Hey guys, it’s SirMac. I’m the newest “guest blogger” here at MJ’s, as the large volume of competition reality shows created a little bit of a scheduling jam. Join me tonight as I recap the So You Think You Can Dance Top 4 show. I’m really excited to make my debut here tonight, and I hope you guys will enjoy.

Watch Eliana, Tiffany, Chehon, and Cyrus compete for the title of America’s Favorite Dancer.

This year, there are actually 2 winners, 1 guy and 1 girl, so we’re actually watching 2 different competitions. Will it be Eliana or Tiffany? Chehon or Cyrus? I have several friends who are friends with Tiffany (she’s from my hometown), and have taken dance classes with her, so I know they’re rooting for her tonight.

Cat takes the stage in a lovely red dress to remind us that it’s been 16 weeks. I wonder if that counts all the time off we had for the Olympics and July 4th? Each contestant will be dancing 5 times tonight. Holy…
The judges panel tonight is Nigel, Mary, and Rob Marshall (director of Chicago).

1st- Cyrus and Eliana- Paso Double (choreographer Jason Gilkyson)- The Game Has Changed (Daft Punk)
I’ve been waiting to see Cyrus challenged in the ballroom genre, and this will be a challenge for him. Most of his choreography seems dumbed down, as he does a lot of posing and not a lot of dancing. Because this dance is a strong partner dance, it means Eliana isn’t getting nearly enough moves to show off her amazing abilities. A very slow Paso Double. Cyrus is supposed to be a matador, commanding Eliana around. I don’t know…. Nigel says Eliana has “secured your place in this industry” and Nigel claims Cyrus “deserves to be here” but he needs to “lower his shoulders and straighten his legs.” They’re still grading him on a sliding scale. Mary acknowledges the difficulty of the paso double, and tells Cyrus that he delivered, and she could have done without the cartwheel. Mary tells Eliana that she was on fire and she loved her. Rob loved that Eliana knows how to throw the technique away and just tell a story.

Cyrus will be dancing with Twitch later.

2nd- Tiffany and Will Wingfield- Contemporary (choreographer Sonya)- The Time Is Now (Moloko)
I’m happy to see Will back on the show. he’s a strong dancer. Tiffany is handling the choreography quite well, but it seems to be a “storyless” routine, which sometimes don’t translate as well to the audience. She’s a beautiful dancer, and Will partners her well. Mary tells her she’s a star, and their partnership was made in heaven. Rob compliments Sonya’s choreography, and compliments Tiffany on her fearlessness. Nigel tells Will he’s matured into such a strong dancer, and compliments his presence. He tells Tiffany that she’s the girl next door, yet no one as amazing as her has ever lived next to him.

3rd- Chehon and Eliana- Ballet (choreographer Marat Daukayev)- The Nutcracker Suite- Pas De Deux
I had forgotten that both of these dancers are actually trained ballet dancers. This is phenomenal. Chehon is slaying this. Eliana is gorgeous. I’m not a huge fan of ballet, but this is ballet done well. My only complaint is that it didn’t last longer. Rob compliments them on their versatility, and Eliana on her extensions, and Chehon on his balance. Nigel gives us some background on Marat, who was previously a principle dancer in Kiev’s ballet company. Nigel is super excited that two ballet dancers made it to the finale. Nigel compliments Chehon on being a great support for Eliana. Mary says it’s a triumph for the show, and for the celebration of ballet.

4th-Cyrus and Tiffany- Lyrical Hip Hop (choreographer Tessendra Chavez)- Best Thing I Never Had (Beyonce)
Cyrus broke Tiffany’s heart, he feels bad, and wants to make up. They start the number on the floor, and it’s really strong from both of them. Cyrus looks most in his element in hip hop routines, but really Tiffany is attacking this with so much ferocity that it’s impossible to not watch her and think of Cyrus almost as an afterthought. Tiffany was amazing, Cyrus was good (but some really strong acting). Nigel compliments these two on never having been in the bottom, and says they’re both amazing in emotional routines. Mary expected Cyrus to kill it, and thought Tiffany was a beast. Mary hasn’t seen Tiffany hit it as hard as that before (neither have I). Rob compliments them on their reckless abandon, and how they could have dropped at any moment because they had given everything they had.

5th- Cyrus, Tiffany, Eliana, and Chehon- Group Number (choreographer Tyce Diorio)- Eine Kleine Nachtmusik (District 78 Remix)
All four dancers are conducting (some more sexily than others… Tiffany), and after they get rid of the music stand and the sheet music, they’re able to break out into their dance. HOLD UP! It’s a remix, complete with lasers! This isn’t your dad’s Nachtmusik. Cyrus pops, Chehon pirouettes, and Tiffany and Eliana get their sexy on. Finally, the music stand is back, and we’re reminded that they are conductors again. Really a cool dance.

6th- Eliana’s Solo- Passacaglia (Johann Johannson)
Eliana’s package talks about how excited she was to be with Cyrus, and how awesome it was to dance with Alex. She thinks people got to know her through those partners. Her solo is a beautiful little ballet piece, and the music is beautiful. She has lipstick on her teeth when she tries to get people to vote for her… poor child…
To Vote For Eliana: 1-855-GO HER 01 or text Eliana to 83676, or Fox.com/Dance, or the new SYTYCD app.

7th- Chehon and Allison- Contemporary (choreographer Stacey Tookey)- Leave (from Once: The Musical)
Beautiful song. Fantastic choreography, really emotional. Allison is killing it, but Chehon is going for the gold here. He’s the best male dancer this season, and his gigantic leaps in the air and effortless lifts remind us of that. He did a one hand lift. He’s so strong. The number ends with Chehon and Allison making out, and then Allison’s face… is perfect. Awesome. Standing ovation from the judges. Cat makes a big deal about the one hand lift. Mary screams. Mary tells Chehon how free he is in this piece, and compliments his extensions. Chehon keeps growing and growing. Rob calls Allison fierce, and Rob and Nigel talk about how she should be an actress. Step Up 5 maybe? lol. Sorry, too soon… Nigel says “wow, young man” and some other over the top complimentary stuff.

8th- Tiffany and Eliana- Broadway (choreographer Ray Leeper)- When You’re Good To Mama (from Chicago: the Musical)
Stripper pole! Expect Nigel to make inappropriate jokes. There’s something about this dance, and these two girls not being quite in sync together that bothers me. But it’s a super sexy dance, and Eliana can really work that pole. Standing ovation from the judges. I wonder what the director of the Oscar winning Chicago thinks. Nigel defers to Rob first. Rob says he’s trying to imagine Queen Latifah doing that. He calls Ray’s choreography extraordinary. Rob loved Eliana’s final pose on the pole. Mary loves the finish on the pole. Nigel realizes he can’t say anything that won’t get him in trouble, and says the last time he saw something like that he was with Randy Jackson.

9th- Cyrus’s Solo- Holy Ghost (Messinian)
Cyrus originally planned on being a basketball player. Cyrus’s lowest moment in Vegas was after Sonya’s piece, because he felt like he was reflecting her piece poorly. His highest point in Vegas was during his solos. Cyrus loves him some dubstep. It allows for all the popping that he’s so good at (or animation as he calls it). Standing ovation from Mary and Rob.

To Vote for Cyrus: 1-855-GO HIM 01 or Text CYRUS to 83676 (or vote at Fox.com/Dance, or using the SYTYCD app).

10th- Tiffany’s Solo- I Believe (Fantasia)
Tiffany had to go to choreography, and didn’t make it straight to Vegas. Tiffany cited ballroom as her turning point. She also noticed her lack of screentime in the auditions. She feels like her dance with Ade was the moment that America really saw who she was. It’s basically every contemporary solo ever performed on the stage. She dances it well, but it’s not particularly memorable.

To Vote for Tiffany- 1-855-GO HER 02 or text TIFFANY to 83676 (or vote at Fox.com/Dance, or using the SYTYCD App)

11th- Chehon and Cyrus- Jazz (choreographer Sonya)- Fangs (Little Red Lung)
Sonya says she’s not lightening the load for Cyrus. She says it’s time for him to step his game up. Cyrus is a fighter. He’s on stage with one of the most trained dancers in the history of the show, and he’s fighting to show everyone he deserves to be there. I’m a Cyrus fan, don’t get me wrong, but I never thought he’d make it this far. And against Chehon? This is tough. Both boys danced this number really well. Cyrus really attacked this number as much as he could. Nigel loved that Sonya choreographed it, and that she made Cyrus and Chehon come up a level. Nigel says that Cyrus is an inspiration, and his favorite person on the show. Nigel says Chehon is his favorite dancer, and says both are inspirational. Jennifer Beals is in the audience! Mary says each dancer has fought to get here, and that Cyrus has gotten much better technically as a dancer. Rob agrees, and comments on the brotherhood between Chehon and Cyrus, and how they help each other.

International B-Boy Sensation Jean Sok performs. He’s only got one leg, and dances with crutches, but he’s still fantastic. It’s amazing to see what people can do when given a challenge in life. He gets a standing ovation from all three judges.

After a REALLY LONG X-Factor promo…

12th- Chehon’s Solo- How It Ends (DeVotchKa)
Chehon decided to do the show to learn new styles. He cites the last day in Vegas, when he did his solo, as being his big moment. He says his best moment was when his mom came and saw the show. Chehon goes for an emotional solo, full of power moves, gigantic leaps, and stunts. Good job.

To Vote For Chehon- 1-855-GO HIM 02 or text CHEHON to 83676 (or vote at Fox.com/dance, or using the SYTYCD app)

13th- Eliana and Alex- Contemporary (choreographer Travis Wall)-Without You (Harry Nilsson)
There isn’t a lot of story in the package (they just talk about goofing off). It doesn’t matter, because with Travis’s choreography, you can always feel something being told. A story of love and heartbreak. Alex and Eliana are perfection together. One of the best dances of the evening, definitely. Rob calls it Poetry. There’s nothing Eliana can’t do, and compliments her extensions again. He says Alex is a gorgeous partner. Rob says Eliana just got lost in the routine. Nigel thinks it was his favorite of the night. He says it brought together his favorite things with Travis, Alex, and Eliana. Nigel says Eliana is his favorite OF ALL TIME ON THE SERIES. really? Mary compliments Alex on being here as an all-star, and tells Travis it’s one of her favorite numbers of the night. Mary compliments Eliana on her passion… oozing…oozing passion.

14th- Tiffany and Chehon- Rumba (choreographer Dmitry Chaplin)-Love Me Tender (Adam Levy and Norah Jones)
I’m so excited for this dance. Dmitry says it has to be so hot that it’s awkward to watch them. This is so gorgeous. Chehon paired with a girl means they have a strong partner, who can just fling them around with his pinky. The turns are so quick, the lifts are effortless, and each extension is flawless. Absolutely beautiful. Mary says it was beautiful, and compliments Dmitry. Mary didn’t buy the chemistry, but loved Chehon’s slide. Mary compliments Tiffany (who has also fallen victim to lipstick teeth). I’m guessing a makeup artist is getting axed tonight. Rob thought it was sexy, and he did feel a connection between them. Rob loves their abandon. Nigel says the dance was sexy, and wonders what happened to Chehon’s buttons on his shirt.

15th- Cyrus and Twitch- Animation (choreographer Christopher Scott)- Like A Criminal (District 78)
Alright. This is sick. The breakaway glass was a super cool trick. Since this is animation, which is not quite Twitch’s style, he’s allowing for Cyrus to look just as strong as him. This was probably the most fun routine to watch of the night. Standing ovation from the judges. Rob says it was crazy and calls them both superstars. Nigel compliments Twitch on adapting to the style, and says they’re both world class (which he heard from Christopher Scott). Nigel apologizes to Cyrus for not voting for him tonight, but he’s proud of Cyrus. Nigel understands why America will vote for Cyrus, but he’s voting for Chehon. Surprisingly… he wasn’t booed.

Some really strong routines tonight. I think Eliana and Tiffany are in a dead heat. Yes, Nigel has put tons of praise on Eliana, but there’s something to be said about Tiffany not being in the bottom… ever. And same with Cyrus (who also has never been in the bottom). Yes, Chehon is amazing, but America seems to love Cyrus. That last routine was killer. Who are you voting for? Sound off in the comments!

MJ says I’ll be back next week for the finale recap, so I’ll see you then. I hope I did justice to the live blog, and I hope you had a good time. I’d love to do this more often. ;)

Recapping Your Voting Numbers:
To Vote For Eliana: 1-855-GO HER 01 or text ELIANA to 83676, (or vote at Fox.com/Dance, or using the SYTYCD app).

To Vote for Cyrus: 1-855-GO HIM 01 or Text CYRUS to 83676 (or vote at Fox.com/Dance, or using the SYTYCD app).

To Vote for Tiffany- 1-855-GO HER 02 or text TIFFANY to 83676 (or vote at Fox.com/Dance, or using the SYTYCD App)

To Vote For Chehon- 1-855-GO HIM 02 or text CHEHON to 83676 (or vote at Fox.com/dance, or using the SYTYCD app)

 
  • Heidijoy

    Eilena and Chehon are the best dancers, so I’m rooting for them.

    All four put on a great show. 

    I love Alex and love seeing him.  He is fantastic.  Felt so bad when he had injuries two years in a row.  Yes Mary, we have all wondered about him for a few years. He has talent and a wonderful attitude.

  • http://twitter.com/KariannHart Kariann Hart

    Thank you, Sir Mac.  You did a fine job and I disagreed on only one performance analysis.  Yes, please cover the Finale for us!

  • http://www.fatladysings.us/ TFLS

    Love, Love, LOVE Chehon!  From his audition, I thought he was one of the best classical dancers I’ve ever seen on the show (wouldn’t you love to see he and Alex dance Matthew Bourne’s celebrated pas de deus from his all male version of Swan Lake?).  I do hate that Nigel pulled one of his “I’m not voting for you” stunts.  He always does this, ends up having to apologize; scotching it for whoever he supported.  You’d think he’d have learned better by now.  Mixed review on the finale choreo.  Not as good as last season imo.  As to who’ll win?  No idea.  I like Eliana and Chehon.  Be interesting to see how it plays out.  Gotta say I miss Amelia.  I’d originally hoped she would make the finale.   

  • http://twitter.com/RKOBlackSwan Black Swan

    Nigel is an extremely smart man. He isn’t a very nice one but very smart.

    What he did tonight was reverse psychology. It is something he admitted to using last season after the finale and it is something Simon Cowell has used for years on American Idol.

    By saying what he did, he enraged enough Cyrus fans (not even kidding, go check twitter, facebook, etc…) to get them to vote like mad. Chehon doesn’t stand a chance. Everything about that final critique was worded perfectly to get the result that Nigel has wanted from day one- Cyrus winning.

    What confuses me is why even do it? Cyrus has never been in the bottom while Chehon has, so obviously, the votes have been there all season for Cyrus. He has danced in the final spot countless times and the show has made no subtle attempts at reminding us that this is America’s FAVORITE dancer, not exactly best. So I don’t know why Nigel felt the need to use reverse psychology this go around.

    It just leaves a nasty taste in my mouth.

  • Dot2745

    How long are the voting lines open?  thanks
     

  • Dot2745

    How long are the voting lines open?  Thanks!

  • http://twitter.com/KariannHart Kariann Hart

    Kesia, it isn’t that Cyrus bugs me (or maybe others).  He seems like a very nice young man, and I am sure this experience has helped his self-esteem.  What bugs me is Nigel’s (and others) over-praising.  After a while, it got to be a bit too much.  There were several other nice young men that could have been in that spot.  I will give him credit; he did the best that he could do.  Yet, I can’t help but feel someone else should have been there.  Oh, well…life goes on.

    It was a wonderful evening of dance.

  • Meenama

    If Cyrus wins over Chehon, SYTYCD doesn’t deserve to be renewed. Every season the same thing happens, the judges pimp a street unworthy and overly criticize other performers in order to boost their protegee. Also Nigel is incorrect, Cyrus did appear in the bottom two, and that was in last week’s show. Tiffany is the only dancer to escape the bottom throughout the whole season.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Madelon.21 Madelon Laca

    I definitely think Eliana and Chehon should win the whole thing for countless reasons! And I hope they do! Anywho, I just want to thank MJ and SirMac for the amazing live blog and for putting the vids up so quickly… I know I can always rely on you, MJ *bows thankfully*

  • jr8809

     No they didn’t announce a bottom 2 last week, they just put Cyrus next to Cole, all they announced was that Cole was the lowest vote getter. Cyrus and Tiffany are still the only ones to not have been in the bottom.

  • hayes

    So they all actually danced 6 times, counting the group number and the solos. Jesus that’s a whole lot of dancing for one night. It was awesome!

    The only good thing about having two winners is that we can say that Eliana is a winner, because if we were to name only one, I think Cyrus will take it all. But I’m never right, so I’m not counting out Chehon winning too. Eliana and Chehon deserve to win.

  • idolbeat

    I really enjoyed the routines tonight! I have to agree with Nigel about Eliana. I never want to miss a second of her dancing – literally can’t take my eyes off of her movements. The Ballet routine: words can’t describe that fluidity, grace and control – reminded me of what my pastor said Sunday about Truth & Grace. That dance was 100% both. How could you top it? With Travis Wall, Alex Wong and Eliana! That one was beautiful & breathtaking.

    Loved Twitch & Cyrus’ break-out – gosh, that was exciting & fresh! :)

    Loved the recap SirMac!

  • cooks

    Sometimes Nigel just needs to stop talking!! There was no reason for him to say “you’re my favorite person and you’re my favorite dancer”. Then he tells Cyrus he won’t vote for him..well I think that just insured him a lot more votes and the win.

    Cyrus is unique and I really like him, but I don’t think he deserves to win. Based on performances the win should definitely go to Chehon and Eliana.

  • usedtobelucy

     ”What he did tonight was reverse psychology. It is something he admitted
    to using last season after the finale and it is something Simon Cowell
    has used for years on American Idol.”

    I suppose I’m hopelessly naive, but I thought that Nigel actually meant what he said tonight. I do know that sometimes he says things to manipulate. But I really think that he does truly love *dance* so much that he sometimes says things that are honest about it (unlike with Idol, where he doesn’t care nearly as much about the art, and *way* unlike Simon, who doesn’t care about anything but the benjamins and his own ego.)

    My take is that Nigel maybe knows that Cyrus (and maybe Tiffany??) is/are so far ahead in the voting, consistently, that there’s no way Chehon (or Eliane??) could possible win. So he might as well describe the dance and his own preferences honestly — both in the service of the art that he loves and as kind of a consolation prize to him (them??) for his/their inevitable losing of the popular vote.

    I hope that I’m right about this, although I suppose you are. heh. To me, over the years, Nigel has shown the capacity to be both a jerk and a decent person — and that he’s most decent when he’s doing some little thing in service of dance, which is something that he truly and devotedly loves. …. I recall, for instance, how *mean* and *snarky* and *Simony* he initially was a a judge on SYTYCD, and how people complained and he knocked that off.

    Okay, I choose to think that, this time, he was sincere (although, of course, he said it because he knows the inevitable results)…. Honestly, I think Nigel’s too complex a person to just be a total Simon C-ish jerky child.

    Anyway, I loved the show. Cyrus shouldn’t be there. *But* he did some really good work, his solo and his number with Twitch were amazing, and he does seem like a very very nice, smart, highly worthwhile person, who deserves good things, even though he is in no way shape or form a versatile dancer.

  • Kurt Samuels

    Huh?  Not sure your comment “I think Nigel should have said says Eliana is ONE of his favorite OF ALL TIME ON THE SERIES” reads properly or makes any sense actually???  Eliana IS, in fact, the most versatile dancer ever to grace the SYTYCD stage, so why shouldn’t Nigel be entitled to claim her as his all time favorite?

  • http://twitter.com/KariannHart Kariann Hart

    Kurt, maybe I understood it wrong?  I thought he meant his favorite out of 9 seasons.  He has said this before.  I guess she may have been his favorite THIS season?  Sorry if it didn’t sound right to me!  Oh, and I do agree she IS the most versatile! :o)

  • lovemyidol

    I really had so many things about this season I didn’t like: 1) Hated the format – it ruined the fluidity of the show and didn’t give me anything to look forward to the following week 2) Hated how they got rid of some of the people that were the best personalities and maybe dancers and kept saving others America didn’t vote for (Will, Amelia, Whitney) 3) Hated how Mia Michaels didn’t choreograph anything new and hated how they tried to revive her old pieces with dancers that didn’t match her choreography.

     But most of all, I despised the overpimping of certain dancers.  This show used to provide constructive criticism for up and coming dancers, so that they could actually grow.  They gave them challenging dances, to see if they could reach the bar.  I’m thinking of Ivan, Hok, Jose and Legacy in particular. All hip hop dancers, some with little to no training who did beautiful contemporary pieces because they were challenged, had musicality, and had a passion to learn different styles. Frankly, Cyrus was given a pass.  How many times was he in the pimp spot?  How many times did he get hip hop?  I don’t ever remember seeing a contemporary piece from him or any ballroom besides a paso doble. He wasn’t strong enough to lift the girls very high and his technique was sub-par compared to the other hip hop dancers I mentioned. I just don’t think he deserves to win. 

    My vote is for Chehon and Eliana.  Chehon grew in his own way and deserves to win – I didn’t see the same growth out of Cyrus.  Eliana just outshown (outdanced) Tiffany with the Chicago song, so my vote goes to her.

    I hope SYTYCD goes back to the old format and stops trying to pander to the audience with things they think we want to hear.  It’s like they think the audience is dumb.

  • alonzo7

    My favs are Chehon and Eliana but it’s not just about the dancing-I’m happy for any of them to win as they put on a great show last night-how in the world they could do all those dances in a week baffles my mind!!!!

  • p2fan

    I love your recap sirmac.  Congrats! And I enjoy the show.  Hoping for Chehon and Eliana to win.

  • hcpoirot

    Cyrus will 100% win this. The producer from the get go already want him to win by showing him tons (the only male dancer) of screen time from audition to Vegas week.

    Then for the last 3 weeks, he dance second last, pimp spot , (and this final week) pimp spot again.

    Just too obvious. Again the best male dancer will not  this season. (after season 6 when Jacob only been runner up to Russel win)

    Nigel really want Eliana to win. But somehow Tiffany get tons of votes. It close to call between Eliana and Tiffany.