He can’t survive an a’ight album. Adam, on the other hand, can. As can Allison.

I’d say the only difference is that Adam has Broadway to fall back on. If Adam (or Allison) doesn’t move units, they’ll get dropped, just like any other Idol who didn’t meet TPTB’s expectations

I suspect for example Jordin’s #2 album is going to do even better than her first album because she was able to take more time.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-RgdtQEL0Xo

There are supposed to be cell casts on Rickey TV tonight

I’m listening to it now as I type. No offense to Rickey, but it sounds horrid. Cell phone technology obviously wasn’t designed to transmit live concerts. If anyone used this “music” as an example of Idol talent, the contestants and the show would be finished!

UGH! I need to turn Rickey off! :thumbdown_tb:

I’d bet my house that these first albums from Adam and Kris are going to be just a’ight at best.

And Kris fans better hope you’re wrong, because that will be the end for Kris Allen. He can’t survive an a’ight album. Adam, on the other hand, can. As can Allison.

I’d bet my house that these first albums from Adam and Kris are going to be just a’ight at best. And I’m basing my opinion on watching these Idols release records year after year.

MJ, I have to agree. this is my first year really following Idol but I can’t see how anyone could end up with a great album considering the way these AI albums get put together — so many commenting masters, having to work on the album when not touring (a day here and there), and putting together original material in a couple of months.

I can’t see how any of them can focus on creative collaboration.

I guess I can hope for a miracle or two. But I will guarentee one thing both Adam and Kris will have at least one song that is better then NoBo.

I don’t know. I’m a writer and I know, when you are flying by the seat of your pants and letting it all happen, that’s when it’s magic. When you start over-thinking and over-producing, that’s when you start questioning yourself and get bogged down.

It’s not comparable. Writing is a solitary effort. Recording an album is collaborative, and there are many, many fingers in the pies here.

I’d bet my house that these first albums from Adam and Kris are going to be just a’ight at best. And I’m basing my opinion on watching these Idols release records year after year.

“As Adam said, RedOne is a genius that works on the fly.”

Red One is good. Chemistry between producer and artist is also important. Once there is the meeting of the minds, then the rest should be fast.

“When you start over-thinking and over-producing, that’s when you start questioning yourself and get bogged down. ”

Creative suffers when on over thinks and over analyze. I am in the advertising industry and we see this always happening in commercial creative development. Client always 2nd guess what the consumers wants and viola, they want everything in the material. This should not happen.

“I also know that I’ve listened to ‘Brigadoon’  (a tape-recording of a live, outdoor show) and it could not be more immaculate if you had all the production in the world behind it. The same thing goes for ‘Come Home’  and ‘I Just Love You,’  they are stellar. AND they are just recordings (one shot deals) of live covers.”

Yes, yes, yes. I can listen to these songs the whole day. For those who think that Adam’s music are not for radio airplay, they just have to listen to all these materials to realize that his songs are for radio airplay.

Perhaps because the artist is brilliant? The material? A month head start on the others? Maybe she was referring to writing only ‘being almost there’ . I apologize for not praising Adam for a boring page and a half before getting a little(overly) excited about Alli. LOL, if it’s not about Adam, it’s hard to have a pleasant thought, huh. lemme LOL, again.

No one on Idol is brilliant enough to put out a brilliant album in that short amount of time – IMHO.

I don’t know. I’m a writer and I know, when you are flying by the seat of your pants and letting it all happen, that’s when it’s magic. When you start over-thinking and over-producing, that’s when you start questioning yourself and get bogged down. Now, I don’t believe they are going to let any major-label be released in a rush, but I’d also love if they’d just let something organic happen. As Adam said, RedOne is a genius that works on the fly.

I also know that I’ve listened to “Brigadoon” (a tape-recording of a live, outdoor show) and it could not be more immaculate if you had all the production in the world behind it. The same thing goes for “Come Home” and “I Just Love You,” they are stellar. AND they are just recordings (one shot deals) of live covers.

I want Adam to do his original stuff, of course, but those covers are so exceptional that they warrant a consideration of some release in themselves.

If nothing else, they are indicative of the kind of quality work that can be done without an avalanche of production behind them.

http://www.radio913.com/

I also saw a Brazilian station where they were both in the top 10.

I don’t think this is subjective. I wasn’t taking long term appeal, I meant they’re currently popular overseas and this can be taken advantage of. After all, their albums will be out in four months.

Main thing is, they’re doing amazingly well in foreign countries and I feel sort of proud of them.

girlygirl, I really appreciate the link to the the interview with the tour’s director. Wonder which song Kris is playing electric guitar on? Wonder how part of Heartless will sound with a rock feel?

Even if Adam’s CD’s aren’t huge sellers (difficult in today’s economy), his tours should be hugely popular. An industry exec said that is what Adam needs, because he is such a visual artist. I’ve already told my hubs to expect to go to Adam’s concerts when he starts his solo tour. I’m wondering if he is going to kick start it in October for the Zodiac show. Carmit B. mentioned that would their next show, and she wants Adam there.

Someone posted from Israel, and she did say Adam was hugely popular there.