, but their is a youtube video with the announcement. The video also has an upcoming album announcement too. I won’t even bother posting it though. I’ll just wait for it to come up in a blog or on some program, then maybe. MAYBE. it might get posted here.

  • http://idolstages.com Connie D.

    The show last night left me cold. Every song and event made me comment out loud “That’s not right”. Before the end of the hour, people had to “shut me up”. I’m not blaming the kids, only the producers.

    Carly’s failure to look at Michael even once during the group song when it was appropriate to do so: That’s not right.

    Katharine’s dress and performance: That’s not right.

    Squandering the opportunity to use Jason’s talents effectively: That’s not right.

    David Hernandez leaving before Top 10: That’s not right.

  • GwendolynD

    Thanks for the recap, MJ. Ruben’s song…”Celebrate Me Home”…I’ve heard that before. Did Clay Aiken sing it? Anyone know?

  • http://myspace.com/girlgeek mj

    I won’t even bother posting it though. I’ll just wait for it to come up in a blog or on some program, then maybe. MAYBE. it might get posted here.

    Nanny, this is what I’m talking about. Just accept that there are people here who don’t like Katharine, and keep the sarcasm out of it.

    I have to say, the “fan crusaders” who drop by here just to defend their favorites…I don’t understand. And I don’t really like it. This blog is what it is. If what you read here makes you angry, It’s probably not the place for you.

    So here is the thing. You can say all the positive things about Katharine that you want. But, please, leave it at that. Don’t judge or make comments about people’s opinions e.g.: wishing out loud that they felt differently, saying you feel sorry for them because they don’t see what you see, or that the negative remarks upset you. Maybe I’m not making myself clear when I mod you, but THAT’S the sort of thing that annoys me, and it really is against the guidelines.

    And yes, it is my blog. It stops here. No more arguing the point with me.

  • primeminister

    Okay so I just watched the show in full (darn midterms!)…

    Kristy Lee Cook isn’t too annoying. Also, I’m saying this after having stayed up LATE, but she doesn’t have a bad voice. I actually watched through the whole performance.

    On the other hand, all the cross promotio IS annoying.

    I found the Kat and David Foster collaboration a little disturbing. Oh and her dress…those lucky ones in the mosh pit sure got more than they were asking for.

    The call in questions were LAME. Paula is a girl, uh, and Randy’s shoes and Simon’s v-neck??? Wha?? Sometimes, Jason rivals Paula in loopiness, but they’re cute. Both of them.

    I feel bad for David H., but hopefully, those TMZ rumors are correct.

    Now it’s back to checking iTunes 100 times a day until the show starts again next Tuesday! (I need help….)

    CHEERS everybody!

  • primeminister

    Thanks for the recap, MJ. Rubenà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s songà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ Celebrate Me Homeà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ve heard that before. Did Clay Aiken sing it? Anyone know?

    He sure did! Someone posted Clay’s version in the comments when news about Ruben doing the boot song just came out.

    On a side note, MJ, it’s funny how excited you sound in your comments about the group sing. I’m glad one person enjoyed it! :D

  • ericalina

    Thanks for the recap, MJ. Rubenà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s songà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ Celebrate Me Homeà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢ve heard that before. Did Clay Aiken sing it? Anyone know?

    He sure did! Someone posted Clayà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s version in the comments when news about Ruben doing the boot song just came out.

    On a side note, MJ, ità ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s funny how excited you sound in your comments about the group sing. Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m glad one person enjoyed it! :D

    “Celebrate Me Home” is also a famous Kenny Loggins song from 1976. They play it a lot at Christmas time.

  • Nanny Mcphee

    I have to say, the à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“fan crusadersà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  who drop by here just to defend their favoritesà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬ ¦I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t understand.

    That is NOT at all what I am. You don’t have to worry about me annoying you anymore as this will be my last post here.

    Peace, Love and Mcphee. :bye_tb:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ON9kceXuEok

  • http://stores.ebay.com/BookWomanBlues-Book-Nook Bobbi

    I enjoy the group sings a whole lot more than the cross promotion and those idiotic phone calls! I also noticed the blatant disregard of the 50 year old caller. Nothing like sending a large portion of your audience the message that you can’t be bothered with them.

    I think I read here that next week’s theme was supposed to be the “year you were born” theme. I’d much rather have that and save a second Beatles week for later. But does AI know how to do anything subltly or with finesse?

  • jdt

    Still really disappointed Hernandez is gone so soon….I think he was VASTLY underrated…..he sorta reminded me of Elliott only his voice was more “smooth” and with less vibrato….plus, he was actually a much better stage presence than Elliott was….should’ve made it way past #12….

  • cat

    I’m sorry but David H. was far too cheezy. I kept expecting jazz hands at any moment.

    Not that Kristy should still be there, because she has sucked consistently throughout the competition thus far. The only way she could hope to do well is if they let her sing “Amazing Grace” every single week.