Season 7 Top 12 Guys – Performance

i am here. ready to comment.

me too!

i can’t believe they’re starting with a 60′s nite!! that kinda cheesy theme is usually several weeks into the season

we hate cheese:) lol. not really….

come to chat…

Man, Checkezie (sp) has got a mouth on him! That could backfire….

I secretly agreed with Simon. It reminded me of something I might have seen on one of the many variety shows from way back.

Anyone notice that Carly was not sitting with the girls? I had to rewind and double check- only 11 girls there.

Aw, maybe her visa ran out again! :mellow_tb:

Chikezie — this is your second time around. Be mannerful and don’t talk back to Simon. He started out with flat notes, and I’ve heard that song sang by others and those opening notes are very hard to hit. Bad choice of song for his voice.

David Cook = very karaoke, I don’t like that song on him.

David Cook has eschewed the wallet chain for the handkerchief-in-the-pocket.

Chicago-sally, I thought the same thing. I also thought he was somewhat off-key.

I think I’d like him better if he’d just own his hair and comb it back or something. It’s like he’s wearing a youthful version of a combover – still not fooling anyone.

I was not surprised to see David Hernandez going first and Michael Johns going last. TPTB always have a plan.

I wanted to like Chikezie and was going to vote for him even after he did a lousy job on the lousy song. After his tantrum, there is no way I’m voting for him. I don’t know what he was thinking being so disrespectful. Simon already has a job in show business Mr. Eze is trying to break into show business. STUPID MOVE on his part, IMO.

I have hated the slowing down of the beginnings of each of the first three songs. I hope that doesn’t continue. I’m not happy so far.

It’s as if Chikezie’s never watched the show before!

Gabam I wouldn’t call it a tantrum, I would say he was defending himself, because remember he’s been eliminated before.

So far I’m not too impressed with the guys.

Aw, Jason was sweet! THAT’S how you handle criticism!

Since Chikezie had been eliminated before, he should have been grateful enough for a second chance to let the professional judge state his opinion without interrupting and arguing with it. He should just take the advice in the opinion or discount it, but not argue with Simon on the first night. People don’t get a second chance to make a first impression.

Tonight was the first time a lot of people have seen him. I already liked him and he lost me, I’m sure that he completely turned off a lot of people who might have voted for him if he had just kept his mouth shut.

I like Jason’s looks, his voice is fine, it was the song or the arrangement. 60s is a little sucky isn’t it? Wasn’t Motown in the 60s? Seems there were some better songs in the 60s.

Robbie is a pro — he’s showing the others up.

Crap, already the only 17 crap. Oh please

David A. is a pro too. he picked the right song. But kind of feel he has a big head start and leap over the others because he knows how to work the crowd, he’s been performing since the age of 2.

Is David truly the chosen one? If so, another failure to sell CD’s on the horizon….I wouldn’t give one of his to my granddaughter….bubblegum.

Well, I think it’s pretty clear who TPTB would like us to vote for tonight.

Robbie has a wallet chain!

So far, David H, Jason, and David A have been the best for me. I’ll vote for them.

Looking forward to the second half and more unknowns!

Only two I am looking forward to is of course Michael cause I just really love his voice, and then Luke.

Yep was going to vote, but the just pimping of David, nope. I was telling Ryan “enough already!” move on ……….. and where is Carly? Hmmmmmm

The cheesiest songs from the 60s imaginable. What a bad way to start a season. Jailhouse Rock is from the 50s isn’t it?

I prefer Taylor’s version of Jailhouse Rock. And I’m not a huge Taylor fan.

So far David A is leaving everyone in the dust and he’ll be a boring winner just like Jordin.

I don’t think Simon likes Dannie — he wants Dannie OUT! He wasn’t grotesque! But Paula is correct, he’s a good performer, and it was a safe performance, and I can see him on Broadway.

Dayum, I hate to say it, but Danny is just too precious for me.

I like JPL’s version better too – although it’s the song he went out on *sob*

Danny, not even close to Taylor’s version.

How’s about we set a new age limit for AI? I say you gotta’ be 20…

I’m starting to hate this teen crap….

There are other people who buy CD’s besides tweeners….

I hope Luke is good.

Jpfan you are correct. I know there were better songs from the 60s — Motown anyone? What about the blues singers of the 60s like Fats Domino, the New York sound, like the Drifters and Frankie Lyman (was that the 50s)….theme night isn’t starting off too well…or could it be — oh not! They hyped the singers up to high “this is the best group we’ve ever had” that we expect more from them?

So far David A. and Robbie have my ear.

Wow, Danny just needed to stop talking. He totally got on my nerves.

Danny is like Sanjaya with more talent but less charm.

Luke is a cutie too. That was a nice version of the song. Nice, not exciting.

oh Luke, what happened???????

Oh huge disappointment, dang Luke. I really wanted to like ya since you were so purty, but that voice is just not my style. Drat. Not bad, just not my style.

I agree w/ Simon, he was forgettable as was the song.

I liked Luke and not David A. I guess my ears are broken.

I thought Luke sounded good. But I guess they want him gone.

Singing the song that Chris D was cut on? I’m not sure about this…

Question to everybody — was this group hyped as being the best singers yet? I think they’re good singers, but the songs are “OK”, and they’re not bringing anything new or exciting to the songs.

I completely agree, Chicago-sally.

Oh found my bathroom break singer, Colton.

Simon is being brutally honest right now. He wants a star, a recording artist, and he’s not getting it tonight.

lisa — too funny

My problem with tonight is the kids are so so young, there is not really any hurt, disappointments, heartaches for them to draw from for their songs. Like Colton’s song, smiling all the way through the song, no UMPH anywhere in the song, no heartache. Just BLEH.

Dear God please don’t let there be any more teenagers….aaaarrrrgghhhhh……………….

Curses! Luke’s voice has no substance! He makes Ace look like, um, someone with substance!

I was really looking forward to the guys. I have to say I’m quite disappointed.

Too many teens with no emotional connection to their music.
Gee, maybe this won’t be the most talented top 24 ever.

Lisa you make a good point. Why do I get the feeling that 19E/Fox/AI is trying to find a “Jonas Brothers” “Miley Cyrus” performer because they’re the hot kids right now? The two pros so far are Robbie & David A., let’s see what Michael brings.

Well, and DANG – Luke is one of the older ones! All that shot to hell. Bring back the guy in the car! Josiah!! HE had connection!

Josiah is making the rounds on the talk shows and selling his songs on Myspace.

Ah shit…another damned teener..and Luke sucked big time……..another girl winner I guess…GO AMANDA!!!!!

Garrett kinda sounds like a girl – just like the original singer of this song, who’s name escapes me right now.

Dude is all off Key. Cutie pie, but doesn’t bring anything to the song Breaking up is Hard to do….no emotion, just all flirting with the camera. But he’ll last another week because the little girls will love him.

I agree Sally! I don’t get the guy picks at all. Maybe I am too old, lol, but teen male singers do nothing for me. There is just nothing there for them to draw from. All I see right now is all puppies and rainbows. I almost lost my taco from Colton’s performance.

Ok AI just hit a new low for me with this Garrett kid.

Save the season for me, Michael!!

Longsong, it is Neil Sedaka. :smile_wp:

D’oh! Thanks, Lisa!

Ha! ROFLMAO!!! My hubby just asks me where all the testosterone is????????

Is it Michael’s turn yet??? *grabs the peptol* after Garrett’s song.

10 down, two to go. Pleeease, save the season, dreadlock guy and Michael!

I seriously gotta’ wonder what in the hell the “judges’ saw in any of these kiddies that made them send them to this point??!?!?!?

It’s time to change the judges if this is all they found amongst 100k /- contestants….

WHERE’S THE BEEF????????

You know AI always starts out like this. They have a few weak ones mixed in with the really good ones….but they hyped this season to be so “great”….you just hope some of these guys come back next week a whole lot better than they are tonight….it’s just like the previous seasons….there’s a Scott Savol, Kevin Covais and John Stevenson in the bunch like before….it won’t really get competitive until the final 12. And I’m surprised that only ONE BLACK DUDE IS AMONG THE GROUP…usually there’s 2-3….you mean out of all the black dude singers they could only find ONE???

I really hope the last two make this worth watching.

With the exception of 17 year old David, I’ve been incredibly underwhelmed.

Why didn’t Jason Y get more pimping, he has an adorable son and can sing and looks good. Maybe the only time having a kid helps is if your a single mother, not a single father. Please bring on some really interesting talent, I’m bored.

Who the hell would download any of the lame cheese from tonight?

Nostra: You know the judges are overruled by the producers

THANK YOU! I like Jason!

I liked him!!!

I dont need Randy to tell me if someone is good or not! I thought Jason C. was GREAT!

Jason isn’t bad, but those dreads have to go. That was a bold move. He’s not “star” quality at this point.

Yay for Jason! Truly likeable.

Please join in a crusade that will save us all. Let your voice be heard.

VOTE OUT THE 17 YEAR OLDS.

Honestly I can’t believe that Archuletta said “and I’m 17″. I can’t take another year of it. Move now, vote for anyone 18 and above. Send the “only 17 year olds” home.

I like that Jason doesn’t come to the show a seasoned performer and actually has room to grow.

Sure hope Michael can save the boys. Ok strike that. Bring on the men and save the night from the tweenie boys.

Jason has starred in an MTV season called Cheyenne. He has plenty of experience and is a seasoned performer. Just saying.

Jason did something different and he’s a cutie. He’s safe.

jpfan….No shit…processed cheese at that.

Chicago-Sally….I guess even when I first heard Daughtry and even Taylor (who I’m still not a fan of), I could tell there was something there…some depth and real soul.

There hasn’t been one damned note that I’ve heard tonight that sounded real and worth a damn….ENOUGH tenor singers!!

Oops. I meant show, of course. There’s lots of info about Jason.

longsong – completely agree. I think that’s what I like the best about him. He’s a true undiscovered talent who could do really, really well given a chance. I’m interested to see what happens with him in this competition.

JPfan: I never heard of Cheyenne, is that a TV drama?

Uh-oh, I expected better from Michael. He’s a little off-key; no? That’s not one of my fave songs anyway. Just meh.

Michael is being pumped up….Simon is all over him…I don’t think so.

Sorry Michael…but Amanda already killed that song…

OK, I’m behind you all cuz I didn’t start until 8pm (DVR is THE way to go) and I’m just at Robbie Carrico. He’s the first one who I didn’t speed through after listening for ten seconds. Oooh, Simon just agreed with me. That’s scary! Before Robbie, I had paused and switched to Josiah Leming’s performance on Ellen Degeneres…I was in desperate need of someone being original/and or interesting. Josiah provided that fix. Ellen is SO cool giving him all those gifts.

Michael ya got my vote.

I didn’t think Michael was that fantastic, but maybe that’s just me. Jason C. gets my vote tonight.

Yes. It was a drama about a teen singer and he played her boyfriend. He’s one of the lesser plants. Undiscovered, not really.

Lisa, he got my vote too, but I expected more from him. That song has been done to death.

Kraze: I agree, he was OK…it was the song….I felt a bit of nervousness about him. We will see next week what happens. Expectations are higher for him than the others…uhoh Simon is already in love with him, he’s an AUSSIE — we know what that means….

Wow, for Michael Johns they brought back the Chris Daughtry flames background, plus he got to sing last. No pimping going on there. No. None. LOL.

I liked David A., David N., Jason Castro and Michael Johns.

I also liked the voice and positive attitude of Garrett Haley. I hope he makes it through to the next round so I can see how he would do with a better song.

I expected more also, but after tonight he and Jason C saved it for me. I might have to split my votes between him and Jason.

There is something I really like in Jason C. He just makes me happy, heh.

Where was Carly???

Okay, this is the problem I have with this group: No one had a distinguishable different distinctive voice. They all sounded almost alike. Close my eyes and try to tell them apart and I could not (excl. the two Davids)….is it me? Oh well, we’ll see next week folks next week.

Does anybody know if Carly Michael & David slept outside overnight to get an audition like the other 100,000 people?

Thank god for Michael Johns! I loved him. He was really good.

Jason C was good but I prefer Michael’s voice and style.
I guess the best ones here are Michael, David A and Jason C. JMHO.

I really liked Michael Johns.

Jason was really good, too but the guitar didn’t add anything to the performance for me.

I was hoping for more from David Cook. I liked Jason Castro and Michael Johns the best tonight. Robbie Carrico was not bad either.

Chakeeze was my least favorite. Arguing didn’t make me like him any more.

David H, Colton, Jason Yaeger, and Garrett were forgettable. Danny might be the next Sanjaya-very annoying. Luke and David A were kinda eh.

Maracaibo: When they get down to the final 12, they get a full orchestra and backup singers.

Yay, the night was saved for me by the last two! There were others I liked as well…but….can’t…remember them now….

I guess that’s why they call it the “pimp spot”.

the show for me tonight, meh, the songs, cheezy and I resorted to chardonnay for the show, hoping for some decent pinot noir.
very underwhelmed by most of these boys,poor song selections and the facial expressions, the odd smiling, the mike stand gestures, been there, done that. have these contestants watched the previous seasons? !
actually liked David A- yeah, the kid is cute, reminds me of my youngest son, as for Michael Johns, I laughed out loud at the flames- and last to sing. well we already knew that didn’t we..
Jason C is a cutie, those dimples, and they better not cut the dreads :cry_wp:

I’m using DialIdol to vote and I’m getting through like EVERY call! Is anyone else using DialIdol? If so, is the same thing happening to you??

And we still wonder, where was Carly?

loved loved loved Jason Castro. Way to make the ‘theme’ work for you, dude! You got my votes!

Talked to my mom. She adores David A and likes Castro a lot too.

I love texting. 25 votes for Castro, already gone.

Finally through the rest. Here’s my other fav’s:

Garrett Haley’s voice is too high at first listen, but he did the second best job so far for singing with just a little bit of originality. Or not. RandyPaulaSimon just said he was UNoriginal.

Jason – Good, too! At least he didn’t have the stupid grin that most did. Like the song, too.

Michael Johns – Well, that’s not fair to wear the scarf and sing Jim Morrison. Sheesh! OK fine, he’s good, but “they” already know that, right? Help, I’m having Constantine flashbacks…

Looks like VFTW picked Danny Noriega. I concur.

Have they ever drug out the dreaded “flames of rock” this early before? Even though he comes across like a total douche, he seems to be the only adult in the guy group.

I don’t want to like David “only 17″ A., but have to admit he has a very good stage presence and good voice.

I said to myself before Jason C. started “I hope he does something hippy-folky-Woodstock”…Yay for Jason!

Other than those three…pretty dull night with not much talent.

I LOVED me some Constantine! Diffrent strokes, and all that.

So basically I would be shocked at this point if David Archuleta does not win the ENTIRE competition- im a firm believer in not picking a winner at this point in the game but i mean cmon ppl- the kid does EVERYTHING right- even when he hesitated before his final note (which he nailed) worked for him. He is going to do the perfect thing and go from making small mistakes to being perfection by the end of the season. he has the perfect personality too. and not to mention that every single girl 16 and under will vote for him (and me & my mom)-

sorry peeps- no comparison, in terms of the american idol competition, in who took the prize for tonight.

major props to jason castro- proud to have one of the 4 not shone be a baller. maybe chyanne can make a guest appearance this year?!?!

my picks to go hom- deff Jason yager, & prob Garrett H….maybe Luke?

xoxo mj-

Not a single “recording artist” amongst them…not one….

ps- for everyone trying to get rid of the teens- dont be prejudice and sterotyping- cuz right now a couple of them r gunna go realllly far. just cuz ur old and decrepit doesnt mean u have to hate on the youngsters…

I just read through everyones comments, and you all seem to agree with me on everything. Well, except for Michael Johns. I thought he was pretty bad. But Checkezie (sp?) was very disrespectful to Simon, I don’t care how mean Simon was being. Isn’t that kinda what did in Chris Sligh last year, trying to take on Simon? You just don’t do that on the first night, when you have no fan base yet. And Danny is my other pick to go home tonight. Luke was pretty weak, but I hope he stays a little longer just so I can look at him.

What’s the number for Jason Castro? and Luke? SAVE LUKE! And I liked Garrett’s voice; I thought his vocal was better than Luke’s. Can I have Garrett’s number too?

Is it just 1-866- IDOLS-##?

dukesterathlete…..Are you 12? Seriously, learn to spell and isn’t it past your bedtime?

Whatà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s the number for Jason Castro?

1-866-436-5711

My overall take is this: I love love love Jason C. I hate how TPTB try to push certain contestants every year (i.e. David A. & Michael), and I always wind up not liking those contestants. I’m well aware that this is an aspect of the show that will never change, but it doesn’t mean I’ll ever like it. I think that Jason Yeager is a sure shot to go home. As for the other person to leave…I dunno. I hope that David H. and Luke stick around…I think they both looked nervous and are probably much better than what they showed tonight. I’d love if Danny got the boot…I hated his arrogant attitude. He’s not as good as he thinks he is. I also don’t think it was a good idea for Chekezie (sp?) to talk back to Simon. I’m not crazy about most of the young contestants, to be honest.

Wow, weirdness. I’m not sure how I feel about this group as a whole but I’m surprised at how much I liked Jason Castro (I didn’t like his YouTube performances). Very good song choice and the guitar was a nice touch. I…want to comb his hair though.

I find Danny Noriega adorable. God help me. He’s so pretty and campy and cheesy and I just… don’t understand it. It wasn’t a good performance and he’s a worthy VFTW pick.

David A is also adorable. I think he’s totally conventional and vanilla, but he makes my daughter squeal which makes me smile.

I gave a few votes to Jason Y, and Luke for being fodder that I’d like to see one more week. I was going to give Chikesie a vote too, but he copped a tude after a bland performance. Not cool.

Michael Johns once again played it safe. He’s getting flames of pimpage treatment so he’s not going anywhere, but I thought Jason C and David H were better.

Oh yeah, Simon wants David Hernandez gone. I don’t. I gave him some votes too.

Incidentally, is it me, or are the phones not busy at all? I’m voting via gizmo on my computer and I’m getting through almost every time.

Oh and the answer to that question: No. This is not the best talent ever. In my humble opinion.

Oh what a night!!!! I don’t know what to make of all this plants, teens, etc. If they are plants??? I took notes for each from Randy, Paula and Simon. Simon had nothing good to say for anybody except David A, Jason C, and MIchael J. The rest were forgettable. I don’t quite agree with that. Then he said they were looking for a recording star someone special and unique. Makes you wonder how they can judge someone based on them singing someone else’s songs and not compare.

But Danny N will go home thursday. Other than that, it’s anyone’s race.

primeminister – 1-866-436-5708 for Luke – I agree, save Luke, give him another chance (but only a little more, Luke, pick it up next week, k?). He and Jason C have my votes tonight.

Jason Castro FTW. I’m voting for the other cannon fodder,too.

I really want mini-perez (David C) gone.

So Luke disappointed, huh? I’m glad to read the nice Jason Castro comments, though.

Why be surprised the phones aren’t busy? This is a pretty lame crew. I can’t imagine wasting much time voting for any of them. Vocally David A is the best in the bunch (IMO) and yet so boring I wouldn’t spare one vote for him.

I can’t believe I bought the hype that “this is the most talented group ever.” I fear the girls may be equally bad. I mean in all of America they could only find one male R&B singer and no male country singers? But they found at least three teen males who all quite horrible. Blech.

The top 4 of the night for me were Castro, Michael, David A (who I so want to dislike, but he’s so darn adorable), and David H, who really got the shaft by going first. Mary, I totally agree – Simon wants him out STAT. I’m voting for him the most tonight just because of that.

David C disappointed me, but upon rewatching the performance, it wasn’t as bad as I originally thought. I still kinda like him. Our local Fox affiliate keeps showing Robbie over, and over, and over, (he’s a semi-local guy for me) so of course I’ve gotten a chance to reevaluate. Better than I originally thought, but still not in the top 4.

I still think Luke’s mic was turned WAY down. I mean, of course he’s more eyecandy than anything, but he’s so. freaking. gorgeous. He gets votes from me too. I dunno about busy signals because I’m texting.

It’s not that he sucked, purple. His voice was just a little weak. He didn’t really stand out at all.

purps, come to chat. Jason C did well.

Man….what I wouldn’t give for just ONE baritone, rich voice….just one……..

I hope the curse of going first doesn’t mean the end for David H., I think he has potential. I liked Jason and Michael, too. But the one that surprised me was Robbie, because I was prepared to dislike him because of his boy-band past, but I really thought his performance of “One” was a solid one.

There’re still the girls, Nostra. All is not lost…

Aw, Luke Menard is at the bottom of DI! How’d that happen? He so pretty!!

longsong….True, but other than Amanda, I don’t hear anyone who’s not cut from the same old tired cookie cutter….GO AMANDA!!!

MaryS-NJ – You can’t comb something like that. You just have to shave it and start over. Be careful, there might be small animals nesting! (I really like Jason Castro best of all!)

I’m voting with DialIdol and I’m getting through EVERY time! Do you think that Idol has more phone lines now or do you think that we’re the only ones who still care enough to vote?

Thanks for that original performance, Michael! Isn’t it wonderful when you can sing a song like somebody else and nobody questions whether you “made it your own”?

I almost died when Randy said to David A that he is only 17 and then David A repeated it. Great comedy! No wonder David was laughing so much.

I liked Robbie, Jason C, David H, and Garrett (because I’m loyally sticking to the buckeye dude/Frampton and want to hear him one more time before I have to find a new favorite). I hope he finds more courage and belief in self. Luke looked so sad or mad at the end. I wonder what happened to his mike.

Nigel Lythgoe is what happened to Luke’s mic.

Michael Johns is a major favorite of mine and he did stand above the crowd tonight, but my votes are going to Garrett. I think Michael did better because he is the more experienced performer, but listening to Garrett, I heard a really great voice with some shaky nerves that he will lose for sure if given the chance to move on. So tonight, my votes are going to 1-866IDOLS10 for Garrett!!

Jersey, I couldn’t resist and listened to Luke’s clip at rickey’s. Yeah, that didn’t do anything for me. If I didn’t know how he looks, I won’t be voting for him, either (if I could).

I also listened to Jason’s clip. It did not blow me away (yet), but I liked it enough. Certainly better than Luke’s.

Vote Luke!!!!

1-866IDOLS08

DI still has him as last!!!

I am voting for six guys and getting through every time.

One of those guys is Jason Castro, 20 year old Texas A&M student. He put life into that tired old song! I hope we get a chance to see him play drums sometime during the season. I do not like dreads, but I like him.

*ahem!* dukestr – you might want to read the guidelines. This here’s a civilised board.

Regarding dreads – is there such a thing as clean dreads? I really don’t mind them, it gives you all kinds of hairstyling options, but I’m hoping he’s not smelly. Just curious.

i really dont understand why everyone is making such a big boo-hoo sympathy story for these people who didnt get air time….i realized tonight why they didnt get any airtime- its because they are COMPLETELY BORING and COMPLETELY BLOW (im refering to jason yager, luke, & garrett) Jason Castro was very good- he deserves votes- but voting for someone because they didnt get shown when they had their chance and sucked it up??!! think about it- doesnt make sense.

ps. go david a. & danny & david h.!

I’m trying to think of when I saw someone saying they’d vote for so-and-so due to lack of air time. Hmmm…..

Longsong- i read the guidelines- i did nothing wrong…ill be nice to u cuz u like danny too. is it true he is openly gay? i mean, it does make sense and i think it will work in his favor. hes got a great personality…

ur rly asi9. gro ^ & b poh lite

You missed my post, duke. I DON’T like Danny, he’s my least favorite.

And now I’m off. Toodles!

Is it my imagination or does the one guy look kinda like Joey Lawrence only with long hair. Geesh I don’t even know these guys names except the last one – he’s kinda yummy. Michael Johns. :rasberry_ee:

so um i dont know if anyone checked out VFTW but they picked Danny as the worst tonight?? ur gunna tell me that luke, garrett, chezike, jason y & colton were better than him tonight?? im sorry- but it seems highly plausible that there is homophobia going on. i think they just want to find another sanjaya to hipe up- and danny is lightyears better than sanjaya. it just doesnt make sense to me.

I feel so dirty that I like the chosen one. Yet, I do. (Duh, Michael Johns)

But, I really like Jason Yeager’s voice. Thought his song sucked tonight, but I like his voice.

Over all, the boys did NOT impress me tonight. Feeling a little frightened about tomorrow night. Not a fan of any of the girls.

Yes, I’m back. Thanks for the fanfare ;o)

The best performance of the night goes to David Archuleta. He sang his guts out, and charmed America with that sweet smile, gorgeous eyes, and humble manner.

Unfortunately the worst performances come from guys I like: Luke, Jason, and Chikeze. How strange for ppl who claim to have watched the show ‘from season one’ to perform slow songs/ballads. They should know that unless you wow America from your very first performance you are dead in the water.

Somehow I knew Danny was going to perform an Elvis song, a novelty song. He didn’t nail it, but his huge fanbase will pull him through. However, if he keeps going this route that fanbase won’t have enough pull in future episodes.

Among those who are going home in order of liklihood: Jason; Luke; Colton; Garrett.

Don’t bother to respond to dukester. He’s banned.

People who disregard my guidelines don’t last here very long.

West Coast here….I love how Ryan said at the beginning of the show that “people” are saying it’s one of the best talent years ever. The “people” are American Idol employees. Obviously the show is putting that line out there to convince America that the show is not “on the decline.”

Oh yeah. I forgot. Pretty boy Luke Menard was so so bad. Hahaha! Hope he makes it through for me to enjoy his eye-candy self, but damn. That was not good.

so um, duke. that’s not the way VFTW works. They pick the contestant most likely to be a burr under the saddle of TPTB, not the worst singer. They (VFTW) make a point of trying to mess with the Idol producer’s eeeevil plans to manipulate the contestants and the viewing audience.

Danny is this season’s Sanjaya.

eta: nevermind. mj, you’re *fast*

I was happy to finally hear Jason Castro. It was worth the wait. To me, Michael Johns is the one most likely to be successful and the only one tonight with sex appeal. I didn’t really like any of the teens but I’m sure they’ll be safe.

My favorite tonight were Michael Johns, David Cook, and Jason Castro. The worst IMO, Chikezie (sp?) Jason Y., and Luke. I also liked David H, and the Archuleta boy.

My favorite tonight were Michael Johns, David Cook, and Jason Castro. The worst IMO, Chikezie (sp?) Jason Y., and Luke. I also liked David H, and the Archuleta boy.

I’ve voted for the cannon fodder. Mostly, Castro. He’s so charming and I love the inflections he put into his vocals. I’ll worry about him when he looses the security of his guitar.

MJohns… I resent him, but he was pretty good. And has nice arms. Can’t believe he did the Doors again. No wait. I called it.

Someone needs to call Ryan and tell him ………no, this is not the most talented group EVER based on tonight.

I guess tomorrow night is the Irish Girl’s night. Yuk, not looking forward to that.

Damn – I can see the final three now – the Irish Girl, the Australian and the 17-year-old. Hopefully, there is a sleeper in there somewhere who will take step up to the plate and kick some butt!!

Has anyone figured out yet where Carly was tonight?

Hopefully on her way out of this competition. The worst part of this whole thing is that Randy worked there when she was signed, and for that reason alone she should be kicked off. It’s a conflict of interest, and violates fairness.

KrazeeK120 Feb 19th, 2008 at 11:38 pm

Has anyone figured out yet where Carly was tonight?

I agree that the best of the night was David A. I knew he could sing, but DAYUM, I didn’t know he had soul too. Michael Johns is the best rocker there, hands down. Plus, he smoulders with those rugged good looks and that reserved nature. Carrico looks the part and picked a great song but was just OK for me. He needs to work on cultivating a grittier, more angsty style if he wants to advance. Jason Castro did not disappoint…he did a great job!

I can’t decide who was worse – Jason Y or Luke or Chikeze. Danny N was surprisingly good and is probably safe.

I didn’t even notice Carly’s absence – hope she is OK.

David A was the best performer IMHO, he sang his face off, he is adorable, and it’s not his fault that they haven’t mentioned his Star Search past. Michael Johns is an exciting performer but he was a bit off tonight. Mr. Eze was stupid I guess he never watched the show, bad on him. I don’t understand the premise of VFTW anymore. Danny Noriega is their pick. I guess I will have to mosey on over there and see their thinking. I actually don’t dig them so much because in trying to screw over the show, they are screwing over the contestants, once again JMO.

Overall, imo, too many of the guys sound the same, like last year. Too many of the ballad type voices. I would like a few more gritty or deeper voices from the guys each year and at least one country singer. I like Michael Johns, the guy with the long dreads, and the first guy who sang, David H. I think. I wasnt keen on an aussie or an irish girl being in american idol since they could compete in their own countrys version, but Michael said tonight he had been living in USA for 10 yrs now so I’m willing to give him a pass. I really wish they would quit with the themes and let them all pick their own songs. They mostly put out cds with different types of music on it then what we hear them sing on Idol so their cds dont sell as well. No wonder.

Chikezie Eze and Danny Noriega have got to go first.
I don’t know how much of Archuleta I can stomach. He’s a
male Diana DeGarmo…trained since birth, entered in every
contest available. NO MORE TEENS! Let ‘em grow up, grow hair and come back; then we’ll talk!

That wasn’t as good as I was expecting but I think a lot of it had to do with dealing with a theme and it being the first show combined.

I came in wanting to vote for Chikeze but his backtalking did him in, not to mention the flat performance.

I want David A to come live with me. He has an inner glow and he just made me completely happy.

Danny N cracked me up with his “Some people didn’t like it.” But overall his face expressions got on my nerves.

I know Luke didn’t perform well but I really liked his voice.

Love David H and Jason Castro who I thought picked the best song for himself. It just sounded so natural and pleasant. It sounded like a song I would like sang to me if I were on a picnic. LOL

Jason Castro is SO awkward on that Idol stage. It cracks me up (no pun intended)! After a whole string of pageantry performances though, I totally dug his take on “Daydream.” Definitely not Idol’s standards of best voice, but refreshing nonetheless.

I also find myself longing for older, more seasoned performers. Taylor (although I’m not a big fan) could have BLOWN any of these guys out of the water. I really think the teens stunk it up this round.

All in all, Season 7 is off to a slow start. Gone are the days of Season 5 where the guys opened it up with some mind-blowing, original performances. I think the whole idea of theme nights in the Top 24 ABSOLUTELY STINKS. Now it’s more karaoke than ever! And 60′s Night?!?! Sure, the 60′s had some great music, but I think it’s definitely a step backwards from the creativity and artistry they allowed in the past 2 years.

Badly done, Nigel, badly done.

OMG I nearly forgot.. Simon calling Chikeze .. Jacuzzi had me on the floor!

I heard elsewhere that Kristie was also missing tonight. Anyone else know if this is true? What’s up with that?

Top 12 Boys – Songs of the Sixties
————————————

General Comments
—————-
1. Can’t wait to hear from the four “Silent Ones” tonight.

2. Ryan says that people are saying that this is the Top 24 ever. Who would these people be, Ryan? You, Nigel and the three judges?

3. Chandler: Could there BE anymore commercials?

4. How did a song from the 50′s qualify for “Songs of the Sixties?”

Performance Comments
——————–

1. David H. – “In the Midnight Hour” (1965 – Wilson Pickett) – Interesting arrangement, but the background singers dragged it a bit into Muzak territory. Started great, but some trouble with that glory note at the end. Can he overcome the dreaded death spot?

2. Chickezie – “More Today than Yesterday” (1969 – Spiral Starecase) – Interesting suit. Vocals were a bit weak in the beginning, but got stronger during the glory notes. Something was missing. A bit of a spark. Never argue with the judges like that. Never.

3. David C. – “Happy Together” (1967 – The Turtles) – This guy has the worst hair. What’s he trying to grow on his face? Man do I HATE this arrangement. Way to smash the funky beat right out of the song. Glory notes are not his friend. Well, he at least tried something new.

4. Jason Y. – “Moon River” (1961 – Audrey Hepburn) – His voice is has a very nice tone. His style is a little caberat. Best pure vocal so far. A little cheesy. Well played to mention this is the first time Simon has been critical of him.

5. Robbie – “One is the Loneliest Number” (1969 – Three Dog Night) – Everything about this guy seems calculated. I never noticed how repetitive song this is. Like, what, 7 words? I liked the arrangement and he sounded good.

6. David A. – “Shop Around” (1960 – The Miracles) – I’m not sure his voice has healed. It sounds a little muffled. He’s a cute kid. I HATE the way he licks his lips after every phrase. Drove me nuts in the Hollywood episode and he’s still doing it. OMG! Randy shutup about the 17. SHUTUP! I think I twitched when he mentioned it. This is going to be a LONG season. Simon, his performance was good but it wasn’t that great.

7. Danny N. – “Jailhouse Rock” (1957 – Elvis Presley) – I don’t know about this song choice. Elvis has some pretty big shoes to fill and Danny doesn’t really have the edge to pull it off. His voice is good enough and his personality is known enough that he is safe. Simon is right. Lose the attitude, kid.

8. Luke – “Everybody’s Talkin’” (1968 – Harry Nilsson) – He has a pretty voice. It was a bit off, though. Needed something with more “oomph”. Simon may be right that the performance was forgetable, but Luke’s face isn’t.

9. Colton – “Suspicious Minds” (1969 – Elvis Presley) – This is an odd kid. Poor Elvis. I want a snear, not a smirk. It’s not a good thing you are caught in trap. Don’t smile. Does he know what this song was about? His voice is nice enough.

10. Garret – “Breaking Up is Hard to Do” (1962 – Neil Sedaka) – Nice enough voice. Needs some training. Decent introduction to one of the silent ones. Much better than I expected, but not that original. Hair should keep him memorable. Seems like a nice kid.

11. Jason C – “Daydream” (1966 – Lovin’ Spoonful) – Nice move with the guitar. Great song choice for him. He’s come to play. Best job out of the “Silent Ones”. Fun performance!

12. Michael – “Light My Fire” – (1966 – The Doors) – We JUST heard him sing this song last week. Dude, we know you can sing it. Sings last AND gets the flames of pimpage. Definitely one of TCOs. Good performance, but I’m deducting points for singing the same song. Blah.

Top 4: Jason C., Michael, Robbie, David A.
Bottom 4: Chikezie, Colton, Danny N., David C.

Who Should Go Home: Chikezie and Colton
Who Will Go Home: Chikezie and Jason Y (tough call)

Just finished watching on the West Coast. For once in a great long while, Ryan got it right about saving the best for last. Michael Johns is, quite simply, in a different class from any previous or current AI top 24 contestant in style and substance. He surpasses Constantine’s pretensions and Chris Sligh’s early expectations. According to his AI mini bio, Johns is a Neil Finn fan. Happy happy joy joy! Since Josiah isn’t around to sing Jeff Buckley, Michael is my best hope to elevate the AI7 catalog — unless David Archuleta sings Weezer. Nyuk nyuk.

I really like David Hernandez, but he is a hybrid of every loser I have ever cared about — Elliott Yamin meets Rudy Cardenas with a hint of Patrick Hall. Like Rudy and Patrick, David H. was the first to go first in the cannon fodder slot.

I only watched maybe an hour of the auditions this year, but now I’m getting sucked right back into the swirling cesspool.

I thought David Hernadez was so much better than he got credit for. I hope he gets another shot next week. Also, the guy who did Moon River, Jason,-beautiful, smooth voice but it wasn’t appreciated.
On the other hand, Danny N-just didn’t do it for me and the faces were so over the top. No likey. I didn’t think David A was nearly as good as the praise. I also thought Robbie did a good job. The wallet chain undid me. Notice it is longer than Daughtry’s.
I think everyone’s audition and Hollywood footage should be shown to put things on a more fair playing field. Plus, I would like to see them all.
weakest tonight-Garret, Chickezie, Luke (please let him stay for sheer good looks) Danny N, Colton
Best tonight and that is relative cause it just wasn’t great-Michael, Robbie, and Jason for quirkiness
in between-David A, David H, Jason Y, David C

For the most talent evah-i wasn’t blown away. Season 5 is still lighting my fire:)

Best Tonight — Jason Castro
Worst — Chickezie, Luke, Danny N, Colton (the performance, not the voice)

Other observations:

1) Michael Johns is obviously talented and seems like a nice guy, but he comes on a little too strong. Like he knows he’s good.

2) What is it with the superstar hair styles this year? David Cook, Colton, Danny N — a bit over the top, don’t you think?

3) Colton’s theatrics made me cringe. He did not seem to understand the lyrics of the song.

4) Danny N — great voice and potential, but my husband hit the nail on the head. You cannot do a gay Elvis — the two just don’t mix. David Bowie maybe, but not Elvis.

5)Talking back to the judges is a big turnoff — will not win you any votes.

Yea, got a great link that I could watch as we don’t get the show til Friday. Now I can play too! Interesting, not what I expected. My takes?

1. David H curse of going first shame. He’s got a good voice with deer in the headlights. I’d like to see him stay and relax a bit.

2. Chikeze stop! Please shut up now. uh oh you’re in trouble.

3. David C finally took a shower and washed his hair, but someone hid his gel and now he can’t do anything with it. Liked the song, not feeling him

4. Jason Y, ahhh, sweet and cheesy. Lovely tone to his voice but not memorable

5. Robbie, lol Kirsten, yea it is repetitive!

6. David A, very polished and cute. I can’t help liking him.

7. Danny I liked! As someone else said, an emo Elvis. Camp funny and he does have a good voice. Maybe not the best song choice. Gay Elvis LOL!

8. Luke, ohhh, he’s so purdy, can I take him home with me please?

9. Colton, hmmmm, stop smiling, you aren’t getting this song. Nice voice tho.

10. Garrett, ahhh, clueless, lamb to slaughter, out of his league. Poor kid…..

11. Jason C. WOW!! the surprise of the night! Where did he come from? Loved it. Strange but dreads aside is any else seeing a resemblence to John Stamos? Dark horse.

12 Michael. well what can you say? Very professional with a lot of charisma. Didn’t want to like him but hard not to. Pure Doors’ Jim Morrison appeal. If I can’t look at Luke I guess he’ll do!

(A trivia note, the very first ever “Idol”, the UK Will Young did Light My Fire as his signature song. Simon panned it, Will talked back respectfully pulled it off and Simon actually apologised the following week. An Idol first and last. Will did the Jose Feliciano version.)

So it will be interesting to see who goes on Thursday! There’s a lot of queries of where Carly was, I read a lot of them are down with the flu, maybe she was too sick to come?

Not many stuck out last night for me. I thought Jason Y. did a good job on “Moon River”. Andy Williams would have been proud.

Danny N. and Colton B. most likely had Elvis spinning in his grave. I wanted to slap that smile off Colton’s face.

David A. made my teeth ache. He sang the song well, but I hated the gushing, laughing, “I’m 17!” aftermath. Did absolutely nothing for me.

I completely understood Simon’s comments about Garrett needing some fresh air. Between the hair, the gauntness of his face and the lighting, he looked as if he was going to keel over at any minute.

Jason C. did a great job on a feel good song. I hate the dreads.

Michael Johns…….meh. Cute guy trying too hard.

None of these guys made me really sit up and take notice. Most of them are sooooo young and have nothing in their voice to show they’ve lived. I finished watching the show feeling very underwhelmed. I really hope things improve!

I’m hoping that next week will be better for the boys. If the rumor that everyone had the flu this week was true, maybe they were all suffering from the effects? (One can only hope.)

Did anyone else hear crickets throughout the show or was it JUST ME?

I hate when I anticipate something so much and it falls on its face…

Please girls, save me tonight.

Over all, it was OKAY, but there was just like a good hour in the middle where it was one blah song after another.

Best surprise of the cannon fodder: Jason Castro! I REALLY enjoyed him tonight!

Worst downfall of the cannon fodder: Luke Menard. Damn. He was so cute too! Think his good looks will hold him on another week? It was just dreadful! Really, if this Idol thing doesn’t work out, I wouldn’t mind seeing him on my Grey’s Anatomy…

The get off my tv:
Garrett Haley. Awe, he had such a nice voice, but what a blah, boring song. Nice kid though.

Colton Berry: The cheese factor was just a bit too much for me to take.

Danny Noreiga. I didn’t like his song. I don’t like his attitude. He just strikes me as punk teenager who doesn’t know how to keep his mouth shut. He had a decent enough of a voice, but nothing I couldn’t live without.

Robbie Carrico. Overall it wasn’t bad, but the song had, what, five stupid words? I mean really, Robbie? I AGREE with Simon. Your “rock” edge isn’t very authentic. I think you’re a pop singer too, and I can’t stand you.

The GOOD:

As much as I hate to admit this, I loved David Archuleta. He was a nice surprise in an otherwise dull evening.

David Hernandez. The beginning was much better than the rest, but he can really sing.

MY FAVORITE:

Jason Castro!!!! What a NICE surprise. I just loved him and his song choice and it just all went together so well! He also gets massive props for being the only contestant to play the guitar.

Michael Johns. Jim Morrison he is not, but I just loved it anyway because he did a great song. *bow down to the chosen one*

The gone: Jason Yeager. He had a nice enough voice, but boorrrrring.
Luke Menard. I don’t think pretty can save him from that performance.

They got rid of groups on Hollywood Week, but groups separates the driven and the best from the rest IMO. When you pair them in groups you see who’s the leader, the most motivated to win….it’s not all about backstabbing….I think groups would have brought out the real “men” vs. the wimps we got last night.

I LOVE LOVE LOVE Jason Castro. He’s my choice and I agree with Simon, he’s got that something. Psyched he was able to put it out there last night.

Disappointed with Luke and Chickeze.

I am with LOLA, I am not sure how much of David A. I am going to be able to take! Yikes! Did he speak a sentence after he sang? I think he’s a little pagenty.

I found the personality of the guys to be a little grating in their post song interviews. Colton was definitely theatrical, Garrett’s (I think he’s the one) watched the show enough to know to say he’s taking the criticism home to soak in for next week and not mouth off… Chickeze hello!

Anyway, I LOVE Ryan’s subtle dig to Robbie Carrico about him looking like Justin Timberlake. THAT was funny!!

To Bobbi: Did you feel like me that Simon was ready to walk out at one point? I thought he would throw his pencil across the stage floor in disgust

Sigh… I knew it was too good to be true. Luke can’t sing. Oh well, he can always be an underwear model. I think the best were Michael. Jason was OK. David has a good voice, but he is just too cutsie for me. I wish Danny would go away, he annoys me.

GMA has Kyle Ensley and Nina Shaw on this morning talking about the “ringers.” They quoted Simon’s comments last night about Michael having the natural confidence of a lead singer……well, of course he does because he was! Nina said they have an advantage. Then they went into Carly and Kristi Lee Cook’s stories. Kyle said the plants weren’t well known so doesn’t think it matters. Michael Slezak said it is going to take a lot more than this to put a huge dent in the ratings. Pretty lame coverage, actually.

Sally, actually I was surprised by how well Simon took some of the kidding, but yeah…….I thought he really wasn’t pleased with some of what was on stage last night.

But Luke CAN sing….just not on TV when it matters…*sigh*

He’s a local for me, somewhat. His little hole in the wall is about 2 hours away, near Lafayette, Indiana. They had him on my local news last night showing about what he looked like in high school( drop dead gorgeous still) and his wife saying she thinks America is going to fall in love with him…

Well, we DID fall in love with him…just not his singing. Which I know he has in there somewhere…

Please stay one more week so you can possibly redeem yourself and not sing such a boring song with your mic turned down.

In the fresh (cold) light of morning, I wish they would have saved the theme nights for the top 12 and given us a chance to get to know the contestants before putting them in uncomfortable song choice options.

I realize there’s no going back now, but I think I for one would have been more blown away, a la season 5, had they gotten to pick their own songs to showcase themselves to their best ability.

I just read Michael Slezak’s take on last night. Surprisingly, he liked Robbie Carrico! But, overall, he was disappointed too. I think that’s probably going to be the primary reaction.

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20007164_20171835_20178941,00.html

Randy was on Letterman last night still trying to pump life into the “best top 12 ever.” They really need to rethink the only four mentors this season. I don’t see the fascinating personalities and back stories that warrent a ton of focus. Plus the songs choices was quite horrible making me wonder about their musical tastes.

To Bobbi: Did you feel like me that Simon was ready to walk out at one point? I thought he would throw his pencil across the stage floor in disgust

Yea, I thought that too, there was one shot to the judges where he was turned sideways in his chair and it looked like he was going to get up and leave. He did look bored and disgusted.

Maybe annoyed that Danny is probably going to be around awhile and we all KNOW he is going to bug Simon to death!

Simon? He’s going to bug ME to death!

I will say that I thoroughly enjoyed the show last night even with the 60′s theme. I hope I can say the same after the show tonight.

I finally caught the show and I’m just so glad Jason Castro did well because I am afraid I/we would be saying goodbye to dear Luke so soon.

When Simon told Garrett he looked like he needed air, I would have loved Garrett to say, “You’re right I needed air TIME. That would have helped.” But instead, Garrett gave the “constructive criticism” response……….which shows he a much nicer person than either Simon or me.

1. David H. – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“In the Midnight Hourà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – bad luck going first. He did better than I expected considering I didn’t really remember him at all from earlier weeks. Bad last note. Good looking enough. He’ll stay a bit.

2. Chickezie – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“More Today than Yesterdayà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  -Not outstanding & a bad move talking back to Simon, altho I did laugh out loud at his comment that it’s hard to be current on 60′s night!

3. David C. – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Happy Togetherà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  -I’ve disliked him due to his boxy weird hair. But I thought he tried to do something different w/ the song & I he did better than I expected. He’ll stay a bit.

4. Jason Y. – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Moon Riverà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – buh-bye.

5. Robbie – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“One is the Loneliest Numberà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – Hadn’t noticed him before but he seemed the most in tune so far. Nice job.

6. David A. – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Shop Aroundà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – Seemed like he was singing in a lower range than usual. He’ll be around a long time.

7. Danny N. – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Jailhouse Rockà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  -How did this make 60′s night? Not a good move to do a song that was so well-known from a previous idol. He sang OK, got a little growly which was unexpected….but he was just all over the place. Of course Simon would hate it – he hated Taylor’s as well. He does get points for wearing tight straightleg jeans, tho, as I’m tired of the guys wearing their baggy jeans around their thighs w/ their boxers showing.

8. Luke – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Everybodyà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s Talkinà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – He’ll slide by on looks.

9. Colton – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Suspicious Mindsà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – Again – a memorable song from when Daughtry did it. This kid is just to weird.

10. Garret – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Breaking Up is Hard to Doà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – All the great songs of the 60′s and he picks this? Buh-bye.

11. Jason C – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Daydreamà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – I didn’t know guitars were allowed at this stage – way to stand out! I liked him! I didn’t know him from adam but I liked him. He’s like a spark.

12. Michael – à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“Light My Fireà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  – Well, obviously he’s going to be around a long time. Funny how no one complains that he’s “too old”. Good performance tho.

Good morning, MJ friends!
Several of you have had me crying already and trying not to spew coffee on my computer! I’m so glad the season has started!
And I LOVE Jason Castro!!

OK, David A is gonna be around for a long time. His fan base (Im betting) is going to carry him through well into the season. He’s a little too cutsey for me but he can sing. The last guy, Johns? He was terrific i think.

Best top 12 ever? Thats debateable. the best pimped top 12? Oh yeah.

I will never understand why these “kids” dont understand that when you get on that stage its important to really give the performance of your life. You cant hold anything back and this year as in seasons past I keep yelling at the tv saying “come on”!, this is no time to be conservative! Get out there and make me remember you! Thats what T did, thats what Daughtry did, thats what E did and thats what Blake did and its what Sanjaya did. (dont even go there, I loved him).

I agreed with Simon 100% of the time last night. They werent giving it all they had and Im sure nerves were a big part but the time is now to make me want to pick up that phone. So far I havent heard or seen that performance or that performer who makes me want to do that. Not YET.

Oh yeah, how could I forget Danny N? Another decent talent who will have a large fan base. Im not counting him out just yet. The young girls will love danny and david A. They will be one the phones and texting all freaking night.

So far Im liking this season.

Luke menard looks like Patrick dempsey. If he fail enter the top 12, he can try apply as Patrick younger brother in Grey Anatomy.

My initial impression is that whoever decided to make the semi-finals theme weeks needs to be immediately fired.

Those were the three weeks where you could get to know who these kids were musically by doing their type of music and the songs they think they perform best.

Instead, we now get awful 60′s covers. As if any one of the contestants would put out that kind of an album.

Horrible, horrible by TPTB.

Oh, and put me down for Castro being the best of the night. Cook and Carrico right behind. You can have the rest. Including the Aussie.

My favorite last nite was David A.. Not because he has the best voice but because his voice is smooth..doesn’t push..his smile is beautiful, his personality is adorable and he makes me happy just looking at him.. I was with Ryan last nite..I wanted to adopt him..LOL

I also loved Jason Castro & liked Robbie, David C, Michael J, David H and Danny N.

Chikeze..tsk tsk…I wanted to like him..but he blew it last nite with his back talk imo..

Good Day NY had two male editors from US Weekly on talking about last night. They singled out Michael, David and Jason Castro while mentioning Jason had no previous airtime but still managed to standout, they think David and Michael will be the F2 (without even seeing the women sing?) and one of the editors just went on and on about the greatness that is Michael Johns and the hosts were agreeing. It was very over the top and made me roll my eyes a little.

.

There have been 3 performances of Jailhouse Rock on American Idol.

The first one was Jon Peter Lewis in Season 3 ( the following night, he was eliminated ).

The second one was of course, Taylor Hicks ( Season 5) which Simon called plain silly ( which for some reason was requested again by Rebecca Romijn at elimination night ).

Then we have Danny Noriega.

let’s put it this way — ANYTIME YOU SING THIS SONG, YOU ARE IN FOR A SIMON BASHING.

I agree with you, Easy, about theme week being a bad idea for Top 24. This should be a time when we could get a sense of the musical tastes of the contestants by the song choices.

Between myself and one friend we’ve correctly called the top 12 and the final 2 for each season by the end of the second week’s performances. As for these men: Michael Johns won’t be in the final 2, but David Archuleta probably will if he doesn’t choke on country night. Danny will make the top 12. As with every year there is going to be a ‘shocking elimination’, not because it is fixed (as most using online forums will claim), but because of the way the voting trends go when the list of contestants become shorter. (usually around position 5 or 4)

With the ringers or plants or whatever you wish to call them now in the top 24 it is obvious to die-hard fans that the show began its decline with season 6. Unless TPTB stand up and fix their mess the show won’t last much beyond two more seasons, especially once Cowell’s contract is up in 2010. (he’s indicated several times that he won’t sign again when it expires) Nearly all successful shows historically begin their decline about the seventh season.

This is a sad time for us fan-atics. I routinely watch all of the old episodes straight from season one onward many times through the year and still say that season two was its peak and it was THAT season which had “the best talent ever” where 9 to 10 of the top 12 were awesome. Season three had a lot of great talent as well.

Oh, and as for those who keep saying the show is BECOMING too gay? Guess what? Here is a list, all of whose names can be found in the press. (i.e. it isn’t original with me)

Season 01: Jim Veraros; Ejay Day; RJ Helton
Season 02: Vanessa Olivarez; (some claim Clay, but he says no)
Season 04: Anwar Robinson
Season 05: Will Makar; Ace Young (bi)
Season 06: Sanjaya Malakar
Season 07: Danny Noriega

Oh, and as for those who keep saying the show is BECOMING too gay? Guess what? Here is a list, all of whose names can be found in the press. (i.e. it isnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t original with me)

Season 01: Jim Veraros; Ejay Day; RJ Helton
Season 02: Vanessa Olivarez; (some claim Clay, but he says no)
Season 04: Anwar Robinson
Season 05: Will Makar; Ace Young (bi)
Season 06: Sanjaya Malakar
Season 07: Danny Noriega

I think AJ Tabaldo is also gay. Colton B. and David A., too. Heh. *hides*

At one point while I was watching the show, my sister passed by the TV and suddenly asked, “is that the gay one?” referring to David Cook. LOL

Yeah, my gaydar goes off for Colton, but since I haven’t seen his name in the press mentioned as gay I didn’t want to list it since it could be construed as slanderous. From what I’ve read from friends and colleagues of David Archuleta he is a strict Mormon and NOT gay, but if he changes his mind he can give me a call anytime ;.) AJ never struck me as gay, just tender and gentle.

The fun thing to think about is that because during season 01 and 02 the contestants all lived in a mansion what was going on with all those gay guys? ;.) Of course, we die-hards know what was going on season 02 on all fronts.

Well, Will Young, the first “idol” winner ever in the UK Pop Idol show that started this whole madness is gay too.

I half-watched last night as I will NOT get hung up on AI the way I have been the last two years and this is why: AI doesn’t want a BIG voice to win, they want a ‘pop’ sound and, historically speaking, the ‘pop, unemotional, non-personality’ voice is the voice that sells Top 40 hits.

So, while a couple or so contestants may have dead-on awesome voices this isn’t necessarily what AI is looking for nor is it what sells in today’s pop market.

Last night I come to the conclusion that I really want to like David A., but when he opens his mouth talking, he sounds just like any other inmature 17yr. old. I don’t want a fluffy guy Idol, I want more of a Dinty Moore kinda of guy on the Idol stage singing in my ear.
On the subject of Luke Menard..sweetie you can come and sing while you are cleaning my carpets anyday. :wink_ee:

Wow, last night was not the blow out I thought it would be. A little disapointed so I will list them as I see them from bad to better:

I was hoping Luke sang as well as he looked, but he is just a little mouse. Too bad. He was by far the worst of the night, but his internet pics will keep him around until next week I am sure.

Colton was way over the top and I thought he would swollow the mic in a big gulp of air…hes gotto go.

Leif,(his parents misnamed him Garret) is such a little sweetie with a charming voice. He kept his cool but I don’t know if all the little teenies can keep him from going home.

I hope Chikeze gets another chance, he was corny but he’s old enough to know that and fix it for next week.

Jason Y was very pretty and reminded me of Pat Boone. Definately cruiseboat worthy. His little boy was darling and will save daddy for next week.

David Cook looked so uptight staring at the camera when Ryan was talking to Colton…scary plus. I liked what he sang but his weirdness factor is not going to pull votes

Jason C sang surprizingly well, but maybe I only think so because everyone else was not so great. He looks like he doesn’t belong there and wants someone to save him. He was hiding behind the guitar and the dreads seem to be window dressing. He could not have stood there and sang without the props.

Robbie sang well and was comfortable but I can’t get on the bandwagon yet. Please loose the bandana. I would like to see more of what he can do.

Danny, what a riot! Flaming and all, love the attitude. His song was right on with his personality. He will be fun to have on the show for a long time.

David H has a voice! But the boy he was nervous. He reminds me of Elliott in that his voice is going to carry him through the competition. I hope he enjoys the ride.

David A was very good, but I keep thinking of him as a big care bear. I could use a little less “Aw, shucks” attitude.

Micheal was my favorite. He is a natural. Maybe a professional natural, but good nevertheless

My gaydar was going off for pretty much all the guys: Colton, Danny, both Davids…not that it matters. I actually think there’s a method to the madness. With the exception of David A, i think the pack of teenage boys is supposed to serve as fillers…maybe TPTB are expecting them to be eliminated early on as a result of Sanjaya-backlash.

Jason and Michael were definitely my favorites of the night. For some reason, the show felt more “karaoke” than ever before. Jason and Michael were last night’s saving graces for sure.

And uh….what happened in season 2? I consider myself to be a fairly “die hard” AI fan, but i have no idea

Hi B! Good to see you on the board again. Can’t help you with the season 2 stuff, ’cause I’m clueless too. Hope Dov comes back and explains.

Here’s a nice way to put it: ‘Sex, drugs, & rock ‘n roll’, with bitch fights galore. Add some backstabbing, fakery, and secret affairs and you have the fun that was season 02 “behind the scenes”.

Don’t worry, Clay was actually one of the nice ones.

So what rocks harder: a really long wallet chain, a skanky bandana hanging out of the back pocket, or a scarf? I hope these guys aren’t getting any fashion help yet. That’s the only reasonable explanation for how David C, Robbie and Michael dressed. I’m also still pondering Colton’s bedazzled bright blue pants, too.

I enjoyed Jason C. for the sheer anti-Idolness of his performance. His voice was weird and different, but it’s kind of hard to tell with that song. Fortunately, we should get to hear more of him next week.

Luke on my tv was even prettier than Luke in pictures and more disappointing than I ever would have imagined as a singer. Sigh.

Most of them were too boring to get a reaction from me, but David C was so over the top in his Constantine imitation I wanted to punch him in the face. Connie may be gross, but he did have a performance style I enjoyed at times. I suspect David was up late “studying” youtube videos of “I Think I Love You” all week. At the same time, he looked like he was trying out for the Jack Black role in a community theatre production of School of Rock. I don’t get why someone who has been in bands for so long comes across as such a desperate poser. He has a pretty good voice, I wish he wouldn’t try so hard. He should perform with a guitar next week and leave the camera and microphone stand alone.

Does anyone think they’ll have a Doors theme next week? I hope Michael sings Light My Fire!

no way, i’m hoping for queen next week! i wonder what michael would sing?!?!?! :O

i love david cook and jason castro. and i’m rooting for danny and colton (who i hear is also openly gay, fwiw) to both do well – they weren’t perfect last night, but i adore them.

Great recap MJ. You brought up some of the same burning questions I had like what happened to Jason’s baby’s mama, why was Colton smiling like a madman & what happened to Chikeze’s last name?
Here are my faves of the night: Michael Johns, Jason Castro, David Cook, “bitchy” Simon & loopy Pauler.

guys..rather boring
gals next..hope we are not going to be presented with nothing but hootchie stuff.

Hootchie stuff … I just had flashbacks of Haley Scarnato singing “I’m saving my love for you … and you … and you” while doing the stripper shimmy.

Looks like everything that was going to be said by me has been said.

Still. I plunge in and give my assessment.

First of all. Has anyone addressed Simon’s white sidewall hairdo? What is THAT?? His girlfriend must secretly hate him if she allowed him to go out in public with that horrid look on his head.

Overall impression of the show was disappointment. I expected way more and got way less. Some nice performances in there, to be sure, but I was really hoping for some shine and fireworks.

Overall impression of the singing is David A. sang rings around the competition last night. Didn’t mean his wide-eyed, this-is-so-amazing-look-at-those-bright-lights-and-that-audience! reactions weren’t completely irritating and bogus. David. You did all of this before. Remember? I do.

Overall who I liked. Jason Castro. Really nice looks and voice. Smooth. Robbie sang well, but oh my is he ever the walking, talking poser!

Danny Noriega may be a bit too snap-snap-I’m-not-hearing-you for my liking, but I applaud how this wispy boy keeps bringing the powerhouse vocals that do NOT fit his appearance or manner. So I hope he sticks around and annoys everyone a lot.

David Hernandez and Jason Yeager. Such nice voices! Such nice boys! Bye! Bye!

Overall who kinda, or really, sucked. Luke. So sad! Such beauty! Such a nothing voice!

Colton DeGeneres. Ugh. Go!

David Cook is so strange looking I really cannot watch when he is on.

Jacuzzi. You have a sweet face and a great voice, but Simon no likee and lord knows HE can sure judge how someone looks, no?

Oh Garrett! I want your poster on my wall! You are so sweet and you look like someone could break you in half with just a mean glance! You will continue on because you were not awful on that song and….those wounded puppy eyes! That halo of 70′s fluffy hair! I want to see you again!

Lastly. I am firmly in the Michael Johns is Overrated Camp. Yes. Let’s get him to sing “Light My Fire” again, since his tepid take was so great the other times. He is hot looking and he does have charisma, but he is NOT all that.

Note: I predict ratings will drop after this week, if the girls are at least as unexciting.

Note 2: This year is, so far, WAY better than last year in my view. Not sure what that says, but there it is.

I’m in love with Jason Castro and want to have his baby. It doesn’t matter that I’m old enough to be his mother and had a hysterectomy 2 years ago. We can still try can’t we?

Did anyone besides me get an Amos Lee flashback when listening to him? I love me some Amos Lee. (But don’t want to have his baby)

C’mon now. Don’t make me be the first to say it…

Taylor Hicks rocked the house with Jailhouse Rock. What kind of fool would attempt to do an Elvis song that was done outstandingly two seasons ago.

I’m suprised the judges didn’t mention what a great job TH did with the song.

Oh wait. Not suprised.

As usual, MJ’s summary of the contestants’ performances are spot on. I also was very disturbed by Colton’s inappropriate smiling while singing “Suspicious Minds”. I thought the judges would mention that for sure. And, I also got a strong Osmond vibe off of Jason Yeager. He is lovely for nostalgia, but I don’t think he could make it on the music scene today.

Apparently, there was a flu bug floating around among the contestants. That might explain Carly’s absence.

I hate to wish her ill, but I hope she’s not on her game tonight! Go Amanda!

If Michael J’s fathead doesn’t explode first, he’ll probably make it to the finals.

Jason’s 100 year dreadlocks are a must go — cootie alert.

Too much metrosexual/ubersexual going on.

I have faith, Luke will make it another week. Let us pray.

Overall grade – C-

First of all. Has anyone addressed Simonà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s white sidewall hairdo? What is THAT?? His girlfriend must secretly hate him if she allowed him to go out in public with that horrid look on his head.

Ryan did zing him on it. I was kind of wondering if Simon had fallen asleep with his head on a hot plate and burned the hair off of one side of his head. I don’t need to see that much of Simon’s scalp.

I hope Simon doesn’t pay more than $8 for those haircuts he gets (and even that would be too much to pay for the shirt he was wearing last night)

Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m suprised the judges didnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t mention what a great job TH did with the song.

Oh wait. Not suprised.

Who? What? Never heard of the guy.

Ryan did zing him on it. I was kind of wondering if Simon had fallen asleep with his head on a hot plate and burned the hair off of one side of his head. I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t need to see that much of Simonà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s scalp.

LOL, Kirsten! I did hear Ryan’s zing, but that was WAY too mild a comment for the pure awfulness that was Simon’s haircut last night.

Hot Aussie is still hot. I’m happy about that.

Luke. Poor, dear Luke. Mute button for you from now on. It’s better that way.

Chikeze (sp) brought his ticket home. Bub-bye!

David Hernandez, if he makes it out of this week, might turn into that “improves every week” contestant, because he seems eager to please. But he ain’t gonna win. DAMN, I hate when Simon is right.

Jason Castro seems batshit crazy, but in a good way. LOL!

I’m rooting for Garret Haley. Poor kid was SO in over his head.

David A. = overpimped. He wasn’t THAT good. But he does have charisma.

I already forgot the rest of them.

I almost forgot about the Simon white walls! I initially thought Simon had really gotten a lot of gray in his hair and that was what was shining. Then I decided that he had been buzzed really, really close.

Comments about the song choices… I speculate that the short list of 50 are songs for which AI could get the recording rights (as well as the performance rights) for cheap. They want to sell those iTunes downloads, now don’t they? In which case, I will cut the kids a little slack for crappy song choices because we don’t know what all the options were.

That said, Jail House Rock = NOT a 60′s song.

The judges donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t agree with me, but I think this is a good song choice for Luke.

I agree with you, for what it’s worth. The guy may not have a knock out voice to go with his drop dead good looks, but I think it was a good choice for the light, subtle tone of his voice. I really think he got the hyjinks with the mic. It really sounded like the volume was turned way down.

I miss Josiah.

Great recap, MJ. I too hope Garrett makes it another week. Thank God at least ONE teenage boy can take criticism well.

sniff, sniff, I may have to buy Luke’s itunes download just in case he doesn’t get another chance. And for the record, I really didn’t think he sucked. I just think he doesn’t have a belter’s voice. It was pleasant enough – just a tad weak.

Ià ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢m suprised the judges didnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t mention what a great job TH did with the song.

Taylor sang it well; but he flubbed the words. He flubbed the words again on the encore. I don’t know where he got the words he was singing; but they weren’t the words of Jailhouse Rock.

I enjoyed last night. Woohoo American Idol..love this show…the good ..the bad and the ugly! My faves so far are Jason C., Robbie, David A. Michael, and David C. Since two have to go home I would like to say bye-bye to Chikieze and Danny N. or the other David.

Nola..recently listened to that video and didnt see where our ol’ Taylor boy flubbed the lyrics. At the end he did a typical rock/blues type of pause to kick in the last lines. Not quite finishing the last prev.word but that’s commonly done. Lyrics can be played with is diff than forgetting or messing them up. Usually one can tell. I dont recall the encore however. What I heard was the correct lyrics. BTW Elvis did that same kind of thing in personal performances sometimes…the fast stop then kick it in.

Connie may be gross, but he did have a performance style I enjoyed at times. I suspect David was up late à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“studyingà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  youtube videos of à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“I Think I Love Youà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬  all week. At the same time, he looked like he was trying out for the Jack Black role in a community theatre production of School of Rock. I donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t get why someone who has been in bands for so long comes across as such a desperate poser.

:lol_ee:

Spot on, Cheese!

Jasonà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s 100 year dreadlocks are a must go à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬’  cootie alert.

No, they help him stand apart from the crowd. He seems so genuine, which is part of his appeal (see above re: David Cook). If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

The judges donà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t agree with me, but I think this is a good song choice for Luke.

I agree with you, for what ità ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s worth. The guy may not have a knock out voice to go with his drop dead good looks, but I think it was a good choice for the light, subtle tone of his voice. I really think he got the hyjinks with the mic. It really sounded like the volume was turned way down.

Luke is such a sweetheart and I loved his song. I did notice mic editing for some of the guys. What’s with that?

Oh, I absolutely adored Jason Yeager! So what if he sang one of the most difficult song ever. Why even put “Moon River” on the list when there’s not much you can do with this classic ballad? I know he’s going home, but I did enjoy his performance.

Danny Noriega had the worse performance AND presentation of the night. He butchered a 1957 Elvis song. He already has a fan base, otherwise he’d be going home instead of Jason Y. and Garrett.

I LOVED the theme and hated a good portion of Simon’s comments!

hapi, here are the correct lyrics. I think our Taylor just made up the words as he went along. LOL It was a great performance, tho.

(words & music by jerry leiber – mike stoller)
The warden threw a party in the county jail.
The prison band was there and they began to wail.
The band was jumpin and the joint began to swing.
You shouldve heard those knocked out jailbirds sing.
Lets rock, everybody, lets rock.
Everybody in the whole cell block
Was dancin to the jailhouse rock.

Spider murphy played the tenor saxophone,
Little joe was blowin on the slide trombone.
The drummer boy from illinois went crash, boom, bang,
The whole rhythm section was the purple gang.
Lets rock, everybody, lets rock.
Everybody in the whole cell block
Was dancin to the jailhouse rock.

Number forty-seven said to number three:
Youre the cutest jailbird I ever did see.
I sure would be delighted with your company,
Come on and do the jailhouse rock with me.
Lets rock, everybody, lets rock.
Everybody in the whole cell block
Was dancin to the jailhouse rock.

The sad sack was a sittin on a block of stone
Way over in the corner weepin all alone.
The warden said, hey, buddy, dont you be no square.
If you cant find a partner use a wooden chair.
Lets rock, everybody, lets rock.
Everybody in the whole cell block
Was dancin to the jailhouse rock.

Shifty henry said to bugs, for heavens sake,
No ones lookin, nows our chance to make a break.
Bugsy turned to shifty and he said, nix nix,
I wanna stick around a while and get my kicks.
Lets rock, everybody, lets rock.
Everybody in the whole cell block
Was dancin to the jailhouse rock.

Grammie, I loved Luke’s song choice too. “Everybody’s Talkin’” is a favorite of mine from “Midnight Cowboy.”

There were several songs that were music themes from the movies. If my son had been a contestant, I would have asked him to find time to watch the movie. Listen, TPTB wanted to present some diversity and challenge the guys and gals. I am old; I loved the theme!

Some how I believe Danny was encouraged to do a1957 Elvis song. It was a deliberate move.

Is there a slight possiblity Jason Yeager will make it through so we can see him perform some uptempo Journey? I want more!

Luke has a lot of fans, but I don’t know if it is enough to get him through.

There is NO reason a professional should do the same song in the TOP 24 as he did in Hollywood! I expected more.