I didn’t mention Cat Deely in my last recap. She’s so efficient an unobtrusive, it’s easy to blow by her. I don’t mean that in a negative way. She keeps the action moving in a likable and friendly way and has a nice rapport with the contestants.

The guest judge for Charleston is Tyce Diorio.

More Recap, with Video After the Jump…

Charleston, SC Day One

  • Sheila Kaiser 18 – Atlanta GA – Video – She’s studying engineering in Georgia, and her parents are also engineers. Inbetween all those science and math classes, she must have fit in a bunch of dance classes. She has a very sweet, open face and a very fluid style. She goes straight to Vegas.
  • Erin Mansour 30 – Greenville, SC and John Tabakian 23 – Charleston SC – Video – She and her partner are ballroom dancers. Erin insists that her partner is awesome, but he’s not. Nigel tells John that he needs to be more masculine. “I tried,” says John meekly. “The only place this is going to go is home, I’m afraid,” says Nigel.
  • Jeremiah Hughes 19 – Toronto CA – Video – Jeremiah babbles on about spiritual divinity–WTF did he just say? I have no idea. He’s not a perfect dancer, but he’s got some awesome jumps. After some constructive criticism, Nigel tells him he’s one of the most exciting dancers he’s seen this season. He goes straight to Vegas.
  • Syiddah King 25 – Charleston SC – Video – Syiddah refuses to call whatever it is she just did on the stage “dancing”. She stomps off the stage mad after getting into an argument with Nigel.
  • Shamika Robinson 28 – Wingate NC – Video – Also stomping away mad–Shamika, after a routine that consists of writhing around the stage for a bit. She’s engaged and is planning to move her wedding up if she makes it to Vegas. When Nigel tells her not to bother changing her plans, she lays on the you-all-don’t-know-what-you-are-talking-about deal. Delusional!
  • Anthony and Antwain Hart 20 – Linden, NC – Video – These guys are identical twins. Anthony auditions first, and he’s average. Antwain auditions, and he’s miles beyond his brother. When Anthony is brought back to dance with his brother, somehow he raises his game. Both move on to choreography.
  • Choreography – Day One – Video – The twins, Anthony and Antwain, plus 18 other dancers move on to Vegas.

Charleston, SC – Day Two

  • Abigail Thurman 18 – Acworth GA – Video – Abigail wants to find out if she can dance. Guess what. She can’t! The producers go to the trouble of doing a little backstory on her. She teaches kids how to swim, and we see her as she works with the kids. When the judges tell her she sucks, she takes it with very good humor.
  • BJ Harris 23 – Brooklyn NY – Video – BJ’s co-workers raised the money to send BJ to Charleston for the auditions. He flew for the best time. His hip-hop style has lots of great moves and a sense of humor. Mary says that he’s got some moves that she’s never seen before. He moves on to choreography.
  • Courtney Galiano 19 – Dix Hills, NY – Video – Her grandparents attend the auditions, and they couldn’t be prouder! Courtney has a very strong, fluid style, and the judges love it. “Beautiful face, beautiful body…there were some nice elements…” says Tyce. Courtney is sent straight to Vegas.
  • Jason Looney 21 – Charleston SC – Video – Erm. Transvestite with a beard. Lovely! The producers are shocked, shocked! How dare Jason waste their time while so many accomplished dancers wait in the wings! Nevertheless, Jason’s phony ass still winds up on my TV!
  • Claire Calloway 20 – Huntsville, AL – Video – Claire was a contestant Season 2, but was sent home early because of a foot injury. Nigel promised her she’d go straight through to Vegas if she came back the following year. She gets pregnant instead. Two years later she’s back, but the time out she took to have a baby shows in her half assed routine. The judges explain it’s now two years later, and a different ball game. They send her to choreography with no promises. Afterward, in an interview, she seems very upset that she wasn’t cut a break. Hey, that’s showbiz, honey.
  • Choreography – Day Two – Video – BJ blows the choreography round. He’s sent on his way. He’s pretty bummed out. Claire is sent on to Vegas. Seventeen more dancers are also on their way to Vegas.

Dan Karaty is the guest judge in Washington.
Washington DC – Day One

  • Megan Campbell 18 – Muncie IN – Video – She’s a very strong, angular dancer. She says she never auditioned for anything in her life. Her aunt is there to support her and Nigel calls her up front for a big kiss, after he sends her straight to Vegas. Ohh, Lucky Auntie! /sarcasm.
  • Derrick Bradley 23, Holley NY – Video – Derrick is a returnee from last year. It takes 5 minutes to retell this dude’s story of hapless dancing and major delusions. Zzz.
  • Markus Shields 23, Grand Rapids MI – Video – Markus’s mom died when he was 12, and he dedicates his audition to her. He dances to Elliott Yamin’s “Wait for You.” Markus’s dance moves are effortless, but he’s very serious, indeed. He says he messed up, but the judges didn’t notice. Nigel says he’s got great musicality, and that his only mistake was to behave as if he messed up. He’s sent through to choreography.
  • Markus Smith 25, Hyattsville MD – Deonna Ball 23, Washington DC – Video – DC Swing is the official dance of Washington DC and Markus and Deonna are the best DC Swing dancers in the city. It’s the jitterbug with lots of hand movements. The perform a very clever routine, and are passed on to choreography.
  • Choreography – Day 1 – Video – The DC Swing dancers, Markus Smith and Deonna Ball don’t make it through choreography. Markus Shields moves on to Vegas. Nine other dancers advance to Vegas.

Washington DC – Day 2

  • Brandon Bryant 18, Miami FL – Video – Brandon audition 3 years ago, but he was only 15. His mom made him fess up. Now that he’s 18, he’s auditioning again. Brandon is an incredibly strong and graceful dancer. At one point, he does a jump that has him practically suspended in mid-air. Mary is very impressed. Nigel says he’s made for dancing, and that he’s one of the best he’s seen. He’s sent straight to Vegas.
  • Phucdat Ngyuen 25, Jessup MD – Video – Phucdat does some very amusing street dancing. His street name is the “Atomic Goofball”. The judges are impressed enough with his moves to send him on to choreography.
  • Mariya Priymak 26, Houston TX – Video – Mariya, who dances really badly with ribbons, is just a lead-in to the next audition.
  • Anthony Bryan 23, New York, NY – Video – Juliard graduate, Anthony, auditioned season one with a ribbon routine that Nigel called feminine. Anthony is back and to prove his macho, he’s wearing camouflage. It’s a pretty dumb idea, and although his routine is extremely competant and professional, the judges humiliate him further by sending him on to coreography, rather than straight to Vegas.
  • Choreography – Day 2 – VideoPhucdat Nguyen can’t hack the choreography, and doesn’t move on. Anthony Bryan does not move on to Vegas. Although his technique is flawless, the judges say he lacks personality. Phucdat takes his rejection well. Anthony, on the other hand, storms out of auditioned, extremely pissed. What a drama queen! Actually, I can’t quite figure out why he didn’t advance, he is a very good dancer. Nine more people advance to Vegas.

 
  • MrsTrep

    I actually watched and enjoyed last night. I hate it when they show lots of bad stuff…..urgh! But I feel the same about AI. Some of it is funny (Nigel had some funny lines last night). I didn’t watch the entire ticked off scene (flipped to Last Comic Standing) from the kid who graduated from Juliard in 3 years, but I find it amazing that someone can be so technically proficient & make it through Juliard in 3 years but can’t seem to put any feeling into their dance. Anyway, the 18 yr old guy near the end was amazing and I have a feeling we’ll be seeing a lot of him later on. And the guy with his mom on his shirt as well, if he can smile more.

  • wfowfowfo

    I was watching Last Comic Standing, so I DVR’d Dance last night. It truly is the way to go — I watched both shows in under 40 minutes by simply fast forwarding through the awful auditions and only watching the good ones. It gets easier as you go, figuring out which it’s going to be. I don’t enjoy the bad-non dancers, so it works for me. Next time perhaps I’ll do the opposite, as I don’t enjoy the non-funny costumed idiots on Last Comics either.

    That last guy was all kinds of wonderful. 18 years old, beautiful body — amazing. There are more than a few talented Africian American guys this year – I can think of 3 off the top of my head, and that’s just including who they’ve showed us. Maybe dear Danny last year gave the show some credibility and is bringing more really powerful men to the stage.

    Yay.

  • MrsTrep

    wfo – I don’t have a dvr :( I could save myself so much time…

    Anyway, if you still have Dance on DVR you need to watch the transgender guy’s critique. Nigel has a quality quote at the beginning of his critique.

  • wfowfowfo

    The big blond guy? I skipped him — so thanks, I’ll go back. Sometimes, much to my own distress, I really appreciate Nigel on this show. He’s mostly honest, but not over-the-top nasty. Thanks, Mrs. Trep.

  • Ladybug

    I have yet the see the second hour of this since Lost was my first priority.

    I wanted to add to the comment from wfo about Nigel. He is really fairly appealing on SYT. (Funny. On point comments.) But I do think this program is far closer to his heart than Idol, about which he remains mostly clueless.

    The judging (and hosting) on this show are a crash course, to me, in how it all should be done.

  • kerfuffle

    I watched the first 1/2 hour of SYTYCD, then I watched LCS and (continued) DVRing SYTYCD. During LCS commercials I flipped back to SYTYCD. After SYTYCD, I DVRed the second hour of Lost. I’ve gotta watch the first hour of Lost online, before watching the second hour on the DVR. What are these network schedulers doing to us? ACK! Thursdays are crazy! At least NEXT week I (we) won’t have to factor in Lost. Tonight I hope to finish watching SYTYCD, and hopefully Lost will be online. (Not to mention Doctor Who on Sci-Fi tonight. :surrender_tb:)

    Btw, LCS looks like it’s going to be really funny this season. I’m liking all of the comedians getting through – except one guy from last week’s episode. I just wish the Indian guy had gotten through last night. He was HILARIOUS! (I’m such a tv junkie. :eek_wp:)

  • lucy

    And another Idol finalist got music played. The fellow who lost his mother at age 12 danced– beautifully — to Elliott’s Wait for You. The first few lyrics of that song sounded extremely poignant in the context of the dancer’s tribute to his mom. He made it through choreography and on to Las Vegas, too.

  • AZIdolFan

    i soooooo wish i had a dvr. i missed sytycd last night. watched the last 45 minutes of lost and totally forgot about lcs. i’ll be able to watch lost online and i was hoping mj would have some recap of sytycd :) i wonder if nbc puts lcs online?

  • majordude

    @mj – Do yourself a favor, start another blog for this show! You will water down your rankings in Google and turn off people who don’t watch the show and only want Idol chatter!

  • sumidol

    If people only want Idol chatter wouldnt they just go to another thread on this blog and ignore this one? Thanks for the recaps MJ, I was unable to watch so I am catching up here.