Here’s a melding of worlds.  American Idol 10 Top 24 contestant Tim Halperin and Hayley Orrantia, who was a member of Lakoda Rayne, X Factor’s dreadful faux-country girl group join forces to sing “What Makes You Beautiful” the single from X Factor UK boyband, One Direction. Whew!

I don’t even recognize Haley out of the horrible outfits Paula Abdul made her wear. I wonder how soul-crushing it was for her to participate in those God-awful performances on X Factor? Because she’s pretty good here.  Tim, who accompanies the duo on piano,  could have gone deep as a finalist on American Idol in a season that was more WGWG-friendly.  Season 10′s “Sudden Death” format didn’t do him any favors, either.

I will confess. The song, as performed  by One Direction is a guilty pleasure. So catchy. And kind of adorable.  The duo’s acoustic version replaces the cutesy with a grown-up yearning that works nicely.

Check it out below.

Tagged with:
 
  • Anonymous

    The One Direction vid is like a junior version of Westlife’s “If I Let You Go” vid – the latter having a better song, though, and shot more beautifully.

  • Anonymous

    very pretty voices – you know what I mean?

  • ronnie

    Tim used to be cute- what happened?

  • http://twitter.com/KWOnlyDreaming Karen W.

    Their voices blend well together!  Very nice!

  • Anonymous

    Beautiful girl but average voice…she’s still young and has time to develop it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/casslg87 Cassie Gildert

    I love Tim! And these two sound great together. Beautiful song.