Attempting to rank the Idols this week is probably an exercise in futility. I feel pretty confident that Hollie Cavanagh will go because she has spent too many weeks in the bottom 2 this season. If two stellar performances couldn’t keep her out of the bottom last week, I can’t see how she would survive against 3 contestants who ALL had moments.
I’ve ordered Jessica, Joshua and Phillip according to how popular I think they were in the wake of their performances last night. In my mind, all 3 are bunched pretty close together at the top.
3. Phillip Phillips
4. Hollie Cavanagh
Having said all that…I think Idol continues to be unpredictable. I would not rule out a shock boot for tonight.